SwimSwam Pulse: 44% Think 200 Breast Has Biggest Disparity From SCY To LCM

SwimSwam Pulse is a recurring feature tracking and analyzing the results of our periodic A3 Performance Polls. You can cast your vote in our newest poll on the SwimSwam homepage, about halfway down the page on the right side, or you can find the poll embedded at the bottom of this post.

Our most recent poll asked SwimSwam readers which stroke 200 has the biggest change from short course to long course:

Question: Which event has the biggest difference between short course yards and long course meters?

RESULTS

  • 200 breaststroke – 44.0%
  • 200 butterfly – 21.6%
  • 200 backstroke – 18.7%
  • 200 freestyle – 15.7%

The 200 breaststroke came out on top with over 44 percent of votes, though all strokes picked up their fair share.

The results largely mirror what we saw in a similar poll from January 2020, where it was asked in general, which stroke is the most different between LC and SCY, not specific to any one distance. Breaststroke picked up 51% of the votes in that poll.

This poll narrowed in on the 200s to give each stroke a level playing field, but it remains clear that fans believe breast has the biggest difference between the two formats.

If we look at the difference between the fastest times ever swum in the long course and short course (yards) pools, the 200 stroke event with the biggest percentage change is backstroke. The men’s 200 back has a 16.9% difference from SCY to LCM, and the women’s is 15.0%.

Breaststroke sits second if we average out the two numbers, with the men’s (16.7%) and women’s (13.7%) averaging to 15.2% (to backstroke’s 15.95%).

Anyone who’s raced competitively knows the distinct difference between having seven turns and walls to work with in a SC race compared to just three in LC. While this is felt in all four strokes, no doubt, perhaps breaststroke is where one is forced to change their stroke the most (longer glide in LC, quicker tempo in SC) between the two in order to manage fatigue and execute optimally.

Underwaters play a major role in the other three events, more so back and fly than free, but the swimming itself largely remains the same.

Another thing you could look at when considering this question is which stroke consistently sees the same swimmers excel in both short course and long course. One could argue that back and fly are the most common to see someone do well in one and not the other, largely hinging on their ability in the underwaters.

The best breaststrokers (and freestylers), on the other hand, generally tend to rise to the top no matter the course, though for breaststroke specifically, it may not be an entirely fair argument because the best swimmers tend to more commonly specialize in that one stroke.

The 200 fly took second in the poll at 21.6 percent, followed by backstroke (18.7%) and then freestyle (15.7%).

Below, vote in our new A3 Performance Pollwhich asks: Which meet will be faster this summer:

In terms of times required to medal, which competition will be faster in 2022?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

legend-long-2

ABOUT A3 PERFORMANCE

A3 Performance is an independently-owned, performance swimwear company built on a passion for swimming, athletes, and athletic performance. We encourage swimmers to swim better and faster at all ages and levels, from beginners to Olympians.  Driven by a genuine leader and devoted staff that are passionate about swimming and service, A3 Performance strives to inspire and enrich the sport of swimming with innovative and impactful products that motivate swimmers to be their very best – an A3 Performer.

The A3 Performance Poll is courtesy of A3 Performance, a SwimSwam partner.

15
Leave a Reply

Subscribe
Notify of

15 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Bobo Gigi
5 months ago

I’ve responded backstroke.
It’s obviously backstroke.

Swimswamswum
Reply to  Bobo Gigi
5 months ago

Bobo Gigi has spoken!

What Bobo Gigi said must be true!

/s

THEO
Reply to  Bobo Gigi
5 months ago

Backstroke is unequivocally the right answer. See: Hunter Armstrong vs Luca Urlando.

Notanyswimmer
5 months ago

SCY needs to be done away with

Christopher DeBari
5 months ago

brutal race, LCM or SCY

IU Swammer
5 months ago

I think the best way to determine which stroke/distance is hardest to translate between short and long course would be to look at swimmers who are (or were) consistently at the top in one but not the other. We’d probably have to shift the analysis to SCM vs. LCM.

I’d also be curious to see the percent change for each hundred across a 400 IM.

dddddddd
5 months ago

50 back for LCM and SCM

Backstrokebro
5 months ago

If GB was focusing on euros and Russia was racing, I would have voted euros.

ArtVanDeLegh10
5 months ago

It’s backstroke. More than half the race SCY is spent UW. There have been countless great SCY backstrokers that are average LCM backstrokers.

Phi Swimma Fasta
Reply to  ArtVanDeLegh10
5 months ago

44% of the people are correct! Time convertor clearly shows that there is the greatest disparity in breaststroke.

IU Swammer
Reply to  Phi Swimma Fasta
5 months ago

“If we look at the difference between the fastest times ever swum in the long course and short course (yards) pools, the 200 stroke event with the biggest percentage change is backstroke. The men’s 200 back has a 16.9% difference from SCY to LCM, and the women’s is 15.0%. Breaststroke sits second if we average out the two numbers, with the men’s (16.7%) and women’s (13.7%) averaging to 15.2% (to backstroke’s 15.95%).”

This gives a much better picture than the time converter.

15m
Reply to  ArtVanDeLegh10
5 months ago

Same thing with pullouts

ArtVanDeLegh10
Reply to  15m
5 months ago

I agree but can you name more good SCY breaststrokers or backstrokers that aren’t/weren’t at the same level in LCM?

Tom Shields
Coleman Stewart
David Nolan
Dean Farris
Albert Subirats
Destin Lasco
Nick Albeiro
Adam Chaney
Brendan Burns
Hill Taylor
John Shebat
Alex Lim (Cal)
Luca Urlando
Tony Cox (Cal)
Anthony Grimm
Cindy Tran
Gretchen Walsh

I’m not sure what Kasper Stokowksi and Bjorn Seeliger’s best times are in LCM but you can probably add them to the list as well.

Admin
Reply to  ArtVanDeLegh10
5 months ago

Bjorn S – 55.8
Kacper S – 53.8

15m
Reply to  ArtVanDeLegh10
5 months ago

Honestly not arguing one way or another, and most of people you listed are just primarily underwater swimmers. I wouldn’t say that they have a hard time converting, they’re just not as good at swimming as they are underwater. However I’ve known a lot of very good long course breaststrokers that can’t figure it out scy and vice versa. They’re two different strokes, while the difference in all the other strokes is simply amount of time they can spend underwater. You can say the same thing about Dean, and Coleman’s other strokes as you can backstroke, backstroke just seems the worst because their underwater speed is the same in every stroke so it makes the biggest difference in the slowest… Read more »

About James Sutherland

James Sutherland

James swam five years at Laurentian University in Sudbury, Ontario, specializing in the 200 free, back and IM. He finished up his collegiate swimming career in 2018, graduating with a bachelor's degree in economics. In 2019 he completed his graduate degree in sports journalism. Prior to going to Laurentian, James swam …

Read More »