Scoring the Men’s D-III NCAA Championship 2015: Psych Sheet Breakdown

With Allen Weik – Denison ’14 – the NCAA 500 record holder, having graduated, this year’s 500 freestyle is up for grabs – and so are many other titles. This article has you covered for everything going into men’s NCAA Division III championships, which will be held from March 18th-21st in Shenandoah, Texas, just outside of Houston.

Using the top-16 from the psych sheet in order to prescore the events, here are the (predicted) team totals for the 2015 NCAA D-III Championships:

  1. Kenyon | 488
  2. Denison | 350
  3. Williams | 280
  4. Emory | 230
  5. MIT | 191
  6. NYU | 154
  7. Wash. U. | 154
  8. TCNJ | 152
  9. Hopkins | 134
  10. UChicago | 132
  11. Depauw | 131
  12. CMS | 116
  13. Amherst | 75
  14. Gettysburg | 98
  15. Trinity U. | 58
  16. Keene State | 51
  17. USMMA | 49
  18. Union | 38
  19. Mary Washington | 37
  20. University of Wisconsin – Stevens Point | 35
  21. Redlands | 32
  22. Whitman | 32
  23. BSC | 32
  24. Oxydental | 31
  25. Calvin | 27
  26. St. Thomas | 23
  27. Rose Hulman | 20
  28. YCP | 20
  29. Stevens | 18
  30. Whitworth | 16
  31. Coast Guard | 16
  32. Widener | 15
  33. Midd. | 15
  34. Ithaca | 15
  35. Wabash | 15
  36. Case Western | 14
  37. Conn. College | 13
  38. Pomona-Pitzer | 13
  39. Whittier | 13
  40. Hartwick | 12
  41. Rowan | 12
  42. Tufts | 12
  43. CMU | 6
  44. Bates | 2

 500 Free


  1. Ricotta | Williams – 20 points
  2. Geenhalgh | Hopkins – 17 points
  3. Conover | Kenyon – 16 points

Williams senior Thad Ricotta – who finished 11th overall in the event last year – swam a quick 4:25.93 at NESCACs this past weekend – a swim which earn him the first place seed. Hopkins sophomore Andrew Greenhalgh, however, took fourth in the 500 last year and is going into NCAAs right behind Ricotta – seeded with a 4:26.08. Additionally, sophomore Arthur Conover – of Kenyon College – placed third last year and is seeded just hundredths of a second behind Greenhalgh with a 4:26.11. With big names like no. 7 Williams, no. 1 Kenyon, no. 3 Emory, no. 2 Denison, no. 6 Hopkins, and no. 12 Keene State all having swimmers seeded in the top eight, this race could be anyone’s.

1650 Free


  1. Conover | Kenyon – 20 points
  2. Greenhalgh | Hopkins – 17 points
  3. Resman | Keene State – 16 points

The amount of time the top two athletes in this event have dropped over the course of the season since last year’s NCAAs is astounding. Conover is nearly ten seconds faster than he was at NCAAs in 2014, and sits only five seconds away from the national record established by Al Weik in 2012. Greenhalgh is also considerably faster than he was ranked last year going into NCAAs. Last year he dropped 12 seconds from his seed time. If he duplicates that feat this year, the mile is going to be an explosive race! Resman was fifth in the mile last year, behind a few graduated seniors. He is also already two seconds faster than where he was at the NCAA meet last year, and ten seconds ahead of where he had been coming into the meet in 2014.

 200 IM


  1. Depew| Redlands – 20 points
  2. Wilson| Emory- 17 points
  3. Anderson | Mary Washington- 16 points

For the men’s 200 IM Emory junior Andrew Wilson – who finished fifth last year – is already seeded in first with a time of 1:47.59 – a time that would’ve placed him in a close second behind three time NCAA champion Jeff Depew. Coming into the NCAA meet, Depew is about a second faster than where he was last year when he won the event. Anderson of Mary Washington will also be up there in the mix. Last year he came into the meet seeded four seconds slower than he is this year and proceeded to whip his way through to a silver. With the tightness of this event this year, it’s one worth keeping an eye on.

100 Breast


  1. Wilson |Emory – 20 points
  2. Lagieski | Wash. U. – 17 points
  3. Van Deventer | Occidental – 16 points

Wilson is also a shoo-in for the 100 breast – as he is seeded first by over a second. Last year he was under the meet record, but so was Michael Lagieski – a then-freshman from Wash. U. – who touched the wall just before Wilson. Lagieski is seeded seventh heading into NCAAs in the 100 breast.

