Oleksiak vs. Manuel II

We’re in for a treat next week.  The Arena Pro Swim Series stops in Atlanta and the second night features a heavyweight tilt in the women’s 100m free between Simone Manuel and Penny Oleksiak.  The Rematch if you will.   In every sport these types of matchups never go as we imagine.  In baseball the most anticipated pitching duals often turn into early inning blowouts and in our sport we see headscratchers at every meet.  It’s especially so this time of year.

Manuel v. Oleksiak II is an early in-season gift which will give all of us who love this sport a chance to remember what those two accomplished last August, late into the night, on a cold and drizzly night in Brazil.   Heading into Rio, Australia was a powerhouse in this event featuring with 5 swimmers in the top 10 and 12 of the top 14 swims overall.  When the swimmers marched out everyone who understands this sport even a little bit predicted Australia taking gold and silver.  The realistic battle would be for bronze.  Sarah Sjostrom or Ranomi Kromowidjojo?  I picked Kromo reckoning a double gold medalist would be hard to topple but I didn’t feel that strongly one way or the other.  There, 1-4 taken care of.

I figured 5 and 6 would be between the two Americans who were seeded fairly close together.  Both Abbey and Simone took a year off from school to train for this but as I saw it, the women’s 100 free was one of America’s weaker events.  The smart play would have been to pick Weitzel for 5th but Manuel has an eerie calmness to her coupled with an I-got-this look to her face.  I wrestled with this for a while and decided on Manuel.  I didn’t feel confident about it though.

Oh look there’s Penny! Fantastic achievement for Penny Oleksiak, a Canadian teenager, getting into this final and rubbing elbows in the ready and room breathing the same rarefied air as swimming royalty.  This will undoubtedly be a great experience for her and hopefully she’ll be able draw on it four years from now.  I watched the walkout and was hoping she’d beat Ottesen and not come in last.  I wasn’t confident about this pick either.  Then the race started.  It went as most thought with one of the Campbells hitting the 50 wall first under world record pace and the other one not too far behind.  Simone was right there in a medal position and Penny was way back.  4th, 5th and 6th were bunched together.

We all know what happened.  Inexplicably both Australians ran out of gas and Simone reeled them in.  I still don’t know how to process what Oleksiak did on her last 50 overtaking so many tough-to-topple swimmers and touching at the same time as Simone for a shared gold.  Oleksiak’s last 50 was, by far, the coolest thing I’ve ever seen at a swimming pool.  In an age where we structure our diets around our blood types and monitor our iron levels, Oleksiak had the same excited look at the start as a little kid does jumping into a lake off a dock with water wings.  She just might be the one who uncomplicates a sport the rest of us had taken a long time complicating.  Oleksiak could be the swimmer who can take her headphones out of her ears after detailed pre-race instructions and simplifies things into so-i-just-swim-there-and-back……and-beat-these-7-people.  Right?

We get a chance to relive it next week in Atlanta.   American networks won’t break away from their basketball playoff coverage to show it live and with hockey playoffs going on it won’t get any mainstream media attention in Canada, but Simone and Penny racing one another will be a special treat for people like us.  Don’t even try predicting a winner.

In This Story

Leave a Reply

11 Comment threads
13 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
17 Comment authors
newest oldest most voted

Very interesting article. Didn’t realize the matchup was going to happen again.


Penny doesn’t seem to swim nearly as consistently fast in season as the other top sprinters, compared to for example Cate who casually swim 52s in season or Sarah with her multiple 56s low. Penny seem to be a big match performer if Rio is a definitive indication of what’s to come.

We will see how she manages pressure and expectations this time around.

Manuel is a seasoned and experienced racer.

My money is on Sarah, though.


Considering Penny is only 16 and has just recently become an elite swimmer, I don’t think she has enough history behind her to say that she is as fast in season as the other top sprinters. it also sounds like she is not training as much this year compared to last year, and she also has had her shoulder injury at the beginning of this year. It sounds like her coach and parents pay attention to burn-out, and since she already has her medals from Rio, she doesn’t have to prove anything. But I also think Sarah is the favorite based on performances this year, with Ikee and Manuel also being strong contenders for the podium along with Penny. Not… Read more »


I may have exaggerated a bit on the “not swimming as consistently fast as the other top sprinters”, as my two examples: Cate and Sarah may be the exception. As for being 16, Cate and Sarah broke swam records and unbelievable times when they were 14-15-16-17.. in season. Go check their history: Cate swam 50-100 free US open records in 2008 Santa Clara while still 15 turning 16 which went unbroken until Sarah broke them last year, she also defeated handily the newly minted 50 free World champion, in season, in 2007 Japan Open, while being just a couple months older from 14 yo. In 2010, Sarah swam the fastest ever textile 100 free, at 17 yo, in December!. Just… Read more »


Penny also started swimming at a later age than most competitive swimmers. She only first joined a club at either 11 or 12. To develop into a world class swimmer in 4 years is amazing. As much as she swam 52.7 three times at the Olympics in the 100m freestyle (the first being her split in the 4x100m freestyle relay and the second being 52.72 in the semi-final), you’re right that she’s a little inconstant. Despite swimming 51.44 in the 4×100 freestyle and 51.07 in the 4×100 medley (freestyle split) in the short course championships, she only did 52.01 individually. She also swam the butterfly slower in the medley relay in Rio than she did individually when relays are usually… Read more »


You misread and misunderstood what I said:

Penny is not yet as “consistently fast IN SEASON” as the other great sprinters; Cate, Sarah, Ranomi.

Rio was NOT in season, Rio WAS THE CHAMPIONSHIP.

Canadian Swimmer

Very fun article! Hopefully the rematch is just as exciting as the original! Although that would be hard to top!

About Kierra Smith

Kierra Smith

Kierra Smith Kierra Smith is a Canadian breaststroke specialist and NCAA champion. Born Feb. 1, 1994 in Vancouver, Smith was a student-athlete at the University of Minnesota and was the 2015 200-yard breaststroke NCAA Champion with the third fastest 200 breaststroke time in NCAA history. University of Minnesota 2012-2013 As a freshman Smith made …

Read More »

Want to take your swimfandom to the next level?

Subscribe to SwimSwam Magazine!