2017 Swammy Awards: Top 10 Races of 2017

To see all of our 2017 Swammy Awards presented by TYR, click here. 

2017 SWAMMY AWARDS: Top 10 Races of 2017

Counting down the top 10 swims of the year is always an exercise in priorities. While we could simply count off each world record set this year, we always elect for a less boring option. Every swim comes in its own set of circumstances, and some objectively slower swims are more memorable. Of course this list is completely subjective, but we think it’s a good sampling of the significant swims from the year that was.

#10: Zane Grothe‘s Monster Mile

Maybe there’s some recency bias on this one. And sure, maybe it’s in a course where times are hard to understand for a large portion of the world. But it’s the fastest swim in history (14:18.25) in the sport’s longest event, coming from an ascending swimmer who is actually going up in training volume as he gets older. For any swimmer who has stayed in the sport long enough to feel “old,” that’s awfully inspiring.

#9: Sarah Sjostrom‘s World Record Foray Into Freestyle

In a year of anticipation for the August World Championships, with so many predictions made, scrapped and rewritten, the first hypothetical world-record swim to be realized holds extra meaning. That came on day 1 of the meet, courtesy of the world’s leading butterflyer branching out into freestyle. Sjostrom has always been a great freestyler, but she clearly put a major emphasis on the stroke in 2017, breaking two world records. Sjostrom’s 51.71 leadoff on the Swedish 4×100 free relay was an exciting way to kick off Worlds.

#8: Adam Peaty‘s Barrier-Breaking 25.9

The race wasn’t close, and that’s what makes it so impressive. Not only is Peaty one of just a handful of men to ever break 27 seconds, he’s the first ever under 26. He leads the rest of history by half a second and won World Champs gold by a similar margin. The sheer weight of breaking the 26-second barrier adds a lot of notoriety to Peaty’s mind-bending swim.

#8: Adam Peaty‘s Barrier-Breaking 25.9

The race wasn’t close, and that’s what makes it so impressive. Not only is Peaty one of just a handful of men to ever break 27 seconds, he’s the first ever under 26. He leads the rest of history by half a second and won World Champs gold by a similar margin. The sheer weight of breaking the 26-second barrier adds a lot of notoriety to Peaty’s mind-bending swim.

#7: Masse Makes Canadian & World History In 100 Back

Kylie Masse‘s 100 back is historic in two major arenas. Not only did her 58.10 take down the longest-standing world record on the women’s side (a relic from the super-suit era), it also stood up as the first-ever World Championships gold medal for a Canadian woman in swimming. The swim represents the huge leap forward taken by Canada over the past few years as well as evidence of Masse’s own massive personal development into a world-leading backstroker.

#6: Dressel’s Round 40.00

Jumping back into the yards pool for a bit, we check off Caeleb Dressel‘s most iconic swim, at least in terms of the finish time. A year of wondering whether Dressel could break 18.0 or 40.0 wound up with Dressel hitting the latter on the nose in the final individual swim of his banner NCAA Championship meet. That time is the fastest in history by .76 seconds and makes him one of only four men ever to break 41 seconds. It also foreshadowed Dressel’s massive breakout summer (which may make an appearance later in this list).

#5: Manuel Does It Again In 100 Free

For the second summer in a row, Simone Manuel took down a world record-holder to win the year’s biggest gold medal in the 100 freestyle. In 2016 it was Cate Campbell, and in 2017 it was Sarah Sjostrom. Though her lifetime-best is still well slower than both of those two, Manuel has proven two summers straight that she’s the most clutch at getting her hand on the wall in the biggest moment. Can it still be called an upset when it’s the defending Olympic champ winning Worlds? Hard to say. But Manuel keeps proving there’s no reason to count her out, no matter how long the odds appear.

#4: Comerford Ties Ledecky In 200 Free

Probably the race of women’s NCAAs, the 200 freestyle signaled the rise of Team USA’s feel-good breakout swimmer, Mallory ComerfordThis entry on the list truly epitomizes the “race” of the year – it was one of the most exciting, unpredictable swims of the year, with the hotshot upstart Comerford taking on the clutch Manuel and the legendary Ledecky, and ended in a dead tie between Comerford and Ledecky at 1:40.36.

