College Sports Leaders Raise Questions About Upcoming NCAA Championships

A pair of recent reports have raised the doubt among college swimming & diving coaches not of just the NCAA Swimming & Diving Championships happening this spring, but those of other sports as well, specifically the NCAA Division 1 Basketball Tournament. 

On Friday, the College Swimming & Diving Coaches Association of America (CSCAA) released its January Newsletter, bringing into question the likelihood of the Swimming & Diving Championships taking place. A day later, Matt Norlander of CBS Sports discussed the anxiety that Division 1 athletic directors and conference commissioners are facing with this year’s basketball tournament – which could wind up spilling over into other sports.

In the CSCAA newsletter, Executive Director Greg Earhart takes a realistic view of the current COVID-19 situation and how it pertains to collegiate swimming. Earhart references a CSCAA  town hall held back in October where 75% of coaches surveyed gave a less than 50% chance of the NCAA Championships happening. With the number of cases continuing to rise, Earhart calls out the approach of some college coaches, saying:

I’m struck, no – appalled at the lengths some are going to to get their kids’ (or their own) hopes up for qualifying for a meet that may or may not happen.

Teams are traditionally prepping for the college swimming championship season as the calendar turns to February. At this point of the season, less than 25% of college teams (across all divisions) have held a bone-fide meet. 

With swimmers needing to earn cuts for an NCAA meet, particularly in a championship setting, Earhart raises a good point in regard to the viability of the NCAA Championships happening in a safe manner. He goes on to say that coaches need to be prepping their athletes, particularly seniors, for any kind of end-of-year meet whether it is a conference meet or a virtual meet.

Earhart’s viewpoint is influenced by the fact that he is one of the many people who have been personally affected by the coronavirus as his mother died from complications of COVID-19 last year. 

College commissioners are also worried about the increase of COVID-19 rates affecting the basketball season. Norlander reports about a potential mid-season pause for college basketball. There are three factors that are generating the unease of administrators: 

  • Possible new federal coronavirus restrictions
  • Lack of access to vaccines
  • Students returning to campus

Commissioners are keeping a keen eye on the situation and how the NCAA will respond. February is the key month for basketball as teams and leagues will be running out of time to reschedule games and they will be canceled instead. Bernadette McGlade, A-10 commissioner, points out that a stoppage might not come from the NCAA but from other decisions that are out of the NCAA’s control.

This past week has seen two Division 1 schools pause their athletic programs. On Saturday, both Michigan and Vermont made the decision to temporarily suspend all athletic activity. Michigan has seen five cases of the new B.1.1.17 COVID-19 variant and is putting athletics on hold for up to 14 days. Vermont has decided to pause all on-campus athletic activity until February 4 due to a rise of positive coronavirus tests within the athletic program. These moves from Michigan and Vermont will maintain the anxiety levels of athletic administrators about the current coronavirus situation.

The NCAA Basketball Tournament generates significant revenue for the NCAA and they will do everything they can to ensure that the tournament is played, even if that means pushing it back to April or May.

It is in the best interest of not just swimmers, but all NCAA athletes & coaches that the NCAA Basketball Tournament takes place. The money generated from the tournament helps to fund events such as the NCAA Swimming & Diving Championships. Another year without the NCAA Basketball Tournament and we could see even more collegiate athletic programs on the chopping block.

SwimSwam has spoken to many college coaches, who have mixed views on whether or not the NCAA Championships can happen safely. Some are confident that they will definitely happen, while others have expressed doubts similar to Earhart.

The NCAA Swimming & Diving Championships are scheduled as follows:

  • Division 1 Women — March 17-20, 2021 (Greensboro, NC)
  • Division 1 Men — March 24-27, 2021 (Greensboro, NC)
  • Division 2 Men & Women  — March 17-20, 2021 (Birmingham, AL)
  • Division 3 Men & Women — March 17-20, 2021 (Federal Way, WA)

The New York Times reports that as of Saturday, the United States has hit 25 million coronavirus cases resulting in over 414,000 deaths. Vaccinations in the US began on December 14 and since then 22.4 million shots have been administered.

Earhart’s full letter is below.

During one of our town halls, we surveyed coaches about their confidence of a national championship happening.  Back then, nearly three-quarters of you said you felt there was less than a 50% chance that they could be pulled off. Having known this then, and seeing both the rise of case counts since, I’m struck, no – appalled at the lengths some are going to to get their kids’ (or their own) hopes up for qualifying for a meet that may or may not happen.

