The FINA doping panel hearing for Brazilian sprinter Gabriel Santos will be held on July 19th at 2PM in Gwangju, South Korea. Santos was flagged in June for a positive test for the banned substance Clostebol. That hearing, which comes 2 days before the start of the pool swimming competition, will determine, among other things, whether or not Santos will be eligible to race at the World Championships.
Without Santos, then Andre Calvelo will likely take his spot on the finals men’s 400 free relay. Brazil were the silver medalists in that race in 2017, and Calvelo was .21 seconds slower (48.74 vs. 48.53) at the Maria Lenk Trophy.
Santos’ primary defense has been that the substance was present in a topical ointment used on a new tattoo, or that it absorbed after contact with his girlfriend, who also used the substance on a tattoo. Clostebol is, in fact, a common ingredient in topical medication used to treat inflammation and itching caused by a number of skin conditions, including tattoos.
Santos swam on Brazil’s 400 free relay at the 2016 Olympic Games, the 2017 World Championships, and the 2018 Pan Pacific Swimming Championships. That includes winning gold at Pan Pacs and silver at the World Championships.
He also swam in the 100 free individually for Brazil at the World Championships in 2017, placing 14th.
He was selected as part of the 2019 Brazilian roster to compete at both the Pan American Games in Lima, Peru and the World Championships in Gwangju, South Korea. The swimming portion of the World Championships begin on July 21st, and the swimming portion of the Pan American Games starts on August 6th.
Santos, who hails from São Paulo, was administered an out-of-competition doping test on May 20th in his home city, which came back testing positive for Clostebol. The substance is considered a weak anabolic androgenic steroid on its own, but was used as one ingredient of oral turinabol, a staple of the East German state-sponsored doping program back in the 1970s and 1980s. It’s the same substance that another Brazilian sprinter, Henrique Rodrigues, tested positive for in 2017.
Rodrigues was ultimately suspended for 1 year retroactive to the date of the test.
On the same day that the positive test was revealed, Santos was announced as a member of the DC Trident in the International Swimming League (ISL). Shortly thereafter, he was suspended by the league, pending the outcome of the hearing. For anything other than full dismissal, Santos would face a total ban from the ISL, which has enacted a zero-tolerance policy for doping violations. While the league has not publicly described the details of that policy, thus far they have applied it to even violations that were later ruled to be from tainted supplements or accidental ingestion.
Cheaters should be banned for life!
The proposed one-year suspension indicates that the FINA panel accepted that he didn’t voluntarily take any illegal substance. Unfortunately it was a case of involuntary cross-contamination as it had happened before to Henrique Barbosa. I am sorry fpr Gabriel, who will miss the Tokyo Olympic Games and the 2010 FINA World Chanpionship, but the ruling was fair. I would not call him a cheater though unless proven otherwise.
What could possibly be his “I’m innocent” argument here? This isn’t something you can “accidentally eat”.
From what I read, he claims the Clostebol came from an after-shave cream (or something like that) which his brother shared with him. I know it is a far-fetched version, but, as I wrote above, the one-year ban indicates that the FINA panel accepted that it was a case of involuntary cross-contamination. Otherwise, he would probably have been suspended for 4 years or so.
I don’t know about the case but I don’t agree with holding a hearing two days before to squeeze him in to the WCs.
I’d rather have a system where a swimmer gets a fair shot to prove their innocence and earn the right to compete than one where a potentially innocent swimmer* has to miss the biggest meet of the year and have all their work go to waste. If his excuse isn’t good enough (it won’t be), then he won’t compete. Even in situations where almost all fault was placed elsewhere, the swimmers still get at least a three month suspension (Toussaint being the only recent exception I remember).
* I don’t think the swimmer in question is innocent, but no matter who it is, I would want them to have the chance to make their argument beforehand.
If he actually used Clobetasol as an ointment then he should be fine, it’s just a strong topical steroid that helps with skin conditions. If he took it with some other medicine orally then that might be a problem.
If the ointment was contaminated then it’s difficult to argue that he’s a cheater. If clobetasol is one of the ingredients listed in the ointment, then I really don’t see why there’s an appeal. As professional athletes you’re responsible for what goes into your body. You read the labels and you check online, and if it contains a banned substance you don’t use it. It’s not that hard. While he might not be using it with the intention of doping, the fact would remain in that scenario that he should have been more careful. Some of the recent appeals/reprieves are really blurring the lines. Strict liability seems quite a lot less strict than before.
Name that doper:
“I never took no stereos!”
Pro tip: don’t dope and uhhh you won’t have to worry about getting caught doping ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Besides Gabriel Santos, Henrique Rodrigues, Henrique Barbosa Nicholas Santos, Vinicius Waked, Etiene Medeiros, Glauber Silva, Diego Prado, Cesar Cielo, and Leonardo Sumida are other Brazilian swimmers who tested positive for PEDS. Brazil, get your act together and stop cheating.You too Russia and China. Watch Icarus.
You know etiene was a case of tue right?
Your Brazil list goes back 8 years, to 2011 when Waked, Santos, Cielo, and Barbosa all tested positive after using the same supplement.
Here’s the US list that I could find for doping violations, dating back just 3 years:
Grace Ariola
Jack Casey
Ryan Lochte
Amanda Kendall
Matthew Willenbring
Mike Alexandrov
Sam Tierney
The excuse of Waked, Santos, Barbosa, and Cielo essentially mirrored that of Cox (and Hardy). Kendall’s excuse was the same as Medeiros’ (prescribed by a doctor, just an error in TUE paperwork).
Thanks for laying it out this way. It really highlights how dirty American swimming is.
Good point but I’m sure the Americans have a larger sample size of tested swimmers. So statistically the Americans should have more.
Gatorchomp’s list was only for the past 3 years, so I’m sure if you extended it back 8 years to match the initial list given by Scribble, it’d be much longer. I’ll let someone else do the number-crunching to figure out doping violations per 10,000 swimmers or whatever, but my hunch is that America is in no position to claim the moral high ground over Brazil.
Um, except America catches and hands out severe suspensions to dopers. Gatlin missed 4 years of his prime (track). Cox was proven innocent and still had to serve a suspension. Brazil back in 2011 just gave Cielo and Santos a slap on the wrist. America did have sketchy antidoping enforcement and the turn on the millennium, but we have moved on and the USOC is nowhere near as corrupt as it was then (which isn’t saying much lol). Also look at the profile of swimmers catch doping. Brazil had Cielo, probably there most prolific and famous swimmer ever, test positive in his prime. China had Sun, the face of Chinese swimming, at the center multiple suspicious incidents with doping. Russia… Read more »
Sure there are American cheats too, but some individuals make bad decisions vs a cultural acceptance of PED use. China, Russia, and Brazil have long histories of Performance Enhancing Drugs in Swimming. And no doubt American Track & Field and Tour de France bikers also have horrible histories, but only swimming concerns me. I suggest you watch the documentary Icarus or talk to trainers/athletes who use PEDS. It is incredibly disturbing how prevalent and accessible PEDS and blood doping is. Michael Phelps made a very disturbing comment how he doubted he ever swam an International Final with a level playing field. Add the complicity of the governing boards and testing agencies, you don’t have a good situation. If it wasn’t… Read more »
Ryan Lochte took intravenous vitamins that were not tainted, just too much volume, if I recall correctly. Not quite the same as hard stuff.
The beautiful American art of point fingers to our own sins… God bless
See above.
Let’s withhold judgment. Oh wait, it’s Brazil.
Racist
Brazil isn’t a race….they have many races in that country