Shouts From The Stands: NCAA Swimming Should Be a Spring Sport For 2020-21

SwimSwam welcomes reader submissions about all topics aquatic, and if it’s well-written and well-thought, we might just post it under our “Shouts from the Stands” series. We don’t necessarily endorse the content of the Shouts from the Stands posts, and the opinions remain those of their authors. If you have thoughts to share, please send [email protected]

This “Shouts from the Stands” submission comes from Ben Delia, the head swimming coach for Franklin & Marshall College.

Uncertainty rules the roost in 2020. COVID-19 forced the cancellation of the 2020 NCAA Championships for Divisions I and III, and it forced the mid-meet cancellation in Division II. Looking ahead to the 2021 championships, there is still a great deal that we don’t know about what schools, conferences, and the NCAA may allow. While many colleges and universities are poised to attempt a return to in-person, on-campus learning this fall, the fate of athletics is hanging in the balance, especially for non-revenue generating sports like swimming.

Swimming is characterized as a winter sport within the NCAA, with a season approximately corresponding to the short course season. This puts most conference championships and NCAA Championships in the mid-February to late-March time frame. A traditional NCAA season features dual meets in the fall, invitationals around Thanksgiving, training trips in December and January, followed by a resumption of dual meets and then championships in January through March.

Why consider moving swimming to spring sport status for 2021?

The normal travel schedule that takes place during the fall semester of an NCAA swimming season presents an untenable situation in the current Covid-19 era, with too much student-athlete movement from September through the winter flu season. Leaving out the possibility of a second wave, with the resurgence of the first wave, current travel plans are being curtailed for the fall. More schools and conferences are likely to limit or suspend non-essential travel.

Additionally, many colleges and universities are implementing condensed academic semesters with longer than normal break periods in between the fall and spring terms. Few college teams would consider holding their athletes on campus through the entirety of the holiday seasons, so any normal winter season would require coaches and athletes to seek permission from administrators to come and go from campus (possibly several times) during the holiday period when most universities will be seeking to clear out their residents. Doing so would be costly at a time when schools face budget crunches, and would also actively work against the Covid-19 spread mitigation efforts being implemented by administrations. On top of this, the NCAA has already implemented a step by step process for resocialization in sport in this era, which would need to be observed following any resumption from a break.

The rapid escalation of cases around the country creates the reality that campuses that do open in the fall will almost certainly see Covid-19 cases in their student populations. In addition to the obvious safety benefits from forgoing competition during a period of heightened risk, planning now for a spring season avoids the near certainty of cancelling scheduled fall competitions, and can provide for a well thought out and planned spring 2021 competitive phase.

What would a spring season look like?

A normal NCAA swimming season allows for a 144-day official season length for Division I and Division II institutions from start through the conference championships. DI and DII can also begin pre-season workouts on the first day of classes for the academic year. The Division III winter season allows for 19 weeks of official practice leading up to the conference championships. In all divisions, the period between conference meets and the NCAA Championships does not count toward the season length caps.

For this hypothetical exercise, I use a template that contemplates teams returning to campus for the official season phase on January 18th, conference championship meets the week of April 22nd-25th, and NCAA Championships May 19th-22nd. Individual conference schedules typically vary depending on exact championship dates, and from a regional scheduling perspective, it is likely that conference meets would be held across several weekends in mid-April depending on pool availability. At the end of the NCAA Championships qualifying period on April 25th, we then allow for 3.5 weeks to the beginning of NCAA’s, which is the standard length of time from the end of the qualifying period to the beginning of the championships.

For the overall season structure, all three divisions would be allowed to practice only during the fall semester. The entire semester could be the pre-season period for Division I and II, while Division III would be limited to 5-weeks of allowable practicing based on the season outline above. 

Season Phase Division I Division II Division III
Fall Pre-Season On campus practice only – full semester On campus practice only – full semester On campus practice only – 5 weeks
Spring Season Jan. 18 – Apr. 25 (98 days) Jan. 18 – Apr. 25 (98 days) Jan. 18 – Apr. 25 (14 weeks)
NCAA Champs Postseason Apr. 26 – May 22 (4 weeks) Apr. 26 – May 22 (4 weeks) Apr. 26 – May 22 (4 weeks)

Parting Shots

I realize that a spring season may not be ideal for all student-athletes, with coaches and athletes preparing for Olympic Trials in June 2021 having to make tough decisions on whether to compete at a May NCAA Championships. The truth is that those with true Olympic aspirations will be making these decisions whether NCAA’s are held in March or May, and at the end of the day coaches and athletes in this position will choose what is best for their athletes on a case by case basis.

Taking an overall viewpoint, the risks outweigh the benefits when considering intercollegiate competition for fall 2020. We have already seen this in the fall cancellation announcements of several prominent conferences and schools across multiple NCAA divisions. Will January be better than September for the start of the season? The truth is we don’t know, but it is becoming increasingly clear that a September start is not a responsible option. If we want to save our seasons for our teams and athletes, now is the time to take bold action, delay the season start, and plan for a spring 2021 NCAA swimming season.

68
Leave a Reply

24 Comment threads
44 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
40 Comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Hambo

I disagree with every word of this article.

Pez

Theres no way teams will be able to compete in the fall with way its looking, what would you propose then?

Irish Ringer

Agree, at this point I would take a full season in the Spring.

Susan

So what is your bright idea?

frug

Even “roost”?

Swim mom

Yes, not everyone has to follow Harvard

Coach

This is something I’ve thought a lot about. Overall, I think it would be the best move. The Trials/Olympics issue is a tough one and could be very significant not only for U.S. athletes with a June Trials, but international athletes with a trials meet in early Spring. In the end, there is no perfect solution and as mentioned, athletes that are focused on Trials will have to be making tough decisions this year anyway. The fact is, for most collegiate swimmers, the college season is their main focus. A very small percentage have a Trials cuts and a small percentage of those have any type of shot at doing anything more than getting the experience of competing at Trials.… Read more »

Trey

Wow. Coach you really put some thought into this and I am buying every word of it. Not great choices, but I really like the idea of Spring.

Dive Mom

I think your idea makes much more sense than beginning the season this Fall. And as for Olympic trials, there’s no guarantee that the trials or the Olympics will still happen even next Summer.

Swim Fan

There are no perfect answers here, it’s a reasonable proposal to the situation college swimming is in for this temporary time period. Most college teams are not even allowed to use their own facilities right now, and it probably won’t change anytime soon.