2013 US Trials Previews: Ledecky Improving, Can She Make a Run at Franklin?

The American women won the 800 free relay at the 2012 Summer Olympics with some ease over the Australians, but with that Aussie relay being very deep, and seeming very focused, it’s far from a runaway for the 2013 World Championship. That makes this American qualifying for relay spots much more important than it might have been last year.

The Americans will still probably have the best 800 free relay foursome in finals on paper; they certainly have the best two-some in the world with Olympic Champion Allison Schmitt and Missy Franklin.

Dana Vollmer has flipped back-and-forth on this 200 free over the last few years. In 2012, she came in 3rd at Trials, but hasn’t raced the event since her Olympic relay swim, and isn’t entered in the event at this year’s Trials. 

Katie Ledecky, with some serious newfound speed (she was 1:56.93 in Mesa), looks like the only one who could seriously knock off Schmitt or Franklin for the individual spots, especially with the race coming at the beginning of the meet’s second day, meaning that nobody should be too fatigued just yet. Ledecky will have the toughest schedule coming in, with the 800 to contend with on day 1, but regardless, her speed seems to be the key to the Americans holding on to gold in Barcelona without Vollmer.

After those top three, though, the other three potential spots for a relay become very interesting (remember that with roster limits and 50 meter stroke selections this year, top 6 in the freestyles are far from guaranteed to go to Worlds).

Vollmer, even without swimming the race this year at all, is still plenty good enough to show up at Trials cold turkey and stick a top-6 swim in the event. Aside from her, the other three Olympic swimmers, Lauren Perdue, Shannon Vreeland, and Alyssa Anderson were all fairly young. Anderson is done swimming, as she’s moved to Atlanta and taken a job for Coca-Cola.

Vreeland and Perdue finished their collegiate seasons in March with opposite performances. Perdue’s only individual scoring swim at NCAA’s was a 10th-place finish in the 200 free. Vreeland had a very good close, coming up 4th, and dropped almost a second from her finals swim the year prior as a sophomore.

Perdue had elbow surgery this week to fix a torn tendom, so she’s out for Trials.

The challengers have grown exponentially this year. Aside from Ledecky, who will almost surely have herself a relay spot at least, there’s two familiar names who are swimming much better. Megan Romano is training with Allison Schmitt and Bob Bowman at NBAC, which can only help her in this race. She’s been 2:01.0 as recently as Santa Clara, which is a good but not great time, but she should have been on this relay last year were it not for a stumble in finals (she was 4th in a 1:57.99 coming out of semis).

Liz Pelton, a former NBAC swimmer now training at Cal, didn’t swim this race at Trials last year, but swam a lifetime best at Santa Clara in 1:58.52 – the first time she’d gone a lifetime best in the event in years.

There’s a ton of youth in this race as well. Terrapins Swim Team’s Chelsea Chenault swam at Junior Pan Pacs and swam very well for a 1:58.19 – better than she was at Trials, and a time that would’ve made the Olympic Team if done in Omaha. Stanford-bound Lia Neal has been 1:58.26, which also would’ve made the Olympic Team if she’d done it in 2012 (though she was already on the roster in the 100).

The latest big-time newcomer, and another under the time for an Olympic relay, is Quinn Carrozza, who at the Senior Circuit meet in College Station, Texas two weeks ago was a 1:58.36 at just 16 years old. Her best event is probably still the 200 back, but this 200 free might be her most immediate opportunity for Worlds.

So, moral of the story, it’s going to take a better time to make Barcelona than it did to make London. Even if all 6 are invited, I’d guess no slower than 1:57.9 makes the relay.

Texas A&M’s Sarah Henry, like Perdue, didn’t have a great end to her 2012-2013 college season, but like Perdue she knows she swam very well last summer when coming off of an injury.

Texas’ Karlee Bispo was a great 200 freestyler in college, but in long course seems to be developing more into a 200 IM’er. Still, with a best of 1:59.0, she’s in the hunt. She’s been a 2:02.5 as a best so far in 2013.

There’s a few other 1:58’s to be considered, including Leah Smith of the Jewish Community Center, though her best chances are probably in the slightly longer 400 and 800 meter distances; and as goes Jasmine Tosky’s meet, as goes her potential in this 200 free, as she’ll have to do better overall than a few flat championship performances in the last year if she wants to get into this final and have a chance. Catherine Breed is coming off a much more recent, though similar, injury to Sarah Henry’s, but is still entered in the meet.

