Ranking the 2018 Men’s NCAA Recruiting Classes: #5-8

See also:

We’re continuing on with our rankings of the top recruiting classes in the men’s NCAA- these swimmers will be starting their freshman seasons in the next month.

Here are a few important notes on our rankings:

  • The ranking numbers listed for individual recruits are from our Class of 2018 Re-Rank, which was done this past spring. Certainly some of those ranks would change after this summer’s season.
  • Like most of our rankings, these placements are subjective.  Rankings are based on a number of factors, including prospect’s incoming times, team needs filled, prospect’s potential upside, class size, and potential relay impact. Greater weight is placed on known success in short course yards, so foreign swimmers are slightly devalued because of their inexperience in SCY.
  • Transfers are included, and there are lots of big ones.
  • For the full list of the 1200+ committed athletes, click here. A big thank-you to SwimSwam’s own Anne Lepesant for compiling that index – without it, rankings like these would be far less comprehensive.

Here are the 8th-through-5th-ranked Men’s NCAA Swimming & Diving classes, with the top 8 to follow later this week:

#8: California Golden Bears

Top-tier additions: #1 Reece Whitley (PA – breast/IM), Christopher Jhong (CA – IM)
The rest: Daniel O’Connell (CA – fly), Kyle Millis (WA – back), Galen Penvenne (CA – free)

It’s a very small class for the returning NCAA runners-up, but there’s an argument they could be ranked even higher for nabbing the #1 recruit in the class. Reece Whitley has a chance to be one of the greatest breaststrokers in NCAA history, coming in with the fastest breaststroke times of any high schooler we’ve ever ranked. 51.1 and 1:51.4 would have both placed top-3 at NCAAs last year, and Whitley could be both a multi-time NCAA champ and a major difference-maker on the breaststroke leg of medley relays. Far from a one-stroke specialist, Whitley is also the best 200 IMer in the class (1:43.55) and there are some who suspect Whitley could ultimately develop more into an IM type than a true breaststroker. (It’s too easy to forget he’s 3:44.7 in the 400 IM and has the ability and training background to chew up yardage in those tough races).

Christopher Jhong is another very good IM prospect, bringing in times of 1:45.5 and 3:49.0 in the IM events. He’s also a very good butterflyer (48.3/1:47.2) and should be a productive prospect for the Bears.

The rest of the class has upside based on Cal’s track records in their events. Millis is a backstroker (48.2/1:45.2) who has a ways to go, but does join a program that churned out Jacob Pebley, then Ryan Murphy, then Daniel Carr and Bryce Mefford. O’Connell’s 47.7 100 fly is intriguing, especially given he’s only been swimming year-round for a handful of seasons. He was just 51.7 in the spring of 2016, 49.9 a year later and 47.7 this spring, so the trajectory is awfully exciting. Penvenne is a pretty good three-distance freestyler (20.5/44.8/1:38.2) who could develop into a relay piece down the line.

#7: Virginia Tech H2Okies

Top-tier additions: Hugo Gonzalez (Auburn transfer – IM/back), Keith Myburgh (VA – IM/breast), Blake Manoff (VA – fly/free), Antani Ivanov (Bulgaria – fly)
The rest: Brennen Doss (VA – distance), Dylan Eichberg (VA – breast/fly), Henry Claesson (IL – free/fly), Justin Rich (Ohio State transfer – free), Ethan Apisa (Old Dominion transfer – distance), Noah Zawadzki (NC – diving), Alex Wright (WA – back/distance), Ben Hicks (MD – IM/back)

Virginia Tech gets a boost from a massive transfer: SEC champion Hugo GonzalezThe second-fastest 400 IMer in college swimming last year, Gonzalez had a rough NCAA meet and wound up far underperforming his potential. But with a year of experience under his belt (and perhaps the ability to save a taper through ACCs), Gonzalez could be one of the single highest scorers at NCAAs. A 3:35.7/1:40.6 IMer, Gonzalez can also go 1:39.0 in the 200 back, 46.2 in the 100 back, 1:34.7 in the 200 free and even 1:53.9 in the 200 breast. He’s a huge addition not only to the individual H2Okie lineup, but to relays, where he adds his solid 200 free and split 42.8 in the 100 free last year.

