Emre Sakci Disputes DQs At SC Worlds, Challenges FINA For Transparency

Needless to say, it was an eventful month of December for Turkish breaststroker Emre Sakci.

Sakci headed to the 2021 Short Course World Championships in Abu Dhabi with eyes on challenging for a pair of gold medals in the men’s 50 and 100 breaststroke, but was denied the opportunity to swim in either final after a pair of disqualifications.

The 24-year-old was one of several swimmers to get disqualified during the opening session of the meet in a breaststroke event, including six in the men’s 100 breast, and then he was dinged a second time in the 50 breast semis after initially posting the fastest time in the field.

Sakci followed that up by heading to compete at the Turkish National Championships at the end of the month, breaking the 50 breast world record by a whopping three-tenths of a second in 24.95. He also set new Turkish National Records in the men’s 50 and 100 freestyle.

The 2020 Olympian addressed the highs and lows of the last few weeks with SwimSwam, and let it be known that he doesn’t see eye to eye with the disqualifications he was handed in Abu Dhabi.

“I don’t agree with the decision,” Sakci told SwimSwam. “Both disqualification decisions were given because of dolphin kicks. When you examine all the world records up to date, you can see that most of the racing is done with waist movements. There were underwater cameras in the Olympics as well. Many high-level swimmers raced there and came to the world championship, and then we saw a record for the number of swimmers DQed at Worlds.

“What happened in this very short time period? Do you think all these high skilled swimmers forgot how to swim?”

FINA approved the use of underwater cameras to be able to initiate, confirm or overturn disqualifications prior to the Tokyo Olympic Games, which marked the first time they were used in that capacity. SC Worlds was just the second time, with the current rules currently dictating that they only be used at an Olympic or World Championship event.

Sakci says he supports the use of underwater video, but wants more cameras to cover the entirety of each race from all angles, hoping to give everyone more clarity on the decisions that are being made. He also suggests removing all dolphin kicks from breaststroke to remove the need for interpretation.

“All of the race should be recorded with underwater and top cameras simultaneously after the whistle is blown, not just from one angle, but the whole race should be examined (start, swim, return, swim) and should be shared with the world transparently,” he said. “All of the international races, including the accredited ones, should be recorded and examined by experts.

“FINA should set a clear standard so that decisions to be made in the breaststroke style are not open to interpretation, and if necessary, remove all allowed dolphin kicks in the breaststroke style.”

As FINA Technical Swim Committee (TSC) Chair Carol Zaleski told SwimSwam at SC Worlds, the majority of breaststroke DQs in Abu Dhabi were caused by a downward dolphin kick from the swimmer prior to the turn and/or finish.

Sakci says that was the cause of his DQs as well, and that he even forced himself to hold off a little bit during his world record swim in Turkey to avoid the same fate. He says that the way he glides into the wall is perceived as a dolphin kick, but claims it’s not what he’s actually doing.

“To avoid any speculation, I had to slow down in the last meters of the finish in the race that I broke the record so that even a non-swimmer can understand,” he said. “Because in the World Championship, the move I did because of my height disadvantage was perceived as a dolphin kick.”

Sakci stands at a towering six feet eight inches tall, and if you watch the race video of him breaking the world record, he manages to finish on a full stroke, avoiding any potential issues with the glide in.

Speaking on the record itself, Sakci said that breaking it outside of the World Championships “didn’t satisfy” him. He was hoping to do it at Worlds, and would’ve preferred getting it done in the ISL or the European Championships—where he’s facing some of the world’s best—compared to doing it at home where he was essentially racing on his own.

A two-time European SC silver medalist in the 50 breast, including in 2021 in Kazan, Sakci revealed the mindset that allowed him to not only break the world record, which had been on the books since 2009, but demolish it by a relatively massive margin.

“My biggest objective is to force my own limits,” he said. “Our target was to swim under 25 seconds for this record.

“When you aim to break a record, you actually limit yourself, whereas when you aim to develop yourself, the results become much better. My future training will be about pushing my limits.”

The record was set at 25.25 by South African Cameron van der Burgh in 2009—with the aid of the now-banned super-suits—and then was matched by Belarusian Ilya Shymanovich in November 2021 at SC Euros, with Sakci taking second in 25.39.

Moving forward, Sakci is eyeing big things in 2022, saying it will be “a year full of competition.”

With several major international meets on the horizon, including the Long Course World Championships in May and the LC European Champs in August, Sakci started things on the right foot in the big pool to end 2021 as well, establishing a personal best time in the 50 breast at 26.83.

In This Story

23
Leave a Reply

Subscribe
Notify of

23 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Ray Loose
10 months ago

Who cares… it’s breaststroke.

kierkegaard
Reply to  Ray Loose
9 months ago

oh you’re so cool

anonymous
10 months ago

Is it legal to have a breast kick that has an upsweep added to the kick like the up kick on dolphin. Also on the underwater glide is it legal to have both arms extended with hands together then pull about 2 feet down with hands together, then do the dolphin kick then the arm pull. It seems like the athlete is using the arms to make an undulating motion with the dolphin kick then doing the pull

The Original Tim
Reply to  anonymous
10 months ago

Yes, both are legal

DrSwimPhil
10 months ago

A) the cameras do cover the entirety of the race

B) did you guys happen to ask the Turkish federation coach who had the opportunity to view it themselves and not issue an appeal?

IM FAN
10 months ago

He took 2 dolphin kicks off the start

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lpzEBhwQy1o&t=2m45s

He does not take an extra kick off the turn

It also looks like he might’ve taken a dolphin kick into the finish though with no underwater footage I can’t say for sure. Indeed that may just be his Dolphinovich style stroke.

I agree with him that FINA should be transparent about the exact reason but he knows what he did. This isn’t even a new problem either Van Der Burgh was fully aware he was cheating when he took 3 Dolphin kicks off the start at the London Olympics.

His world record is also suspicious to me for this reason though without underwater footage it’s impossible to tell for sure.

Tomek
10 months ago

I really do not understand why not to get rid of downward butterfly kick all together? It would be so much easier to enforce rules.

Dressel will come 3rd in 100 free in Paris
10 months ago

Swimmers haven’t forgotten how to swim… just ever since the current generation of top swimmers have been swimming, people have been sneaking kicks underwater and nothing has been done about it.

Now is the crackdown, that is all.

He’s absolutely right that others have used (illegal) waist movements. They just got away with it… might seem a bit unfair now, but hopefully it will mean a ‘cleaner’ and fairer future for most sprint breaststrokers.

Horninco
10 months ago

He’s not wrong. If the camera angle/quality doesn’t allow you to critique each swimmer equally (like say the outside lanes) then it’s not fair

DrSwimPhil
Reply to  Horninco
10 months ago

He’s incorrect in that assessment. Every lane has the same angle from wall-to-wall, there’s an entire grid of cameras to cover every lane properly

Last edited 10 months ago by DrSwimPhil
Ugly IS my alibi
10 months ago

100 percent for transparency. This is very important for fairness

About James Sutherland

James Sutherland

James swam five years at Laurentian University in Sudbury, Ontario, specializing in the 200 free, back and IM. He finished up his collegiate swimming career in 2018, graduating with a bachelor's degree in economics. In 2019 he completed his graduate degree in sports journalism. Prior to going to Laurentian, James swam …

Read More »