NCAA Releases Statement About North Carolina State Relay DQ Overturning

The NCAA has released a statement on the disqualification of the North Carolina State men’s 200 free relay during Thursday morning’s prelims session that was originally disqualified for an early exchange, but then later reinstated.

Read more here.

The touchpads registered one NC State swimmer has having a reaction time of -.03 seconds, but upon further review, that DQ was overturned, which leaves the team with the top seed heading into Thursday’s final.

In the statement, NCAA Division I Men’s and Women’s Swimming & Diving Committee chair Bill Ball said that it became clear that there was an issue with the timing equipment, leading them to throw out all electronic readings from the relay and rely just on the judged results. That resulted in no disqualifications, though there were three in the 400 medley relay to end the session.

The full statement is below:

The NCAA Division I Men’s and Women’s Swimming & Diving Committee upheld a protest to overturn a disqualification that occurred in the third and final heat of the 200-yard men’s freestyle relay qualifying heats today.

The committee used Rule 4 – 2 which states in part “(the committee) shall have discretionary power to set aside the application of a rule when there is apparent unfairness.” The committee set aside Rule 4-14-7 which allows a referee to review video of relay exchanges because the referee onsite did not have a conclusive view of the swimming exchange to be able to reverse the protest. The team disqualification was overturned due to issues surrounding the timing system.

Committee chair Bill Ball issued the following statement regarding the committee’s decision. “We looked at all the information we had available at our disposal and it was clear that we had some issues with the timing system that extended across all three qualifying heats. We felt that we had clear evidence that the system was not operating properly and we chose to eliminate all the electronic readings and go with human judge decisions in the event. The committee acted in the best interests of all 21 teams that were entered in the event.”

13
Leave a Reply

7 Comment threads
6 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
10 Comment authors
newest oldest most voted
iLikePsych

“The committee acted in the best interests of all 21 teams that were entered in the event – except Stanford and Indiana, because who cares about them?”

liquid4TheBears

Given the timing system malfunction, what would have them do differently??

iLikePsych

I actually made my comment in hopes of being funny, but clearly I should be a troll instead of a comedian…

Nave Dolan

He probably thinks it’d be more in the best interest of Stanford if they disqualified NC State without enough evidence, and then disqualified every other relay besides Stanford. And then made the pool shorter for them so they could destroy the record in finals

Thefasttaco

Nave Dolan haha this guy ^^^

SwimFan2

The ruling is fair to all 21 teams in the event; if Stanford and Indiana had swum faster, they would not be facing the role that they are in (8th to 9th and 16th to out of scoring position). There is an old saying in the computer business ” To error is human to really screw things up takes a computer!)

Fish

Is Omega touchpads not being used at the meet, could have sworn they were.

Unless NCAA does not have the rule -.03 is legal with Omega touchpads as per most countries and Omega timing rules.
Did NCAA not have this rule on the books and they are just covering up an administrative error?
It should have been a clear cut overrule.

gator

its a DAKTRONICS System, with RTO cameras I think

About Braden Keith

Braden Keith

Braden Keith is the Editor-in-Chief and a co-founder of SwimSwam.com. He first got his feet wet by building The Swimmers' Circle beginning in January 2010, and now comes to SwimSwam to use that experience and help build a new leader in the sport of swimming. Aside from his life on the InterWet, …

Read More »

Don't want to miss anything?

Subscribe to our newsletter and receive our latest updates!