2014 Charlotte Grand Prix: Phelps vs. Lochte, The Importance of THE Rivalry

After the swimming world got to witness one of the most exciting races lat month at the Mesa Grand Prix between Michael Phelps and Ryan Lochte, the wait for the Charlotte Grand Prix seemed like an eternity.  However, here we are on day one of the meet, where Phelps swam not one but two races, and the excitement, fun, and smiles we saw in Mesa don’t seem to be replicating.

The two races Phelps competed in this morning were supposed to be accompanied by his rival/friend/co-swimming superstar Ryan Lochte.  As we all know, Dave Marsh decided to scratch him from the meet in order to keep him as healthy as possible for the rest of the summer.  But while a swimmer’s health is a first priority, the absence of the Phelps-Lochte showdown in Charlotte seems to have taken a toll on lone superstar, Phelps.

If you look at any sport, rivalries bring out the best in every athlete.  Everyone wants to come out on top and claim bragging rights, and let’s not forget the fun in all of it.  This is the exact situation that Phelps was swimming in at the Mesa Grand Prix.  Knowing that Lochte was the first guy under 53 in prelims gave him an extra push to be right there with him; and the results proved it.  Phelps swam a sharp and controlled 52.84 that morning.  Compare that to his 53.26 touch-out by Pavel Sankovich today in Charlotte in prelims, though his coach Bob Bowman was very pleased with the result despite being a slower time.

The times are enough to prove that Phelps thrives when he has his co-star is swimming with him.  But if that wasn’t enough, the look on Phelps’ face after the race told the same story.  The smile-less and laugh-less Olympian didn’t look pleased after the swim and looked as though he couldn’t find the fun in that 53.26.

This is where the true importance of rivalries in swimming lies.  While we all know these two swimmers can put up insane times individually, it’s when they’re racing each other you get to see the fun, competitive spirit, as well as the mind-boggling times shine through.  Swimming needs its superstars. They make excitement levels go through the roof, sell out sessions, and show why swimming is one of the most exhilarating sports out there: case and point: when the entire sports world headlined Phelps’ comeback last month. However, they left a significant piece of it out: the rivalry that got renewed.

In This Story

Leave a Reply

3 Comment threads
3 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
5 Comment authors
newest oldest most voted

I believe in the power of rivalries. However, it sometimes appears that the rivalries seem to reported with a male dominance. Maybe a balance of female rivalries could be reported also.


I only like the rivalry if it stays solely in the pool. I honestly hated the clear dislike between Phelps and Lochte in 2012. Mesa was fun because they were rivals in the pool, but friends outside the pool.


Clear dislike? I don’t remember them ever doing anything nasty.

In my opinion, rivalries are great, even if the people don’t like each other much. When National team sports, world titles, Olympic medals and career legacies are on the line (not to mention hundreds of thousands of dollars) I might feel a little animosity towards someone too.

Kitajima and Hansen is a great polarizing rivalry that we remember today. Jager and Biondi was a great rivalry. As long it’s they settle it in the pool and don’t go Malice in the Palace I’m cool with it getting as heated as it gets.


I don’t know about the “dislike” part. If you know anything about Ryan, you can’t totally dislike him. You can be disappointed with his choices maybe but he’s a very likable person.

If I were Phelps I would have been annoyed with the marketing of Lochte prior to the 2012 Olympics though. As a longtime fan, I know I was embarrassed and disgusted many times.

bobo gigi

53.26 in prelims just after a 200 free so early in his comeback is a pretty good performance.
MP can’t make doubles anymore as he did before.
For tonight I predict a win but with a slower time than in Mesa. Around 52.50 would be good.
He will not have Lochte to push him.

And talking about the little rivalry with Lochte, from 2003 to 2012 Ryan Lochte has beaten Michael Phelps only 3 times in the big world meets.
200 free and 200 IM in 2011
400 IM in 2012


2011 Worlds 200 free:
1:44.44 Lochte
1:44.79 Phelps

About Christine Wixted

Hailing from the Mile High city of Denver, CO, Christine Wixted is a current senior at Duke University. Her swimming career started at the age of 12 and is soon coming to a close with only one semester of collegiate compeition left. Throughout her four years at Duke, she has …

Read More »

Don't want to miss anything?

Subscribe to our newsletter and receive our latest updates!