3 FINA Doping Control Board Members Resign to Protest Russian Decision

Three of the eight members of FINA’s Doping Control Review Board (DCRB), including Chairman Dr. Andrew Pipe, have resigned, reportedly in response to FINA’s handling of the Russian doping situation at the Rio Olympics.

Irish broadcaster RTE is reporting that the in trio’s letter of resignation to FINA president Dr. Julio Maglione, the board members said FINA disregarded the DCRB’s recommendation. According to the letter, the board unanimously agreed upon a process to assess each Russian swimmer’s Rio eligibility, but FINA bypassed the process.

“Despite the anti-doping expertise of the individuals who make up the DCRB, FINA chose to ignore our advice,” the resignation letter said.

“We learned of FINA’s decisions regarding the eligibility of Russian competitors only by observing the Olympic competition…” it continued. “We were disappointed to note that our recommendations were not followed – and even more disappointed to receive no specific response to a subsequent written request for information regarding the reasons for FINA’s decision.”

The DCRB was called upon to evaluate the eligibility of Russian competitors as requested by FINA and the IOC in response to Russia’s state-sponsored doping program unearthed by the McLaren report.

In a press release published this morning, FINA responded that the ultimate decision rested with the International Olympic Committee (IOC) and the Court for Arbitration of Sport (CAS).

“Concerning the claims expressed in their resignation letter, FINA would like to clarify that the Olympic Games are an IOC event,” the release said. “For Rio 2016, the decision on the participation of the Russian athletes has been made by the CAS and the IOC. FINA fully respected and implemented their decisions.”

However, this statement runs contrary to IOC President Thomas Bach‘s initial statement on the Russian doping decision on a conference call with world media. On the call, Bach stated that the ultimate decision would rest with the individual sports federations (FINA, in swimming’s case), helped along by an impartial arbitrator.

Meanwhile, the CAS press releases concerning the final decisions in cases like Yulia Efimova‘s cited the ultimate resolution as a joint decision among the Russian Olympic Committee, FINA, and the IOC. Given the conflicting reports, it is unclear who made the final call to allow the Russian swimmers in question to compete.

In his statement today, Maglione underscored FINA’s commitment to clean sport.

“I am sure you agree that FINA is in the forefront of the fight against doping with an important financial investment in doping control activities. FINA always coordinates with all stakeholders in the sport movement to assure that transparency and zero tolerance in the fight against doping is in place, thus protecting the clean athletes,” Maglione said.

The press release did not confirm which other two members are resigning alongside Pipe.

Leave a Reply

Notify of

oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
7 years ago

look at the names involved in this…some of the same names involved in the ticketing scandal. Patrick Hickey the President of Irish OC has been charged by the Brazilian Court & I believe they want to question this Thomas Bach? Both were involved with International OC. Hickey has been pictured living it up with Putin. Doesn’t take a Genius to figure out that something rotten is going on here. I hope someone preferably those in charge, do whats right & stop all of this injustice! It is affecting the actual hard working Athletes & their families!

ice age swimmer
7 years ago

It’s a shame that the three people with the highest moral standards are no longer on the board, but I know that they had to do what they did.

7 years ago

I looked at the pics of the 8 members & besides the fact that Andrew already looks mighty unhappy , I guessed by the names the other 2 .

I was right – ths other 2 with the Anglo names are fellow martyrs. So the little snowflakes of Canada Australia & the US have taken their bags & gone home . Thats the spirit !

The uber racial identity theme can be very efficient .I can deduce situations merely by names . I would like to request that African Americans & other slave descendants change their Anglo names . Sometimes that makes me have to think further but otherwise I can see clealy now & world politics is a cinch

7 years ago

I feel like you could have done better than that

Steven Latham
7 years ago

People need to wake up and see what is happening here.
Russia and FINA are in cahoots with each other. Russian and Putin are continuing to pay FINA to look past every single indiscretion.

Morozov – several positive drug tests – Hidden
Efimova – has tested positive several times, still allowed to compete
Russia on the cusp of being banned entirely from
Rio – gets allowed to compete (surprise surprise)

I take my hat off the the Paralympic committee that banned russia entirely

All Russian athletes should have been banned from all international competition for the next year.

FINA continues to prove how useless they are and continue to prove they are all about… Read more »

Reply to  Steven Latham
7 years ago

If I remember correctly, Morozov has never tested positive, his tests were just replaced, which could be in fact due to Russia taking a preventative measure in the mass coverup they took apart of. Not saying he dopes or doesnt. So I would not jump to conclusions.
Also, Risolvato was not allowed to compete because he had competed for the US and then did not establish residency for over a year. (Seems like that was his fault).
I feel for Arkady though. Really wanted to see him at Rio.

About Hannah Hecht

Hannah Hecht

Hannah Hecht grew up in Kansas and spent most of her childhood trying to convince coaches to let her swim backstroke in freestyle sets. She took her passion to Morningside College in Sioux City, Iowa and swam at NAIA Nationals all four years. After graduating in 2015, she moved to …

Read More »