#4: Comerford Ties Ledecky In 200 Free

Probably the race of women’s NCAAs, the 200 freestyle signaled the rise of Team USA’s feel-good breakout swimmer, Mallory ComerfordThis entry on the list truly epitomizes the “race” of the year – it was one of the most exciting, unpredictable swims of the year, with the hotshot upstart Comerford taking on the clutch Manuel and the legendary Ledecky, and ended in a dead tie between Comerford and Ledecky at 1:40.36.

#3: Caeleb Dressel‘s Textile Best 100 Fly

Caeleb Dressel put up a whole bunch of swims at the World Championships that could be on this list, but his 49.86 in the 100 fly has to be the best. The swim gets a boost for breaking a seldom-traversed barrier, as well as for winning a World title in an event where he didn’t even qualify for the Olympics one year earlier. Dressel’s time is the fastest textile swim in history (discounting the super-suit times from the 2009 era) and is just .04 off the best swim in history, done by a super-suited Michael Phelps.

 

#2: Federica Pellegrini‘s Walk-Off In World Champs 200 Free

Not only was Federica Pellegrini‘s win in the 200 free a big upset over a swimmer widely-considered the best female swimmer in the world (if not in history), Pellegrini’s touchout of Katie Ledecky also capped off a historic 200 freestyle career that will go down in history as one of the most successful. Pellegrini has now won a medal at the past 7 World Championships in the 200 free, including gold in 2009, 2011 and 2017. If we are to take Pellegrini at her word, it’ll be her last one, too. Pellegrini retired from the event at the World level on the spot, making her upset win a true walk-off.

#1: 1650 Free, Men’s NCAA Championships

Our #1 swim is the truest representation of the word “race.” For the second year in a row, the mile at men’s NCAA was the biggest showstopper of the meet. With a field made up of Olympians, international sensations and young challengers, the lead was in flux much of the way, and when the dust settled, four men had swum the fastest 1650 freestyles in history, headed by Clark Smith‘s 14:22.41. Sure, his record was later demolished by Grothe (see #10), but a distance race like this, where 4 guys battle to the last 5 yards, comes around once in a generation. Savor it.

There isn’t much to say that the race itself can’t tell even better, so do yourself a favor and watch it below. It won’t be 15 minutes you regret spending:

 

#2: Federica Pellegrini‘s Walk-Off In World Champs 200 Free

Not only was Federica Pellegrini‘s win in the 200 free a big upset over a swimmer widely-considered the best female swimmer in the world (if not in history), Pellegrini’s touchout of Katie Ledecky also capped off a historic 200 freestyle career that will go down in history as one of the most successful. Pellegrini has now won a medal at the past 7 World Championships in the 200 free, including gold in 2009, 2011 and 2017. If we are to take Pellegrini at her word, it’ll be her last one, too. Pellegrini retired from the event at the World level on the spot, making her upset win a true walk-off.

#1: 1650 Free, Men’s NCAA Championships

Our #1 swim is the truest representation of the word “race.” For the second year in a row, the mile at men’s NCAA was the biggest showstopper of the meet. With a field made up of Olympians, international sensations and young challengers, the lead was in flux much of the way, and when the dust settled, four men had swum the fastest 1650 freestyles in history, headed by Clark Smith‘s 14:22.41. Sure, his record was later demolished by Grothe (see #10), but a distance race like this, where 4 guys battle to the last 5 yards, comes around once in a generation. Savor it.

There isn’t much to say that the race itself can’t tell even better, so do yourself a favor and watch it below. It won’t be 15 minutes you regret spending:

In This Story

45
Leave a Reply

Subscribe
Notify of
45 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Dee
3 years ago

Where is the women’s 50FR… All medallists under 24s was a stunner. Fastest race in history wasn’t it?

