Breaking Down The Objective Process For Sun Yang’s Swimmer Of The Meet

Despite a controversial last day for the Chinese swimmer, Sun Yang was given the swimmer of the meet award at the 2015 World Championships.

The award is handed out to one male and one female swimmer proposed by the FINA Awards Commission who were deemed to have the best performances at the meet by FINA.

After an eventful day involving a physical altercation during warm ups and heart problems that forced Sun to withdraw from the 1500m freestyle, many athletes are voicing their opinions that other viable candidates should have won.

Sun was in violation of section five of the FINA code of ethics today which states, “all forms of harassment, be they physical, psychological, professional or sexual, are strictly prohibited.”

Adam Peaty, one of the swimmers who arguably was in the running to be named swimmer of the met, held nothing back when responding to this tweet:

Screen Shot 2015-08-09 at 6.03.18 PM

 

 

 

 

 

 

Many other athletes took to Twitter to express their discontent for the decision, especially British athletes who backed Peaty’s performances.

Sun did win the most individual golds out of any male swimmer at worlds, which without a doubt puts him in contention for the award. When handed out objectively, Sun makes a good case as the winner.

As determined in the FINA by laws however, the winner is determined based upon the following points system:

*Not indicated but assumed only individual events count, or both Peaty and Manaudou would have beaten Sun

  • 1st = 5 points
  • 2nd =3 points
  • 3rd = 2 points
  • 4th = 1 point
  • Individual world record  = 2 points

We’ve provided the details of each swimmer’s week below in order to determine who rightfully should have won the award. Sun’s performances were very good, but by looking at data below it appears that there are others who might have been just as deserving of the award.

Sun Yang

Sun earned himself three medals at this competition. He took home two golds and a silver medal.

In the 400 and 800m freestyle Sun defended his world championship titles, and became the third man in history to ever win consecutive golds in the 400. With his 800 win he became the only man to ever win three straight 800m freestyles at worlds surpassing distance legend Grant Hackett.

When he touched for silver in the 200m freestyle, Sun became just the second swimmer in the history of the sport to win any color medal across the 200m-400m-800m-1500m events over multiple championships. Hackett of Australia is the only other swimmer to have ever done this.

  • 2 x GOLD
  • 1 x SILVER
  • Points: 13
  • World records: ZERO

Adam Peaty 

Adam Peaty of Great Britain was absolutely electric at these championships, winning two gold medals and becoming the first swimmer to ever win both the 50 and 100m breaststrokes at a single championships.

Peaty swam a 58.18 championship record in the 100m breaststroke in order to advance to finals. In finals he claimed gold becoming just the fourth British swimmer to ever win a world title in swimming.

Following that performance Peaty swam to a new world record in the 50m breaststroke semifinals with a time of 26.42. He went on to win the event later on adding a second gold.

In the mixed 4x100m medley relay, Peaty was incredible and helped the British team win gold and set a world record. Peaty was the only male swimmer at these championships to set an individual world record other than Cameron Van Der Burgh, and one of four guys (two British, two American) to set a world record as part of a relay.

  • 3 x GOLD (ONE RELAY)
  • Points: 12
  • World records: TWO (ONE RELAY)

Florent Manaudou 

Florent Manaudou of France is another viable candidate for the title of swimmer of the meet. Manaudou showed his pure raw speed in both the 50m freestyle and 50m fly, taking gold in both events.

Manaudou also helped the French team recapture gold in the men’s 4x100m freestyle relay, splitting a 47.93 on the second leg.

Manaudou is one of just two male swimmers (himself and Peaty) to be leaving Kazan with three gold medals. No other male swimmer managed to achieve that feat.

  • 3 x GOLD (ONE RELAY)
  • Points: 10
  • World records: ZERO

Mitchell Larkin

Mitchell Larkin became the first swimmer in 10-years to win both the 100 and 200m backstrokes at the same world championships. The last swimmer to do so was famed American backstroker Aaron Peirsol.

Larkin won gold in both the 100 and 200m backstrokes this week, and helped the Australian 4x100m medley relay finish second to the Americans.

Larkin did put up the fastest backstroke leg out of all relay swimmers however, sporting  52.41 at the touch to put his team in first.

  • 2 x GOLD
  • 1 x SILVER
  • Points = 10
  • Word records: ZERO

Laszlo Cseh 

Laszlo Cseh had what can arguably be described as his best world championships ever. The Hungarian superstar won his first world title in 10-years as he beat out South African Chad Le Clos for gold in the 200m butterfly.

There, Cseh posted the worlds number one time until it was beaten shortly after by Michael Phelps at US Nationals. Despite that, Cseh still had plenty more success of his own.

In the prelims of the 100m butterfly, Cseh became the first swimmer since the 2012 London Olympics to break 51-seconds in the 100m butterfly. He swam a 50.91 in prelims and then even faster in finals to take home the silver medal.

With a bronze in the 50m fly, Cseh became the first male swimmer to ever win medals in all three same stroke events at one edition of the world championships

  • 1 x GOLD
  • 1 x SILVER
  • 1 x BRONZE
  • Points = 10
  • World records: ZERIO

 

In This Story

34
Leave a Reply

19 Comment threads
15 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
23 Comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Jay

Quoted from doc on Kazan 2015 website:

Fina individual trophies for the top scoring male and female based upon the following points:
1st Place – 5 points
2nd Place – 3 points
3rd Place – 2 points
4th Place – 1 point
Individual World Record – 2 points for each record broken

Kuru

This short paragraph delivers more info than the entire article above.

SWIMFAN

So based on this small paragraph,

Sun Yang’s – 13 points
Peaty – 14 points (2 Golds 2 WRs)

Still has no idea how Peaty didn’t get it.

SWIMFAN

Oh wait, never mind… Peaty only got 1 WR..

Kuru

@FISH explained below that relay medals do not count toward individual awards. In fact, if Peaty got another 4th finish he would have won (or tie with SY) with 13 points. The original article failed to point that out either!

Fish

Peaty had 1 WR in the 50 Breast semi. The other was a relay.

SpectatorN
mcgillrocks

I feel as though a Continental or Championship record should also be a point (not an extra point- a WR is still 2 points overall, and a CR would be one, and a Continental record would be one, but a swim that’s both a CR and continental record but not a WR would still be one).

Kuru

You made it sound like not showing up due to a heart problem is Sun Yang’s mistake. What’s the politically correct thing to do? swim and die in the pool?

Hulk Swim

Duh. It’s been decided already that he was nefariously

Hulk Swim

Avoiding a drug test…

Kuru

Funny how the minions coming out in droves trying to pile some negative publicity on Sun.

Swimmer A

Like why bother taking the controversial route on that pick? No one would have put up a fight if they picked Peaty. What did they gain from that? Why?

About Mitch Bowmile

Mitch Bowmile

Mitch Bowmile is a former Canadian age group swimmer who was forced to end his career early due to a labrum tear in his hip and a torn rotator cuff after being recognized as one of the top 50 breaststrokers his age in Canada. He competed successfully at both age …

Read More »

Want to take your swimfandom to the next level?

Subscribe to SwimSwam Magazine!