Shouts from the Stands: Creating a Sustainable Pro Swimming League

by SwimSwam 21

June 20th, 2018 Industry, Opinion

SwimSwam welcomes reader submissions about all topics aquatic, and if it’s well-written and well-thought, we might just post it under our “Shouts from the Stands” series. We don’t necessarily endorse the content of the Shouts from the Stands posts, and the opinions remain those of their authors. If you have thoughts to share, please send [email protected]

This “Shouts from the Stands” submission comes from Shawn King.

In Part I, 6 major issues where presented that limit professional swimming: relevancy in national and world athletics, meet organization and duration, meet scoring procedures, team construct and organization, meaningful statistics that increase athlete value, and an annual defined high performance season.  Each of these items was discussed in detail how it influences and limits the growth of professional swimming.

Here in Part II, the outline for a professional swimming league is presented, answering the 6 major issues discussed in part I.

Swimming as a sport is on the cusp of defining its long term future.  For the first time in decades, USA Swimming didn’t experience the rise in membership it usually does following an Olympic year.  For the first Olympics since 2000, Michael Phelps will not be there helping to fuel a swimming dominant story.  Collegiate programs continue to die because there is not consistent interest in the sport by fans.

The situation is dire.  Swimming as a sport can evolve.  By observing other successful professional sports and patterning a swimming league after them, swimming can rise as viable and successful professional sport.  As professional sport expands, collegiate swimming will have a model they can follow to resolve the same limiting issues within their sport.

Here in Part II, the outline for a professional swimming league is presented, answering the 6 major issues discussed in part I.

A professional swimming league:  The National Swimming League

SECTION 1. Increase Relevancy

The National Swimming League (NSL) is an association of Swimming teams following the same format as the National Football League.  The NSL provides a league format wherein teams compete in duel meets to qualify for the playoffs, and through single elimination meets, win the NSL Championship.  Teams are made up of professional swimmers under contracts with their teams.  Competitive rosters consist of 24 athletes (12 women, 12 men).  Following the lead of the NFL and MLS, swimming would have a limited number of duels with the focus being on racing to win.  Teams battle to eliminate one another and advance to the championship.  With a limited number of meets/games, each race becomes very exciting and valuable in the landscape of the teams progress throughout the season.

 

SECTION 2. Team

This inclusion of men and women in the same professional level meet is unique in professional sports and provides an excellent opportunity for growth and expansion as an all-inclusive sport.  This idea cannot be understated.  The amount of media attention that could be delivered to the sport that brings men and women together with equal opportunity to compete and provide them the opportunity to compete together for championships and receive equal press and pay, would be revolutionary in the world of sports.  This one idea has within it the power to forever change the landscape of professional sports.

To build on the combining of men and women into the same professional league, transitioning from the individual format to the team format allows teams to create deeper fan bases than an individual athlete can collect on their own.  Stars can collect together to pursue championships won in duel meets, where the emphasis is on racing and scoring, not times and gold medals.  Athletes would have a specific time of year where their performances were critical and fans could flock to the sport for the given season.

 

SECTION 3. Define Season

The NSL season would begin in mid-April, after the PGA Masters  and before the beginning of the NBA playoffs and NFL Draft.  Teams play weekly on Friday or Saturday for 13 weeks.  Each team has 12 meets with a single bye week.  The top 8 teams with the best duel meet records would be entered in the playoffs.  Single elimination duels would play to eliminate teams from 8 to 4 to 2, with the final NSL duel acting as the season championship.  The regular season and playoffs would place the championship meet about the 2nd week of August.  This summer season is critical to allow the NSL to maximize its relevance during a down time in the US Sports Cycle.  The 8 weeks following the conclusion of the NBA and NHL seasons is open and dead space until the start of the NFL season at the end of August.  All sports media agencies are searching for content during this time of the year.  Swimming could easily fill the space.  The crucial meets qualifying for the playoffs take place just as the NBA and NHL finals finish, allowing casual fans to join the league in time for the drama of making the playoffs and the start of the elimination rounds.  With only 3 weeks of elimination meets, the NSL Championship will be determined in the middle of August.  To conclude the season, the NSL draft would take place at the end of August or early September and would mark the official end of the NSL season.  The season would then finish before the start of football season.

 

Section 4. Improve Events

Based loosely on the current college duel meet event program, the NSL league meets would have 16 individual events for both women and men (32) and 4 mixed relays event meet schedule with 20 events.  A 15 minute half-time will be scheduled halfway through the meet.

This particular event schedule allows a single duel (either men or women) to be completed within an hour and a half, while a full duel (both men and women together) can be completed within 2 hours.  This is much more standard in the event length in comparison to the other major professional sports.  In single duel format, each event has a single heat with 3 athletes for individuals or 2 relays from each team entered for competition.  In the full duel format, there will remain a single heat for combined relays (2 women/2 men) and then proceed with 2 heats for each event (1 women’s heat and 1 men’s heat).

This inclusion of men and women in the same professional level meet/game is unique in professional sports and provides an excellent opportunity for growth and expansion as an all-inclusive sport.