Such a stacked year when that race misses out!

bobo gigi
3 years ago

Jared, here’s a race video of Peaty’s 25.95 in semis at world championships.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TT1SR7FpbRc

bobo gigi
Reply to  bobo gigi
3 years ago
Sir Swimsalot
Reply to  bobo gigi
3 years ago

Thanks! I’ve been looking for these.

Torchbearer
3 years ago

An odd bunch of races- many not Olympic distance, yards, minor US events….maybe it was an odd year.
I would throw in C Campbell’s 100 SC world record then- a swimmer resting for a year, smashes SS newly minted WR just when her times seemed untouchable.

Dee
Reply to  Torchbearer
3 years ago

Odd for non-US site users yes, but as an American site I think you have to expect a skew to yards given the prominence it is given over there. My only caveat with yard swims being included is that in some events (like SCM), you don’t really know how soft records are as not many top-tier Australian/Asian/Europeans have ever competed yards.

Pvdh
Reply to  Dee
3 years ago

The only ones I would consider soft are mends mid/long distance freestyle

Tammy Touchpad Error
Reply to  Pvdh
3 years ago

Men’s IM. We all know Phlocte were on another level and never competed SCY at peak. Certainly 1:38 low/ 1:37+ and 3:29 no problem.

Pvdh
Reply to  Tammy Touchpad Error
3 years ago

I don’t think I 400im is soft. Kalisz is pretty close to the textile WR. Phelps is also probably 4:05 without the suit. 200im maybe, but maybe Dressel swims that and gets to 1:38 low at SECs.

Dee
Reply to  Pvdh
3 years ago

I agree – 400im is not soft looking at all.

Tammy Touchpad Error
Reply to  Pvdh
3 years ago

I don’t agree at all. Chase was not in 4:05 shape for NCAAs. Was he even a 1:40 in the IM? 1:55 shape he was at in worlds and he wouldve been 1:39 low even with being a better LC swimmer considered. I think his 3:33 is at best a 4:07. He was 4:06.9 at Nationals looking better overall than he did at NCs no question.

Look at guys like Seliskar or some of the Florida guys from the past 5-6 years. You really think they are capable of a sub 4:10 Long Course?? No way. Conor Dwyer was also within 4 seconds of Chase’s time. Not a sub 4:10er either and he proved he could do LC. Even… Read more »

OldWahooVA
Reply to  Dee
3 years ago

Same could be said for SCM records/swims as many top swimmers have never competed SCM when fully tapered and shaved (Phelps, Dressel, Ledecky, Murphy just to name a few). Its a shame the NCAA doesn’t go back to the practice tried in 2000 of hold the NCAA meet in SCM in olympic years.

Dee
Reply to  OldWahooVA
3 years ago

Indeed, I did say like SCM ha

Tea rex
Reply to  OldWahooVA
3 years ago

That never really made sense, ncaas in SCM. Still very very different from LCM, but different enough from yards to make adjust their timing on the turns/finish, or duff their race.

Big10 Boyz
3 years ago

Grevers comeback swim and the King/Efimova rematch would be on my list. Great top pick, that 1650 at NCAAs was incredible.

Sir Swimsalot
Reply to  Big10 Boyz
3 years ago

I’m a huge fan of Murphy, and I hope he demolishes it this year, but Inwas so happy to see Grevers on top again. He deserves it.

Rafael
3 years ago

I would put the men and women 50 free and men 4×200

Lpman
3 years ago

I would put Dressel’s 49.8 fly at #1. Even though he did not break MPs tech suit world record, it is a strong indicator of what is possible in Tokyo

Pvdh
3 years ago

I’d go with women’s 100 free I’m Budapest. Most people here just thought it was a foregone conclusion that sjostrom would win.

Philip
Reply to  Pvdh
3 years ago

Manuel never gets any respect.

Dee
Reply to  Philip
3 years ago

I wouldn’t go that far, I think everybody respects her, but she isn’t on the circuit smashing records week to week, so she kind of goes under the radar.

