SwimSwam 2018-2019 NCAA Division I Women’s Preseason Picks

by Robert Gibbs 7

October 19th, 2018 News

Well, it’s that time of year again.

Followers of sports like baseball or football will be familiar with writers from major sports publications making their preseason predictions about Most Valuable Players, World Series or Super Bowl champions, and the like.  We know swimming fans enjoy making their predictions about upcoming events, or even whole seasons, just as much as any other fans out there, so we decided to share own predictions about the upcoming NCAA season with our readers.

We’re not quite still in the college swimming preseason as some teams have started competition, but even some of the major Division I squads haven’t yet had their first official meet, so we figured it’s still early enough to call these “preseason” picks.

We polled our staff, did our research, and came up with our six-months-out best guesses as to who would be standing atop the awards podium for each event at the 2019 NCAA Division I championships, and without any further ado, below are our choices by writer:

Robert Lauren Reid Torrey Jared Karl Braden Andrew James Consensus Pick
800 Free Relay Stanford Stanford Stanford Stanford Stanford Stanford Stanford Stanford Stanford Stanford
200 Free Relay Cal Cal Cal Cal California Stanford Cal Cal Cal Cal
500 Free Katie Drabot Katie Drabot Katie Drabot Katie Drabot Katie Drabot Kirsten Jacobsen Evie Pfeifer Katie Drabot Katie Drabot Drabot
200 IM Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Eastin
50 Free Abbey Weitzeil Erika Brown Abbey Weitzeil Abbey Weitzeil Taylor Ruck Erika Brown Abbey Weitzeil Abbey Weitzeil Abbey Weitzeil Weitzeil
400 Medley Relay Louisville Stanford Stanford Stanford California Stanford Stanford Stanford Stanford Stanford
400 IM Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Eastin
100 Fly Louise Hansson Erika Brown Louise Hansson Louise Hansson Erika Brown Louise Hansson Louise Hansson Louise Hansson Erika Brown Hansson
200 Free Mallory Comerford Mallory Comerford Mallory Comerford Mallory Comerford Taylor Ruck Mallory Comerford Mallory Comerford Mallory Comerford Taylor Ruck Comerford
100 Breast Lilly King Lilly King Lilly King Lilly King Lilly King Lilly King Lilly King Lilly King Lilly King King
100 Back Beata Nelson Beata Nelson Beata Nelson Beata Nelson Beata Nelson Beata Nelson Beata Nelson Beata Nelson Beata Nelson Nelson
200 Medley Relay Stanford Cal Cal Stanford Stanford Stanford Cal Cal Cal Cal
1650 Free Ally McHugh Ally McHugh Ally McHugh Erica Sullivan Ally McHugh Erica Sullivan Erica Sullivan Ally McHugh Ally McHugh McHugh
200 Back Taylor Ruck Beata Nelson Taylor Ruck Taylor Ruck Taylor Ruck Asia Seidt Taylor Ruck Taylor Ruck Taylor Ruck Ruck
100 Free Mallory Comerford Mallory Comerford Mallory Comerford Mallory Comerford Mallory Comerford Taylor Ruck Mallory Comerford Mallory Comerford Mallory Comerford Comerford
200 Breast Lilly King Lilly King Lilly King Lilly King Lilly King Lilly King Lilly King Lilly King Lilly King King
200 Fly Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Ella Eastin Eastin
400 Free Relay California Stanford Stanford Stanford Stanford Stanford Stanford Cal Stanford Stanford

Relays

  • Stanford dominated last year, winning all five relays.  They’ve lost a lot of relay legs due to graduation and/or swimmers during pro, but they’ve reloaded enough they’re our unanimous pick to win the 800 free relay again, as well as our consensus picks in the 400 medley and 400 free relays, although Cal should be dangerous in both.
  • Kathleen Baker turning pro a year early also hurts the Bears a bit, but we think they return enough to still have the advantage over Stanford in both of the 200-distance relays.

Repeats

  • Ella Eastin may have had a rough past two summers, but she’s been utterly consistent during the NCAA season, and she got a possible 27 out of 27 votes to win her three signature events – the 200 IM, the 400 IM, and the 200 fly – this year for Stanford.
  • Lilly King is pretty much a no-brainer here, and the Indiana senior was our unanimous pick to sweep the breaststrokes and go for 8-8 in her NCAA career.
  • We’re not entirely sure what Taylor Ruck is going to swim for Stanford, and she could very well be a threat in the 200 free, but for now, we’re expecting to see Louisville’s Mallory Comerford win the 200 free for the second time outright after tying as a sophomore.
  • Louise Hansson of USC is our favorite to repeat in the 100 fly after going 49.80 last year, but Tennessee sprint star Erika Brown got a few votes too.

The Rest

  • Despite losing Katie Ledecky to a pro career, Stanford may very well still claim the 500 free title, as junior Katie Drabot claimed seven of our nine votes.  Others to watch for include Arizona’s Kirsten Jacobsen, who finished just a couple tenths behind Drabot last year, and Texas’s Evie Pfeifer, the only other returner from last year’s A-final.
  • Just as Ledecky’s departure opens up the distance events, the absence Simone Manuel means we’ll be crowning a new champion in the sprint free events.  Most of our writers feel that Cal’s Abbey Weitzeil will take the 50 free, an event where she is the American Record holder, although Brown and Ruck got votes as well.  Comerford finished about a half second ahead of Weitzeil last year in the 100 free, and the Louisville senior got most of our votes for that event, although we again need to point out we don’t know what Ruck is going to swim, and this is a possible event for her.
  • For the most part, we do think that Ruck will end up swimming the 200 back and win that.  If Ruck doesn’t, though, watch out for Kentucky’s Asia Seidt.
  • Beata Nelson has a new coach at Wisconsin, but we don’t think she’ll miss a beat, as she was our unanimous choice to win the 100 back now that Baker has turned pro.
  • Penn State’s Ally McHugh finished 2nd last year in the 1650, and then had a great summer, so she’s the favorite at the moment in that event, although Erica Sullivan could make some noise in her freshman campaign at USC.

In This Story

7
Leave a Reply

3 Comment threads
4 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
6 Comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Hswimmer

Anna Hopkin could be close in the sprint frees

I think she’s a fantastic sleeper pick (especially for the 50). It’s always hard to gauge how meters-based swimmers do in the NCAA, but she’s been 22-low right off the bat in the 50. Really interested to follow her progression through the season.

Oldswimfan

I’d say Ky-Lee Perry would be in the mix too. She had a big summer after a season ending injury and already threw down 22.2 and 48

Swimmerj

I wouldn’t put anything past McLaughlin in quite a few events

samuel huntington

She’s looking good but she’s in some tough events – 100 fly she will need a 49, 200 fly a 1:48, 100 free a 46, and 200 free a 1:40 – she will need a big drop to win one of these events

samuel huntington

update – her best chance at winning may actually be the 500 with a best time of 4:36.04

4D Patrick

I’m looking forward to the Comerford/TRuck showdown in the 200 free. Should rival the Townley/Pieroni one earlier this March in the men’s 200 free. Wouldn’t be surprised to see winner go below Missy’s 1:39.15 record!

Don't want to miss anything?

Subscribe to our newsletter and receive our latest updates!