Top 8 picks are below, including best times from January 1, 2010 onward.

 

Braden’s Picks Morgan’s Picks Matt & Reed’s Picks
1. Allison Schmitt, Georgia/NBAC, 1:53.61 Allison Schmitt, Georgia/NBAC, 1:53.61 Allison Schmitt, Georgia/NBAC, 1:53.61
2. Missy Franklin, Colorado Stars, 1:55.06 Missy Franklin, Colorado Stars, 1:55.06 Missy Franklin, Colorado Stars, 1:55.06
3. Katie Ledecky, NCAP, 1:56.93 Katie Ledecky, NCAP, 1:56.93 Megan Romano, Georgia/NBAC, 1:57.54
4. Megan Romano, Georgia/NBAC, 1:57.54 Liz Pelton, Cal, 1:58.52 Katie Ledecky, NCAP, 1:56.93
5. Shannon Vreeland, Georgia, 1:57.78 Megan Romano, Georgia/NBAC, 1:57.54 Shannon Vreeland, Georgia, 1:57.78
6. Liz Pelton, Cal, 1:58.52 Shannon Vreeland, Georgia, 1:57.78 Chelsea Chenault, Terrapins Swim Team, 1:58.19
7. Sarah Henry, Texas A&M, 1:58.55 Chelsea Chenault, Terrapins Swim Team, 1:58.19 Liz Pelton, Cal, 1:58.52
8. Chelsea Chenault, Terrapins Swim Team, 1:58.19 Lindsay Gendron, Tennessee, 2:00.02 Jasmine Tosky, Stanford, 1:58.54
Darkhorse Darkhorse Darkhorse
Quinn Carrozza, Longhorn Aquatics, 1:58.36 Quinn Carrozza, Longhorn Aquatics, 1:58.36 Becca Mann, Clearwater, 2:00.28

In This Story

22
Leave a Reply

Subscribe
Notify of

22 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
rowrowrowtheboat
11 years ago

Um. Schmitt is a FULL 2 SEONDS faster than Missy and almost 3.5 faster than Katie. That’s a huge gap to close. Schmitt first – Missy 2nd.

bobo gigi
Reply to  rowrowrowtheboat
11 years ago

Yes, but only on paper. Last year she was amazing and has swum one of the greatest races of all-time in the London final. But since London she has shown she wasn’t in the same shape. She was in 1.54 in June last year before the trials. This year she’s in 1.58. If she swims 1.54 next week I will be the first to be surprised.

Aswimmer
Reply to  bobo gigi
11 years ago

Yes. And this years top 5 times for each:

Schmitt-1:58, 1:58, 1:59, 2:01 (only swum 4 times this season)
Missy-1:56, 1:57, 1:58, 1:58, 1:59
Ledecky-1:56, 1:58, 1:59, 2:00, 2:00

My predictions:
Missy – 1:54.6, Ledecky – 1:54.8, Schmitt – 1:55.0

Swim Jargon
Reply to  Aswimmer
11 years ago

i do like the list of top times of this year for each swimmer. what i don’t think is fair to compare is the top times. if you take away the pair of 1:56s from the franklin & ledecky race they had someone pushing them. schmitt didn’t necessarily have anyone in her races to fight to beat..

Swim Jargon
Reply to  Swim Jargon
11 years ago

take that away and there’s an even playing field. do not rule schmitt out – remember she is training with romano, kalisz, the chinese, dwyer etc etc

Ella
Reply to  bobo gigi
11 years ago

It’s tricky to compare Schmitt’s times this year with last year. Last year she was solely training long course and for the Olympics, this year, she’s been in school and focusing more on college swimming and short course. It’s just a different situation entirely. It’s fair to expect that her times this year are slower than last year. I still have faith in Schmitt to get one of the top two spots.

bobo gigi
Reply to  Ella
11 years ago

You’re perhaps right on that. And I don’t say she will not qualify. I just say I would be very surprised to see her in 1.54 or better this year. Recognize that her overall level of shape is in question. Take the short course world championships last December for example. She won the 200 free but in 1.53.59, a modest time for her in SCM. And in the 400 free she was eliminated in the heats with an awful (for her) 4.05.98. Take the NCAA championships. She won the 200 free but she was disappointing in the 500 free. Again, I don’t say she will not qualify. I just say she doesn’t look this year like the unbeatable swimmer she… Read more »

KeithM
Reply to  bobo gigi
11 years ago

Under Bauerle, Schmitt typically swam slow in season times which changed last year when she trained with Bowman for the entire year.

whoknows
11 years ago

I go with Ledecky and one other newbie… yet to be determined!

