SwimSwam’s Official Ballot for the 2024 Golden Goggles Awards

The 2024 Golden Goggles Awards are heading to the Indianapolis Marriott Downtown, just footsteps from Lucas Oil Stadium that played host to the U.S. Olympic Swimming Trials in June, home to the largest crowds that swimming has ever seen, at least in the modern era.

The city will now welcome back the sport’s best, this time trading their suits and goggles for different kinds of suits and other fashionable eveningwear as the governing body for international swimming in the U.S. decides its best of the year.

  • Vote for your choices here. It’s unclear how these votes weigh, if at all, and the results of the fan vote haven’t been public in recent years.

As you work through your picks, below is SwimSwam’s official ballot of who we think should win each award. Keep in mind that USA Swimming chooses the nominees and award winners based almost exclusively on the results of the year’s primary long course meet – in this case the Olympic Games.

While we recognize that this meet should be weighed heavily, we put a little more emphasis on the rest of the results of the season.

2024 Golden Goggle Awards Nominees – SwimSwam Official Ballot

BREAKOUT PERFORMER
This award is given to the athlete whose performance(s) stand out in relation to other years, with special emphasis on the 2024 Olympic Games.

This one seems pretty clear cut to me. Three of these swimmers were on the 2023 World Championship roster. Gretchen Walsh even won a medal at those World Championships in the 50 fly.

Aaron Shackell entered 2024 with a best of 3:47.00 in the 400 free. His sister was the best-known of the three Shackell siblings coming into the summer, but Aaron broke through in a huge way at the Olympic Trials, not just making the team but winning the 400 free in Indianapolis, close to his home town of Carmel.

It came in a rocky year too, one where he started at Cal before returning to Carmel to make his final preparations for the Games.

At the Olympics, he swam 3:45.45 to make the final as well, ultimately finishing 8th.

My guess is that the award will go to Walsh because of her World Record, but I think the amplitude of Shackell’s breakout should be the winner.

I thought Emma Weber or Paige Madden could have been valid nominees as well. I might have chosen Madden if she were an option, though USA Swimming put her in the Perseverance category instead (probably because of her age).

COACH OF THE YEAR

This award is given to the coach whose athlete(s) performed at the highest level throughout the year, with special emphasis on the 2024 Olympic Games.

This is always such a tricky award. I think it’s clear that Bob Bowman had the best year among American coaches. He’ll probably win our Swammy award in December. But his biggest successes were with a French swimmer Leon Marchand, a Hungarian swimmer Hubert Kos, and his college team Arizona State.

But I think you could justify him taking this award even if you ignore that. Regan Smith had 5 medals (2 gold, 3 silver); Simone Manuel had a big bounceback year to make the Olympic Team; and along with his top assistant (and now replacement at Arizona State) Herbie Behm, they put a bunch of swimmers on the American team too.

If we whittle it down to just work with American athletes, I think all four nominees have an equally-strong case. What Greg Meehan to bring Torri Huske from a disappointing meet last year to arguably the best performer for Team USA, top to bottom, in Paris was masterful. Anthony Nesty leading Ledecky to more golds and Bobby Finke to the World Record was the boost that the U.S. needed to salvage a tough meet. Todd DeSorbo loaded up the women’s Olympic Team, including 200 IM champion Kate Douglass, and one of the big surprises of the meet: putting Emma Weber on the Olympic Team.

If I had to limit the choice to just American swimmers, it’s tough but I think I’d go… DeSorbo. While Meehan with Huske was the best single athlete coaching performance of the year, what DeSorbo did with a breadth of women, plus the NCAA title, that’s the edge for me.

Also, no Dave Durden nomination is an anomaly, but a justified one, for one of America’s most consistent coaches on the international stage over the last decade.

FEMALE ATHLETE OF THE YEAR 

This award is given to the top female swimmer of the year with special emphasis on achievements at the 2024 Olympic Games.

This is another one that comes down to a value judgement, what you think is most important. Torri Huske‘s performance was the one that the U.S. needed the most, especially with what she did on the relays. Katie Ledecky‘s continued excellence, winning two individual gold medals and being resilient to some of the biggest challenges she’s had in a while shouldn’t be underappreciated just because she’s done it so many times.