 50 Free


  1. Potter | Gettysburg – 20 points
  2. Crowley | NYU – 17 points
  3. Brindamour | Coast Guard – 16 points

It might be a while before Zach Turk’s (Kenyon ’12) 50 free record (19.38) falls – yet Jason Potter – a senior from Gettysburg is going to give it a shot. Potter finished third over all in the 50 free last year with a 20.32 – yet is already seeded first in the event with a 20.10. Jerimiah Crowley – a senior from NYU – didn’t even make the C final at last year’s NCAAs – finishing 35th overall with a 20.85. Crowley, however, had an amazing senior season and is seeded just behind Potter with a 20.13. If Crowley can shave another :00.72 off of his 50 time at prelims, Turk’s record might fall. Only .26 seconds separate the first Potter from the eighth seed Austin Caldwell (Kenyon ’15) – this could be anyone’s race.

 200 Medley Relay


  1. Williams – 40 points
  2. Denison – 34 points
  3. TCNJ – 32 points

For the 200 Medley Relay, Emory’s nearly-record-breaking team last year was made up of three seniors – the only veteran from that relay is IMer Andrew Wilson  – who split a 24.68 on the breaststroke leg. No. 3 Emory is seeded seventh in the event, while no. 7 Williams, no. 2 Denison, and no. 5 TCNJ hold the first, second, and third spots, respectively. Last year Williams finished seventh overall – but with junior Jake Tamposi just breaking the NESCAC breaststroke record, Williams is the favorite.

 200 Free Relay


  1. Kenyon – 40 points
  2. Denison – 34 points
  3. Gettysburg – 32 points

Kenyon is back and under 1:20.00! Although no one – including fifth place finisher Kenyon – swam the 200 free relay under 1:20 last year, Kenyon heads into the event seeded first with a 1:19.92. Although it would require a significant drop from each relay leg, no. 1 Kenyon has a shot at the NCAA record – set back in 2012 – of 1:18.06. No. 2 Denison has the number two seed at 1:20.12, followed by no. 19 Gettysburg seeded third at 1:21.10.

 400 IM


  1. Anderson | Mary Washington – 20 points
  2. Manz | Kenyon – 17 points
  3. Lindell | Denison – 16 points

Last year, as a junior, Mary Washington’s Hugh Anderson broke his own 400 IM record by over a second – lowering it to 3:49.25. Anderson goes into NCAAs seeded first – yet Kenyon sophomore Trevor Manz – who finished third overall last year is close behind in second. Third seed goes to Denison sophomore Jack Lindell – who finished ninth at finals last year yet is seeded with a 3:52.81. While Anderson is a shoo-in for first place, second, third, and fourth are completely up for grabs.

100 Fly


  1. Martin | Rose-Hulman – 20 points
  2. Dalton | Wash. U. – 17 points
  3. Mering | Whitman – 16 points

Last year the 100 fly came down to one-one hundredth of a second – with then-junior Karl Mering (47.91) taking the title over then-senior Sam Gill (47.91). Mering – now a senior for Whitman College – is seeded tenth overall with a :48.73. First seed goes to Rose-Hulman junior Orion Martin – who finished seventh in finals last year. Martin claims first with a quick 47.92 yet is only in first by a small fraction of a second – to Wash. U. junior Reed Dalton – fourth place finisher in 2014.

200 Free


  1. Caldwell | Kenyon – 20 points
  2. Mering | Whitman – 17 points
  3. Holder | Hopkins – 16 points

For the 200 free, Austin Caldwell, a Kenyon senior, might be unrivaled this year. Caldwell narrowly placed first in 2014 – with second, third, fourth, and fifth all going to seniors who have since, graduated. Caldwell heads into the 2-free seeded with a 1:36.91 – closer to the record than anyone has been for a while. Seeded in second and third, are Whitman senior Karl Mering and Hopkins sophomore Evan Holder, respectively. Mering may be swimming at a disadvantage having just come off a 100 butterfly minutes before going into the finals of the 200 freestyle.

100 Free


  1. Caldwell | Kenyon – 20 points
  2. Crowley | NYU – 17 points
  3. Morrell | Wash. U. – 16 points

With a second place finish in the 100 free last year, Caldwell looks to take the first place title in 2015. Jeremiah Crowley – the NYU senior who dropped over :00.7 seconds this season in his 50 free – is seeded first. Crowley is the only one seeded under :44.00 – with a time of :43.97. Caldwell, however, is just on his tail – seeded second with a :44.06.

400 Medley Relay


  1. Williams – 40 points
  2. Kenyon – 34 points
  3. Denison – 32 points

Last year Emory was just four-hundredths off of the NCAA 400 medley relay record – yet lost their backstroke and freestyle legs to graduation. Emory takes fourth place seed this year, followed by first seed Kenyon, Denison, and Williams, respectively. Although Williams’ 400 medley DQed in the finals last year, all of the members of the relay will be back swimming at NCAAs again this year.