Ma'am
Reply to  whoknows
11 years ago

Carrozza

whoknows
Reply to  Ma'am
11 years ago

Good Possibility

bobo gigi
11 years ago

I wouldn’t be surprised to see Miss Ledecky with the win but I repeat that 200/400/800/1500/4X200 in Barcelona would be too much for her. Would it be the same schedule as Sun Yang?

Philip Johnson
Reply to  bobo gigi
11 years ago

She should not swim the non-Olympic 1500. Maybe in a couple of years she will be ready for that schedule, but swimming the 1500 will impede on her chances on breaking the 800 WR. The 1500 is a day after the 400. The 200 free prelims and semis (is she swims it) is on the same day as the 1500 final. That would be tough.

Philip Johnson
Reply to  Philip Johnson
11 years ago

Whereas Yang has the following scedule:
Day 1: 400 heats and final
Day 2: 200 free heats and semis
Day 3: 800 free heats and 200 free final
Day 4: 800 final
Day 6: 800 relay
Day 7: 1500 heats
Day 8: 1500 final

The female version:
Day 1: 400 heats and final
Day 2: 1500 heats
Day 3: 200 free heats and semis & 1500 final
Day 4: 200 free final
Day 5: 800 relay
Day 6: 800 heats
Day 7: 800 final

the female version of that schedule is a lot harder! no breaks and seven consecutive days of swimming.

beachmouse
Reply to  Philip Johnson
11 years ago

There is only the men’s 100 back final between the W 1500M finals and W 200 Free semifinals in Spain. And as good as teenage girls are often at quick turnarounds, I’d call those two races and ‘impossible double’ under the old USAS lingo. Seems like we’ve had a few indications that Ledecky is planning on the 1500 M that day (why else would she have bothered to get an updated FINA A time during Grand Prix season) and is entered in the 200 free only for relay purposes.

I actually wouldn’t be surprised to see her turn in a fast 200 free prelims time in Indy and scratch afterwards, provided she’s already on the team from an earlier… Read more »

Reply to  beachmouse
11 years ago

The women side is really harded.. and for make it easier for Yang he won´t have such a harsh competition with Agnel out ( Unless some guy step up of course ) compared to Ledecky..

aswimfan
Reply to  beachmouse
11 years ago

Yang will also not have competition in the 400 as Tae-hwan is not competing and Fraser-Holmes DQed in the AUS trials.

Philip Johnson
11 years ago

Can Ledecky make a run for Franklin? Absolutely. She has beaten her once this year and she’s going to continually drop time. I predict Ledecky will get the the second spot. At this time, I’m not sure if it will be behind Franklin or Schmitt.

Mesa?
11 years ago

Anybody watch the 200 at Mesa? Ledecky will not be out with the leaders, but she will be rolling like a freight train that back half.

bobo gigi
Reply to  Mesa?
11 years ago

Here’s the race from Mesa.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K41sKtJ1L_A

SwimFanFinland
Reply to  Mesa?
11 years ago

Haha, I’m sure Ledecky would be very happy to earn the nickname “freight train” owing to her cast-iron back half :).

swimcoach24
11 years ago

One would think with Ledecky’s distance background shes not going to have the speed to go out with Schmitt and Franklin, however I wouldnt be surprised if shes winning at 100 Meters. If thats the case, its game over. Ledecky is fearless while racing. If she goes 1:55 mid to low, would anyone doubt she wont go out to her 400 in an 1:57? Sub 4?

As much as Schmitt is awesome, this season I cant see her going 1:53 or 1:54. Should be a dogfight in Indy!

About Braden Keith

Braden Keith

Braden Keith is the Editor-in-Chief and a co-founder/co-owner of SwimSwam.com. He first got his feet wet by building The Swimmers' Circle beginning in January 2010, and now comes to SwimSwam to use that experience and help build a new leader in the sport of swimming. Aside from his life on the InterWet, …

Read More »