Some will completely discount Huske’s medal performances, but I don’t think that’s fair. She was the crucial leg on a number of relays for Team USA. She held off China in the mixed 400 medley relay and outsplit Australian star Mollie O’Callaghan. The U.S. was never going to catch Australia in the 400 free relay, but her 52.06 there was the difference versus China for silver. Huske beat the newly-minted World Record breaker Gretchen Walsh in the 100 fly final.

I think Huske’s swims just meant more, but I’m willing to accept the counter argument.

FEMALE RACE OF THE YEAR 

This award is given to the female swimmer with the greatest single individual race of the year, with special emphasis on the 2024 Olympic Games.

Another tough one. All three great swims (I presume all are referencing the Olympic finals).

Huske beat the World Record holder (Walsh), the only of the three who can claim that. Ledecky broke the Olympic Record, the only of the three who can claim that. Douglass was the only of the three who swam a lifetime best at the Olympics.

I’m going to knock out Douglass because the world’s best in that event, Evgeniia Chikunova, wasn’t at the Olympics. I think the nature of Huske’s win was most impressive, so I’ll make her my choice again.

Ledecky probably wins at least one of the above two awards, and Huske probably wins the other. I suspect Ledecky will win Swimmer and Huske will win Race of the Year.

FRAN CRIPPEN OPEN WATER SWIMMER OF THE YEAR 

This award is given to the athlete who had the most outstanding year as an open water swimmer, with an emphasis on the 2024 Olympic Games.

Grimes was 15th at the Olympics, Denigan was 16th, and Puskovitch was 19th, so all three were in a pretty similar position. It’s kind of a coin toss, and I assume the award will go to Grimes because she was the best finisher at the Olympics, so I’ll make her my choice too.

MALE ATHLETE OF THE YEAR
This award is given to the top male swimmer of the year with special emphasis on achievements at the 2024 Olympic Games.

This feels like a slam dunk. The gold medalist, the World Record breaker, Bobby Finke winning his second Male Athlete of the Year Award (2022).

MALE RACE OF THE YEAR 

This award is given to the male swimmer with the greatest single individual race of the year, with special emphasis on the 2024 Olympic Games.

Loved that Luke Hobson swim, but once again, I think this choice is pretty obvious. The only individual men’s gold medal, saving the mood of the meet for the Americans and helping with a final day topping of the medals table: Bobby Finke.

If he wins, he would become the second swimmer to win this award four straight years, joining Michael Phelps from 2006-2009. Katie Ledecky also won the women’s award for four consecutive years from 2012-2015.

PERSEVERANCE AWARD

This award is given to the athlete who came back from adversity, retirement, sickness, injury, etc., to have an outstanding performance(s) in 2024, with special emphasis on the 2024 Olympic Games.

Normally I kind of hate this award, because it’s so hard to peg down what they mean by “perseverance,” but this year, I think there are two athletes who absolutely deserve it.

Caeleb Dressel found his way back to Team USA after the famous breakdown at the 2022 World Championships that forced him to leave that meet early, and won three relay medals (gold, gold, silver).

Simone Manuel dealt with overtraining syndrome in 2021, and also found her way back to Team USA this summer, winning a pair of silver relay medals.

Both swimmers were once the stars of Team USA. Neither swimmer was particularly close to an individual medal.

Ultimately, Dressel had the better finishes at the Olympics, (6th in the 50 free, three medals), so that’s my tie breaker.

RELAY PERFORMANCE OF THE YEAR 

This award is given to the best team relay performance, male or female. The performance considered must be a finals performance, with special emphasis on the 2024 Olympic Games.
  • Men’s 4x100m freestyle relay
  • Mixed 4x100m medley relay
  • Women’s 4x100m medley relay (SwimSwam’s Pick)

All three great relay performances, all three gold medals, but let’s zero in on the women’s 400 medley and mixed 400 medley, which also broke World Records.

The mixed medley was the better race in that a gutsy anchor from Torri Huske pulled out a very tight win for Team USA, but I think the women’s medley relay, with all four swimmers firing and winning by three and a half seconds in the Olympic final, is the best performance. That one really highlighted a spot where Team USA was really good, as a group, in a meet where there not many spots to flash that quality.