Seriously though, with fewer than a quarter of teams having had a bona-fide meet thus far, is a championship this year even legitimate?  Whether it is or isn’t might depend on your perspective, your politics, or your contract’s bonus structure. I get that. If my Brewers had won the World Series, I’d consider it as legitimate as any season, but if the Cubs had, well, then it’s tainted.

What I do know is that the symptomatic spread of this virus is real and deadly. I’ve never won a national title but I lost my mom to the coronavirus. I also know that I would feel guilty if I advocated bringing hundreds of people together just to crown a national champion knowing that it means another member of our community has to say goodbye to a loved one over an iPad.

At this point, I’m convinced that this year’s most important meet is Senior day.  It might be at a conference meet, might be against your biggest rival or might even be virtual. Some kids might swim fast, others not at all. As I’ve been unpacking a lifetime of things stored in my mother’s basement, I can tell you, the notes – especially from parents thanking me for looking after their sons and daughters – mean more to me than any medals or coach-of-the-year plaque.

Stay safe,


Leave a Reply

Notify of
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Cmon Bruh
4 months ago

There is absolutely no reason not have NCCAs this year. Conferences have proved that they can safely host meets. SEC was great about that. To the point that some schools haven’t had an adequate season (no one really has) that’s just another hurdle to jump. These swimmers have put in too much work and sacrificed way too much in this last year not to be rewarded with a championship meet that everyone looks forward to. Get tested before the meet and at the meet and if you are negative, SWIM.

Reply to  Cmon Bruh
4 months ago

Personally, I have seen almost half my teammates be absolutely devastated by COVID to the point where only one girl who had it can now finish more than an hour of practice (three have been forced by doctors to opt out) through travel, logistics of getting food, locker rooms etc. i can see why the NCAA is nervous to have a meet this size. The safety of not only the athletes is in jeopardy but also the residents of the hosting city. Yes we put in a lot of work for this and sacrificed a lot but at the same time do we really want to sacrifice our future health? And for the underclassmen their chance at having a successful… Read more »

Wildcat hopeful
Reply to  Taylor
4 months ago

It’s a lot harder than just showing a negative test. As an athlete participating in a swim meet this past weekend I was appalled at the number of people in a facility. I lost the sense of safety and security due to the huge numbers of athletes present. I could not imagine a championship season of any form going forward.

Reply to  Wildcat hopeful
4 months ago

Was this a college meet or something else?

Reply to  Wildcat hopeful
4 months ago

I agree! The meets I’ve been to have made me feel very anxious for the next couple weeks and one resulted in four members of the other team testing positive!

It’s ya boi
Reply to  Taylor
4 months ago

It’s your own risk to go to these meets

Reply to  It’s ya boi
4 months ago

Yes and it’s our own risk to go to practice every day, and our own risk to go to school and our own risk to go to our job but what is the alternative? The governing bodies are still responsible for ensuring the safety of the attendees as they have always been even before COVID.

4 months ago

Although I had a neighbor that passed away last week at 65-years-old and it hurt and I’ve gone back and forth on this issue, I still lean towards having the meet in some form or fashion. I’m terribly sorry for Greg Earhart’s loss of his mother and I understand his feelings on the issue, but t don’t think his opinion represents the majority of the college coaches affected. I agree with him on playing up “Senior Day” because we do need to be grateful for what we have and celebrate each other. Furthermore, as Jesus said in the Bible, “Do not worry about tomorrow, for tomorrow will worry about itself. Each day has trouble of its own.”

Reply to  Guerra
4 months ago

Making wise decisions based on available evidence is not worrying.

If we want to focus on not worrying, let’s help our athletes focus on things they have control over, not things completely out of their control (like NCAAs happening).

Some of them have a lot more swimming ahead of them and need to play the long game here. Some don’t. For them, this is a tough way to end a career they have put so much into.

Now is a time to help our athletes find perspective and purpose beyond a single meet, time, or performance. Hopefully that’s something that sticks long after covid is over.

Brendan Dassey
4 months ago

Tough situation for the leaders, I feel for the kids that have worked so hard for two years just to have their peak meet taken away.

Reply to  Brendan Dassey
4 months ago

Agreed on outside! San Antonio or Plantation, Florida? (2 outdoor 50 meter pools)