2019 M. NCAA Previews: 200 Backstrokers Aren’t Showing Their Hands

2019 MEN’S NCAA SWIMMING & DIVING CHAMPIONSHIPS

200 Backstroke

At last year’s NCAA Championship meet, University of Texas freshman Austin Katz led 3 Longhorns in the top 5 of the men’s 200 backstroke at the NCAA Championships, coming away with a title and a new Pool Record in the event.

That race, where the Longhorns scored 54 points last year, was where Eddie Reese’s squad really set the tone for the final day of the meet, which was a much closer finish than we usually see at this meet (decided by 12.5 points). This year, the Longhorns project to do better than their 0 200 breaststroke points from last year’s NCAA Championship meet, but Texas still needs big points out of this 200 back to cover for an overall scoring weakness on the final day of the meet.

While Texas is the favorite to win the 200 back this year, just which Longhorn will be on top of the podium is open to debate. Katz is the defending champion, but then-junior John Shebat finished 2nd last year in 1:37.94, .41 seconds behind Katz, in spite of missing much of the season with an injury.

And then there’s Ryan Harty, who was 14th at NCAAs last season, but is the fastest swimmer in the nation this season thanks to a 1:38.61 from the Big 12 Championships.

Knowing where the Longhorns are is always a challenge given their lack of any real competition at the Big 12 Championship meet.

They’re not the only challengers for the title, though. The top 5 finishers from NCAAs last year all return, as do 10 of the top 12 finishers from the meet. And, they’re not the only enigma.

USC’s Patrick Mulcare, now a senior, was 3rd at NCAAs last year in 1:38.43 (and was the top non-Longhorn finisher), and was 3rd a year earlier. He was fast mid-season in the 200 back, swimming 1:39.18 at this same University of Texas pool in early December.

Much like Texas, he’s a bit of an enigma. He was way off at Pac-12s: sporting a sprawling bright-red beard to emphasize that he wasn’t shaved for the meet. He was only 10th at the conference meet in the 200 back, and didn’t even final in the 100 back or 200 IM. His 200 IM time of 1:50.02 was actually slower than he’d been in all-but-one dual meet during the season. In fact, his season dual-meet best, against Utah in  late February, was almost 7 seconds faster than he swam at Pac-12s.

We’ve seen this sort of a strategy work in the past, and we’ve seen it blow up in athletes’ faces. Last year, he didn’t even swim Pac-12s last year. The year before, he swam fast at Pac-12s. In both cases, he was 3rd. New year, new strategy, but repeating a 3rd-place finish against this deep field will be tougher-than-ever.

Staying on theme, NC State junior Coleman Stewart was just 12th in the 200 back at NCAAs last year, in spite of winning the 100 back. He enters this year’s meet as the 3rd seed, having been a best time in the 200 back at ACCs (he also went a best time in the 100 back at that meet).

Cal joins Texas with two seeds in the t0p 8: Bryce Mefford (5th seed – 1:39.13) and Daniel Carr (7th seed – 1:39.43). Both swimmers dropped big time at NCAAs last season in both prelims and finals. Mefford tapered off 2.4 seconds to finish 4th, while Carr tapered off 1.3 seconds to finish 10th.

Two spots have opened up in this A final: Stanford senior Abrahm Devine, who was 8th at NCAAs last year, is swimming the 100 free on day 4 of the meet instead; so too is last year’s 7th-place finisher Dean Farris. That means that in spite of few graduations, only the top half of last year’s A final returns.

Other Returning Scorers from last year, and their seeds:

  • Javier Acevedo, Georgia – 10th seed, 1:39.88 (he was injured in the fall, but has swum fairly well in the spring)
  • Metin Aydin, Hawaii – 25th seed, 1:41.02 (like last year, he went to a last-chance meet; unlike last year, he didn’t need it, as his MPSF time was good enough to qualify, and he wasn’t any faster at the last chance)

B-finalist Mohamed Samy has also chosen the 100 free, but that doesn’t leave the Hoosiers without a big scoring threat. Sophomore Gabriel Fantoni has made big gains in his 200 back this season, swimming a 1:39.53 at Big Tens that puts him 1.3 seconds ahead of where he was last season. He wasn’t able to drop time at NAAs lasst year, however. Arizona State’s Zach Poti (1:39.88), Florida’s Clark Beach (1:39.95), and Missouri’s Nick Alexander (1:39.88) have also been sub-1:40 already this season. All three swimmers were close to their seed times at NCAAs last season, with Poti and Beach dropping a little, but Alexander adding a little. Last year, though, his season-best was at a last chance meet, while this year he did that mid-season and presumably was able to train through the end of the regular season without having to chase a cut.

There’s one really surprising name at the top of the psych sheets: Tennessee senior Joey Reilman (Michael on your scorecards). He’s already dropped 1.3 seconds from his lifetime best this season, and is 3rd in the country coming into this meet with a 1:38.97. Last year, he was 25th at NCAAs, right on his seed time from SECs. If he can do that again, he’s got a top-5 finish in his sights.

So with so much data missing, how do we decide on a winner? The best I could come up with was to go back to the last known data point: last year’s NCAA Championships. If Shebat can finished 2nd in this event after missing time with an injury, it’s hard to not give a healthy Shebat the benefit-of-the-doubt, as a senior, in a home pool.

Picks:

Top 8 Picks format:
Place Swimmer Team Season Best Lifetime Best
1 John Shebat Texas 1:39.55 1:37.24
2 Austin Katz Texas 1:39.33 1:37.53
3 Bryce Mefford Cal 1:39.13 1:38.48
4 Patrick Mulcare USC 1:38.91 1:37.80
5 Daniel Carr Cal 1:39.43 1:39.29
6 Coleman Stewart NC State 1:39.10 1:39.10
7 Joey Reilman Tennessee 1:38.97 1:38.97
8 Ryan Harty Texas 1:39.53 1:38.61

In This Story

22
Leave a Reply

13 Comment threads
9 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
22 Comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Horninco

Beat race of the meet?

Togger

2 free brings together two of the senior class stars, I think a head to head is always exciting.

This might be best 1-8 race, though 2IM is stacked as well.

Lion Rocktea

I would not sleep on Coleman Stewart so much…

B1Guy!

#FACTS I’ve got him 2nd here

Swimmar

I’d watch out for Dahlgren (Missouri) and Whyte (Louisville) potentially making big drops

northernfrijole

The difference between swimswam writers and swimswam commenters: swimswam writers have to put their opinions out there, swimswam commenters get to say things like ‘don’t sleep on my boy from my favorite team who probably might almost definitely could possibly drop a ton of time because he’s been working super super hard this season and deserves it more than everyone else so look out for him and don’t sleep on him’

Your Friendly Neighborhood Spiderman

he’s mad

Nope

They’ve made their drops for the season. The only freshman that could’ve had a chance at top 5 is Casas, but he’s not even swimming it anymore.

About Braden Keith

Braden Keith

Braden Keith is the Editor-in-Chief and a co-founder of SwimSwam.com. He first got his feet wet by building The Swimmers' Circle beginning in January 2010, and now comes to SwimSwam to use that experience and help build a new leader in the sport of swimming. Aside from his life on the InterWet, …

Read More »

Want to take your swimfandom to the next level?

Subscribe to SwimSwam Magazine!