She reminds me of the 400m runner Christine Ohuruogu – Didn’t get many plaudits because she never ran super fast outside of the time it actually mattered. There were always faster runners, but because she always ran her best time when it mattered, she ended her career a dual world champion, and Olympic Champion.

Pvdh
Reply to  Dee
3 years ago

Actually, age wise, I don’t think anyone was sub 24 and 52.2 at 20 like Simone. She will definitely. Challenge WRs by Tokyo

Dee
Reply to  Pvdh
3 years ago

I think it was identical to Cate Campbell – She is 4 years (Scary – Only 4 years older… I remember her being a medal fave in Beijing!!) older than Simone and won 2013 Worlds in 52.3 (Simone 52.2 in 2017)… Was also 23.9 at the age of 17 before she was ravaged by injuries.

My point was also about circuit consistency though – We all know Manuel is super fast, but she doesn’t tend to swim super fast outside of Worlds/Trials, whereas with Sjostrom or Campbell, you could get a random WR at a zonal meet in February haha.

Ervin
Reply to  Pvdh
3 years ago

Frankly what American is on “the circuit”

Dee
Reply to  Ervin
3 years ago

How many times has Manuel swam sub 53, and at what meets, Ervin? Ever gone 52. on the US GP circuit? Has she ever gone 52. at USNats? Answer to all, as you know, is no.

That isn’t a negative, it’s just the kind of swimmer she is – Some benefit from a taper more than others, and she is one of them.

Ervin
Reply to  Dee
3 years ago

Who cares Dee!

Dee
Reply to  Ervin
3 years ago

I don’t know, but you took disagreement with something I said, so I substantiated with the numbers to support my point.

Ervin
Reply to  Dee
3 years ago

You used numbers to support something i didnt say.

KeithM
Reply to  Dee
3 years ago

Some benefit more from tapers typically because of different training philosophies. Some swimmers don’t do extensive yardage and swim fast every time they hit the water; you could debate whether they even ever do a proper taper. You only have to look at results of the US Grand Prix meets over the years to see which approach predominates in the US. Hoff used to swim fast in season but often didn’t seem to improve much or find that edge come the big meet.

Dee
Reply to  KeithM
3 years ago

Thank you, that was exactly my point!

KeithM
Reply to  Dee
3 years ago

Yeah I was just expanding on your point. Just to say that it’s not usually the taper in and of itself, but that it’s reflective of the training…usually. You can gauge most swimmers based on this and their history. We know Peaty will drop a lot but Hannah Miley will typically drop a proportionally smaller amount. Then there are swimmers than confuse you…like James Guy. Sometimes he’s fast in season, sometimes he isn’t that fast. Discount him because of slow times and he’ll surprise you. Get too excited because he posts fast times and then he posts modest results. You don’t know what to expect from him race to race in the same meet let alone over the course of… Read more »

ben
Reply to  Pvdh
3 years ago

Not to mention it was overall the fastest women’s 100m freestyle final in history. (Only 2 swimmers didn’t go under 53 seconds)

Carlo
3 years ago

Yes that NCAA 1650 yard free was actually a “RACE” from start to finish. Never seen anything like it in a long distance race. Best RACE of 2018 by a mile. I doubt we will see any long distance RACE like it again where like 4/ 5 swimmers are in it till the last 100 meters.

notice the difference between RACE and SWIM?

Best SWIM?

Probably dressel textile best in the 100 fly or sjostrom,s 100 free world record. But I would say sjostrom,s swim was stronger.

Carlo
Reply to  Carlo
3 years ago

Best race of 2017 typo

Human Ambition
Reply to  Carlo
3 years ago

RACING is the euphoria we have in every open water race.

About Jared Anderson

Jared Anderson

Jared Anderson swam for nearly twenty years. Then, Jared Anderson stopped swimming and started writing about swimming. He's not sick of swimming yet. Swimming might be sick of him, though. Jared was a YMCA and high school swimmer in northern Minnesota, and spent his college years swimming breaststroke and occasionally pretending …

Read More »