200 Fly


  1. Ricotta | Williams – 20 points
  2. Anderson | Mary Wash. – 17 points
  3. Depew | Redlands – 16 points

Speaking of Williams, senior Thad Ricotta also is seeded first in the 200 fly – but by only :00.03 seconds – to 400 IM record holder Hugh Anderson. Both Ricotta and Anderson are seeded over a second from the third place seed and will most likely take first and second. Anderson won last year with a 1:45.36.

100 Backstroke


  1. Lin | Williams – 20 points
  2. Curley | Kenyon – 17 points
  3. Lindgren | USMMA – 16 points

2014 fourth-place finisher Benjamin Lin – a sophomore from Williams – is set to take the 100 back title. That being said, Harrison Curley – a senior from Kenyon – finished seventh in finals last year and is seeded just behind Lin at second.

800 Free Relay


  1. Kenyon – 40 points
  2. Denison – 34 points
  3. Johns Hopkins – 32 points

With Kenyon seeded first in the 800 free relay by nearly seven seconds, last year’s champions, Johns Hopkins, will have a lot of ground to make up if they want to jump from their third seeded spot to take first place. Number two is currently claimed by Denison.

200 Backstroke


  1. Curely | Kenyon – 20 points
  2. Lindgren | USMMA – 17 points
  3. Lin | Williams – 16 points

Last year in the 2-back, Harrison Curley and Kevin Lindgren, of Kenyon and the Marines, respectively, battled it out: going into finals just five-hundredth apart then finishing first and second with less than a third of a second between them. This year, both Curley and Lindgren are seeded in first and second, respectively, both of them being the only men seeded under 1:46.00.

200 Breaststroke


  1. Wilson | Emory – 20 points
  2. Walthall | YCP – 17 points
  3. Van Deventer | Occidental – 16 points

In the 2-breast, Andrew Wilson also claims the first place spot with 1:57.18. Wilson is almost three seconds ahead of the number two seed, Kyle Walthall and will likely beat last year’s champion, Steven Van Deventer, who is seeded fifth.

400 Free Relay


  1. Kenyon – 40 points
  2. Denison – 34 points
  3. TCNJ – 32 points

The last event – the 400 free relay – went to TCNJ in 2014, but with half their relay having graduated, TCNJ comes into this even seeded third. Kenyon, however, is seeded first by nearly three seconds – to rival Denison – the second seed. With six schools already having broken the 3:00.00 mark, this race is going to be a quick – and exciting – one.


Based on the prelims scoring – in addition to last year’s results – Williams might replace third-place Emory on the podium. That being said, Kenyon is expected to take first place overall, while Denison is expected to take third.

Check back here in March for more Division-III NCAA info!

Leave a Reply

Notify of
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
6 years ago

It’s hard to pre-score diving, but teams like Denison and Chicago will probably bring several divers. As we all know, it was Denison’s strength on the boards that allowed them to break the famous Kenyon Championship streak. Chicago was as close to Emory this year at UAA’s because of a boatload of points off the boards. Assuming an 8th and 9th place finish (one “up” and one “down”) for diving for either Denison or Chicago or anyone else bringing divers, and that’s a potential 40 pt push, enough to push Chicago 10th to 6th on paper.

6 years ago

Last year, who ever predicted the D3 nats winners failed to pick Jeff Depew after he was a two time defending champ in the 200 IM. This year, he isn’t even in the top three after being a three-peat champ? Come on.

Jeff Depew all the way. Watch out for a sick 2 fly too. Last year going into the meet he hadn’t broken 1:50 and ended up as a 1:45.3. This year he was 1:47 at SCIACs. Could be dangerous if you ask me.

Joe Ciliak
6 years ago

Jeff Depew should be in the mix for all three of his races. I heard he was doing doubles up to the day of his conference meet. Talk about gutsy!

Reply to  Joe Ciliak
6 years ago

A lot of swimmers do doubles up until or through their conference meets. Especially if they already have cuts. I don’t doubt Depew will do great but this is hardly a valid point in his favor.

Tom Rushton
6 years ago

Jeepers… those “purple fuzzies” are still around… Kenyon Swimming is a great institution, but those things are possibly more impressive in their resilience!

6 years ago

I am surprised to not see Stephen Culberson up there on the sprint freestyle races. He is faster than he was at this point last year in both of his races. It’s hard to count out the reigning 100 free national champion!

6 years ago

Depew, 1:43.9 in 200 fly for the win. Shatters the NCAA record. Calling it.

About Oliver Goodman

Oliver Goodman

Oliver Goodman hails from a row home in central Philadelphia, Pennsylvania - just one block east of the Schuylkill River. Along with his two sisters, Rachel and Molly, Oliver grew up tormenting his parents with pranks, booby-traps, and most notably, bringing home almost every puppy he and his siblings could find. Oliver started swimming his freshman …

Read More »