Gonzalez has three years left, so his value isn’t even as handicapped as most upperclassmen transfers are. Virginia Tech supplements him with one of the recruiting class’s best IM prospects: home-grown product Keith Myburghwho is 1:46.6 and 3:45.8 in the IM events. Myburgh can also fill in some breaststroke (he’s been 54.4 and 1:58) and is a good 200 fly/back swimmer as well. Virginia Tech didn’t even qualify medley relays for NCAAs last year, but with Gonzalez and perhaps Myburgh building the front half, VT could be looking at huge medley improvements.

And in addition to the Gonzalez transfer, new head coach Sergio Lopez also got a high-level international recruit following him from his previous post at Auburn. Antani Ivanov is a World Junior Championships bronze medalist and Short Course World Championships team member for Bulgaria. Originally an Auburn commit, Ivanov will now join Virginia Tech, bringing a long course 200 fly time (1:55.55) that is faster than anyone in this domestic recruiting class has ever been. Ivanov has also been 52.6 in the long course 100 fly and has relay split as fast as 51.8. There’s certainly a potential timeline where Virginia Tech entirely rebuilds its medley relays with Gonzalez, Myburgh and Ivanov with massive success.

Blake Manoff is a pretty good two-distance flyer (48.1/1:45.7) who could also be in the mix for that relay spot, depending on Ivanov’s performance in short course yards.

This is a big recruiting class that also includes a handful of transfers to bolster depth. Claesson (20.4/44.8/1:37.8 free freshman) and Rich (20.4/44.2/1:38.1 free transfer) load up the sprints. Doss (15:28 freshman miler) and Apisa (15:24 transfer) add to the distance group. When you count new head coach Lopez among the additions, this should be a new-look H2Okie team that well outperforms last year’s crew.

#6: USC Trojans

Top-tier additions: #3 Alexei Sancov (CA – free), Nikola Miljenic (Indiana transfer – fly/free), Ariel Spektor (FL – IM/fly), Victor Johansson (Sweden – distance), Owen Kao (CA – distance)
The rest: Sean Ward (CA – breast), Thomas Finello (CA – sprint free)

USC has some serious outgoing talent, but they reloaded with one of the class’s best prospects in third-ranked Alexei SancovA Moldovan Olympian in 2016, Sancov was a standout at U.S. Junior Nationals this past summer and could be a three-event NCAA scorer as a college rookie. His 200 free (1:32.80) is a hair away from the best time in a loaded class in that event, and his 500 free (4:14.25) is also in NCAA scoring range. A 42.68 100 free will go a long ways in refueling some of the relays USC has holes in. Sancov is also a 47/1:44 flyer and a 1:45 IMer, so his lineup impact isn’t just limited to freestyle.

There’s also an argument to be made that Sancov is better in long course (49.0/1:47.0 in freestyle, 53.2 in fly), and that gives him a real shot to ultimately outperform the #2 recruit, who swims very similar events and currently has a slight edge in short course yards, though not in meters.

The Trojans also picked up an impact transfer: Nikola Miljenicwho was 19.4/43.2 in free and 46.4 in fly for Indiana last year. He fits into a very similar free/fly mold to Santo Condorelli and Dylan Carter, both gone to graduation.

The other big gets in the class are an international distance standout and a versatile sprinter from Florida. Victor Johansson brings big-league talent from Sweden, with a long course 1500 (15:03) and 400 (3:47.33) that project to be NCAA scoring times if they translate well to yards. He also swims down to 1:48 (long course) in the 200 free, and could be a relay factor in the 4×200. Ariel Spektor is the latest standout from the Bolles program in Florida, and could develop in any number of events. His 1:46.5 IM is probably his most intriguing event at this point, but a 47.3 fly is awfully good as well. Spektor is 44.5 in the 100 free, which should suggest some level of relay value, too.

Kao is a 15:18 miler with solid range down to the 200 (1:37.2), and should be a nice addition to the distance group. USC also brought in local products Ward (55.5/2:01 breaststroker) and Finello (44.1/20.2 free).