The abbreviated times for competitions makes the events much more media and fan friendly, with opportunities for the athletes to truly showcase their ability within the given time frame.  With no limitations on events, star athletes can get more pool time and both fans and media are able to maximize their value in watching the stars. This event format also frames the athletes’ performances within a relevant scenario with a win/loss result from the meet, giving value to the overall performance.

Due to the focus on winning and losing, and not breaking time records, the league could bring back the polyurethane body suits of old.  These suits would improve the speed of the meet and also bring a unique look that would allow men and women to have a similar while supporting large team logos and sponsors.  These suits could add flair and fun to the event while allowing athletes to perform at the highest levels.

 

SECTION 5. Simplify Scoring

Athletes will not be limited in the number of events they can swim, allowing teams greater flexibility to maneuver and score points with the athletes available.  Each event is scored according to a six (6) place scoring: 6, 4, 3, 2, 1, 0.  Relays are four (4) place scoring: 12, 8, 4, 0

This scoring system, while based upon the NCAA design, is different due to the need to have closer scoring.  The NCAA system places a much higher value on 1st place finishes, which plays to top-heavy teams.  While this is important, lowering the value of the top score makes depth within the teams more valuable and will keep the scores closer, creating more compelling matchups from week to week.  This scoring is also much more simple than the 16 or 20 place scoring implemented in most of the high level championship meets held, and can be calculated quickly by most anyone watching the meet.

 

SECTION 6. Track Statistics

With no entry limit, points per game becomes a viable statistic that can help to contribute to building records and defining player value beyond specific record times.  While times will always be a part of swimming, allowing players to collect statistics such as points per game, relays swum, the number of 1st, 2nd, 3rd place finishes, etc. allows athletes to compete without the need to have a World Record time with every swim.  The development of new ways to value swimming athletes can help to increase the longevity of the careers of swimming pro athletes, while engaging audiences and fans with their favorite players.  Multiple ways of measuring value and impact improves the diversity of the sport.

 

Conclusion

Swimming is a beautiful sport.  In its simplicity, it is compelling and captivating to watch humans move gracefully through the water at speeds we can barely understand.  By learning from other successful professional sports, swimming can be molded into a thrilling professional sport that can gather followers from around the world.  The professional league format can be adapted to high school and college swimming, as well as formed into a World Cup format similar to the current soccer and basketball World Cups.

If we are willing to step outside the parameters of what swimming has been and look forward to what swimming could truly be, we find that we could build a fast, compelling sport that would be exciting and enjoyable for athletes, coaches, officials, and fans.

 

About Shawn King

Shawn King is the National Development Coach for the Southern Utah Swimming Association in St. George, UT.  Previously, Shawn worked as the Membership Director at the American Swimming Coaches Association.  Shawn has been committed to bringing elite swimming to southern Utah and has seen a Utah High School State Title and SUSA’s first Jr. National qualifier this last season.   Shawn is married and has 4 boys.

21
Leave a Reply

8 Comment threads
13 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
13 Comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Scott Johannsen

Who would own the teams?

Brutus

Who ever came up with the bucks all be team owners…money talks. Initially I agree the format should showcase only short events until the Pro Swim Series took with a larger public base. THEN add distance events. Also if the female athletes would wear bikini type swim wear that would capture a part of the male general public as sex sells also. Have INTERESTING celebrity broadcasters not a dork like Rowdy Gaines…perhaps a Phelps with a gorgeous bombshell female celebrity. The athletes would need to develop “personalities made for the event” including rivalries, vendetta and drama for the soap opera type viewers. Remember it is not about the pure sport in America, we need to be entertained and distracted SAD… Read more »

Daniel

Man, SwimSwam comment section sure hates uncomfortable truths. Have an upvote.

Ugh

fine with all that but i think bikinis would be disrespectful to the athletes… i mean who actually respects the LFL? I agree there needs to be wayyyy more personality, but no we don’t need soap opera type drama. We need more excitement, rivalries and more fun events! I say drop either the 50s of stroke or the 200s because we already have medley relays and 200s are boring. Only the 1000 for distance swimmers because Ledecky. Maybe change events each meet a little?

Michael King

Great ideas, especially about the condensed time for a meet to take place. As a parent who spent thousands of hours on deck waiting and watching for the 3 or 4 events in which my son swam, I like the idea that this format would allow you to view the entire competition in a couple of hours. Considering how much actual “playing” you see in an NFL game verses how long the program takes (huddles, timeouts, measurements, penaltie, etc. etc. etc.), this swimming format appears to have almost non-stop action for the viewer. Even in the Olympics, there is so much time spent on “between the actual swimming” stuff that it is easy for the viewer to lose attention and… Read more »

HotRod!!!

No Distance events? Hmmm… sound like sprinting is the future of USA swimming… No thank you!

Daniel

TBH unless you’re watching KL lap people and be past the WR line on TV, very few people enjoy watching the Mile. If swimming pools weren’t so damn expensive, you could have the distance events running in a separate pool at the same time like Track and Field does, but unfortunately that’ll never work.

ElvisVB

Sprinting is what people want to watch. The market decides

Don't want to miss anything?

Subscribe to our newsletter and receive our latest updates!