In This Story

21
Leave a Reply

Subscribe
Notify of

21 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Anonymous
1 month ago

Ledecky not getting picked for Female Athlete is like Derek Maas not getting picked for D3 Swimmer of the Year. Pan not getting picked Swim of the Olympics.

Sarah Sjöström’s Cats
1 month ago

Kate Douglass’ 200BR deserves more love as the sole American record swim and therefore best performance by an American by at least one pretty important metric.

Like yes Torri swam a great 1fly but saying Kate doesn’t deserve it because Chikunova wasn’t there is a bit weak. Sarah Sjostrom and Summer Mcintosh didn’t swim the 1fly or 800fr either…but ultimately does it really matter?

Just Keep Swimming
Reply to  Sarah Sjöström’s Cats
1 month ago

This logic does not follow. Chikunova is the world record holder and is the clear best 200 breaststroker in the world the last few years. The only reason she is not the Olympic champion is because of politics that are completely outside of her control.

Sjostrom hasn’t swam a time faster than Huske’s winning time since 2017 and she chose not to swim it. McIntosh has never been faster than Ledecky’s winning time and she chose not to swim it.

Chikunova’s situation isn’t even slightly comparable.

Sarah Sjöström’s Cats
Reply to  Just Keep Swimming
1 month ago

My point is that treating Douglass’ swim like a silver medal because Chikunova would have been guaranteed champion is overstating things. You swim against the competitors who are there on the day, not the imaginary ur-competitor who isn’t, and plenty of champions on paper fail to live up to the moment anyway at such a taxing and unpredictable meet (Peaty 100br, Qin 200br).

You can always add “what ifs” to great swims but I don’t think it’s useful for saying whether or not Douglass had the best race.

It’s still an American record…the other swims aren’t.

Also, turns out Summer in the 800 isn’t relevant anyway bc it’s the 1500 that’s nominated sooo lol

Viking Steve
1 month ago

Is Swimswam trolling us by not picking Walsh as the breakout swimmer?!

Besides Finke…. easily the most obvious choice.

NY FAN
Reply to  Viking Steve
1 month ago

Gretchen is a complete no-brainer for the breakout swimmer award. She made massive jumps this year.

RealSlimThomas
1 month ago

I genuinely hope Bowman is only judged off the performances of his US athletes. I don’t think Marchand’s or Kos’ success should factor into an American award. The success of Madden and Smith alone might earn him the award.

I personally like Nesty for the award. He’s coaching the two best US athletes right now in Ledecky and Finke.

chickenlamp
1 month ago

huh, I wasn’t expecting my picks to be that different from SwimSwam’s ballot.
Breakout: I voted for Walsh and didn’t consider anyone else. There wasn’t any true rookies who won an individual gold medal, or even an individual medal. Even though Walsh was at WC last year, she had a massive leap forward in long course this year.
Female Athlete/Female Race: I agree that Ledecky and Huske probably split these awards, and I’m happy with either getting Female Athlete. But I really disagree with the implication that Ledecky will get an award solely due to being a big name or for marketing purposes. Her accomplishments in Paris are absolutely worthy of either of these awards. Her 9th career… Read more »

MY MOM!
1 month ago

I wonder if a relay lead-off can be considered for ROTY. If so, Smith’s 100 BK OR to set up a WR in the final race of the meet should be up for consideration.

I miss the ISL (Go dawgs)
1 month ago

Paige should be perseverance. Dressel and Manuel both had bad meets in Paris, Paige had the best meet of her life, and was the only one of the 3 to win an individual medal. However, Dressel or Manuel will probably win because of popularity. It’s kind of shocking you didn’t even mention her in your analysis for the award.

Jonathan
1 month ago

I’d give the Perseverance Award to Paige Madden.

Outside of his fly split in the men’s medley relay final, Dressel wasn’t special in Paris.

I still can’t believe Paige Madden went 8:13.00 in the 800 free final. Worthy of recognition.

About Braden Keith

Braden Keith

Braden Keith is the Editor-in-Chief and a co-founder/co-owner of SwimSwam.com. He first got his feet wet by building The Swimmers' Circle beginning in January 2010, and now comes to SwimSwam to use that experience and help build a new leader in the sport of swimming. Aside from his life on the InterWet, …

Read More »