#5: Arizona State Sun Devils

Top-tier additions: #7 Cody Bybee (OH – fly/free), #15 Noah Henry (TX – back/fly), #18 Khalil Fonder (VA – fly/back), Jack Kucharczyk (Indiana transfer – breast), Carter Swift (Eastern Michigan transfer – free)
The rest: Elijah Warren (CO – breast), Luke Otto (Buffalo transfer – breast), Ethan Luc (OR – free), Liam Bresette (MO – free), Gage Kohner (Northwestern transfer – free), Nick Carlson (Indiana transfer – free), Eddie Michael (OH – free), Jack Edgemond (VA – fly), Jack Little (AR – distance), Jakob Icimsoy (AL – free/fly), Noah Desman (VA – free), Jackson Etter (Indiana transfer – distance free/IM), Cole Kilburn (TX – free)

This is a massive class that includes no less than six transfers and three of our top 20 prospects. It’s also a fast-rising class: when we did our original recruit ranks in the summer of 2017, only one of these prospects made our top 20, but two more joined the list on big senior campaigns.

The big three prospects are all butterfly/backstroke types, and in fact, ASU got the best 100 flyer and 100 backstroker in the entire recruiting class. #7 Cody Bybee is the best 100 flyer in the class with a 46.50. He’s also a stellar freestyler (43.7/1:34.0), which gives him massive relay value, even as a freshman. For a team that graduated its best flyer (Andrew Porter), Bybee was the absolute top target they could nab.

Noah Henrymeanwhile, is the best 100 backstroker in the class at 46.82. He’s also very good in fly (46.8) and adds a 1:44 in the 200 back. Henry is another potential free relay piece down the road, highlighted by a 1:34.9 200.

Then there’s Khalil Fonderwho has had an outstanding senior year and brings a third sub-47 fly (he’s 46.91) to the roster along with 47.4/1:45 backstroke speed. And in the same mold as the previous two, he’s fast enough in free (44.0/20.3) to be of service on relays in dual meets at the very least.

With fly and back sewn up with blue-chip prospects, coach Bob Bowman went hard after sprint freestylers and breaststrokers with the rest of his class. In total, this recruiting class has nine swimmers with 100 free bests at 44.9 or better, five swimmers with 50 free bests at 20.3 or better and six swimmers with 200 free bests at 1:36.6 or better. The free relays, only one of which scored at NCAAs last year, are in for a serious talent upgrade. Even if it takes a year or two for the class to come together, ASU should have some major relay prowess building as this class moves through the ranks.

Transfers buoyed that freestyle group a lot. Eastern Michigan import Carter Swift (19.9/43.6/1:35.4) is the best of the group, but the Sun Devils also pulled Gage Kohner (20.3/44.1) from Northwestern and Carlson (44.7/1:36.4) from Indiana. Then there are true freshmen Luc (20.3/44.4/1:36.6) and Bresette (20.7/44.2/1:36.3) also in the mix.

The breaststroke corps adds a lot of 100 speed, with the certainty that they’ll have their 200-yard mettle tested in Bowman’s grueling training program. Again, Indiana transfer Jack Kucharczyk (54.4/1:56.2) is the most accomplished and well-rounded at this point. But true freshman Warren and Buffalo transfer Otto have both been 54-mid, though neither has yet broken two minutes in the 200.

In This Story

27
Leave a Reply

Subscribe
Notify of

27 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Sun Devil Swim Fan
4 years ago

Great class coming in/already in! It’s only going to get better!

LOOZING CONTROL
4 years ago

You forgot Matthew Kint as one of the transfers from Indiana to Arizona State

Superfan
4 years ago

The best ranking of the recruiting classes is after the season or after their career is over!

2 Cents
Reply to  Superfan
4 years ago

Hindsight is 20/20 ??!?!? Now that’s a bold statement there.

Jiimbo
4 years ago

The number of kids that commit to ASU without finishing their 4 years is concerning IMO. Anyone else?

longseeker
Reply to  Jiimbo
4 years ago

Thank you JIMBO for posting the comment about ASU, and I might add Indiana as it appears to me that both schools and maybe a few others have had so many departures and transfers that I can’t keep up with what is happening. Are some of these swimmers some how being pushed out? I am a Cal fan who will wait until all the schools list their rosters. I wonder if these mass transfers get out of hand will there be a “sitting period” like football/basketball ?

Realitycheck
Reply to  Jiimbo
4 years ago

Seriously IU has one junior left from a clas of 12+

Breastroke is the best stroke
Reply to  Realitycheck
4 years ago

Welcome to College swimming? This happens everywhere, swimming is not an easy sport and people are in college the reality is this happens all the time

Jiimbo
Reply to  Breastroke is the best stroke
4 years ago

Not trying to come out being arrogant saying that you’re wrong… but you’re wrong. This is not a situation everywhere. Yes a few here and there but that’s not the scenario here. Both ASU and Indiana are bringing in over 15 new guys for a single class. There’s no reason why half of these kids who commit to schools like ASU and Indiana should not be finishing college where they started. If I were a parent of a kid who was looking here it would definitely be a red flag

Sportfan
Reply to  Jiimbo
4 years ago

I’d be more concerned with a coaching staff that cant remember the relay order on the international stage…and a team where the transfer/cut rate is consistently high!

aaalong
Reply to  Jiimbo
4 years ago

Cant get past ASU President Crowe letting Bowman stay after his bold statement to the media. Was he just blowing smoke or has no backbone. Makes ASU admin look weak and not trustworthy.

Nojoke
4 years ago

Still waiting to see if Bob Bowman survives his outing and inappropriate text messages. It’s hard to imagine ASU can afford to excuse him. He has coached the greatest of all time. There is an argument to be made that Michael had an innate talent and would have been successful anywhere. Love Bob as Boomer’s grandpa, but he has failed to produced another successful swimmer besides MP. Yes, ASU is improving, but that is because the swimmer were promised MP. Has BB produced a great, hard-working swimmer besides MP. Kalisz is clearly but under the tutelage of the Georgia head coach. It is time to clean up the sport, and rid itself of swimmer hanging on past their prime,

Cole
Reply to  Nojoke
4 years ago

Are you completely forgetting about Allison Schmitt???

eagleswim
Reply to  Cole
4 years ago

or chase

Realitycheck
Reply to  Nojoke
4 years ago

Or the over 50 swimmers who may swim elsewhere but still train their summers w Bob at the OTC

WeHeartReeceWhitley
4 years ago

reece whitley is a GOD

anonymoose
Reply to  WeHeartReeceWhitley
4 years ago

* is good

Karin
4 years ago

You forgot Galen Penvenne at Cal

Karin O
Reply to  Karin
4 years ago

Thank you for adding Galen in there!

Joe
4 years ago

Can’t wait to see what classes are higher. These classes are stacked!!!!!

JP input is too short
Reply to  Joe
4 years ago

Gotta be Texas, Stanford, Florida and – thanks partly to Zach Apple transfer – Indiana.

catch22
Reply to  JP input is too short
4 years ago

That was my guess too.. putting them in order 1. Texas, 1A. Florida, 3. Stanford, 4. Indiana

JP input is too short
Reply to  catch22
4 years ago

I am saying this before I look at the 1-4 rankings, I promise!

I think 1) Texas, 2) Florida, 3) Indiana, 4) Stanford.

That Florida class at first to me looked not as great, but I think that was just because of what they are replacing. On an absolute basis they’re awesome. I think Stanford’s class is exactly what they need to get to the next level, but Indiana’s is better just because of the certainty of Apple’s 3 scoring swims and relay anchors. Levant and Roy are awesome, but Levant’s events are pretty stacked and Roy is still more or less a one trick pony.

Now let’s see if I was right or not 😛

About Jared Anderson

Jared Anderson

Jared Anderson swam for nearly twenty years. Then, Jared Anderson stopped swimming and started writing about swimming. He's not sick of swimming yet. Swimming might be sick of him, though. Jared was a YMCA and high school swimmer in northern Minnesota, and spent his college years swimming breaststroke and occasionally pretending …

Read More »