Did FINA Award the 2014 World Swimmer of the Year Too Early?

Well, here we are, two Mireia Belmonte World Records later, and the conversation about who really should have been FINA’s World Swimmer of the Year has grown into a bit of an uproar.

Just prior to the beginning of the 2014 World Championships, the only “open” championship meet in the world in 2014, FINA gave the honor to Hungarian Katinka Hosszu.

The initial conversation was surrounding whether the award should go to Katie Ledecky, who was the best long course swimmer in the world in 2014, or Hosszu, who was the best World Cup swimmer in the world in 2014 (and who had an impressive long course season as well).

After just one day of the World Short Course Championships, though, a third party has entered the mix: Spain’s Mireia Belmonte. She raced head-to-head with Hosszu in two individual event finals, and  not only beat Hosszu in both races (200 fly and 400 IM), she broke World Records in both by a second-or-more.

Yes, Hosszu broke World Records in 5 different events this year, and has a stronger World Cup resume, but Belmonte was also very good at the European Championships – she won two golds, two silvers, and two bronzes, including one in open water. Hosszu had more wins head-to-head in Berlin, though, so that’s still probably a check mark in her column.

Belmonte is already the World Record holder in both the 400 and 800 freestyles, which she has yet to swim at this meet. If she extends her success in the 200 fly and 400 IM to the 400 free and the 800 free, there’s no way those World Records stand. She would then have a chance in the 200 IM to make it five individual gold medals and at least four World Records.

Does that stand up to Hosszu’s year, where she became the all-time winningest swimmer in FINA World Cup history? Or to Ledecky’s, where she broke World Records in three events and won 5 golds at Pan Pacs?

With three swimmers who had such wildly different years and no long course World Championship or Olympics, there’s not a clear-cut answer to the question as there was, say, that Phelps was the World Swimmer of the Year in 2008.

But it is a conversation worth having, and that will be had, as the rest of the World Championships evolve. If Hosszu wins a couple of golds and breaks a couple of records, then she’ll solidify her status. If Belmonte does that, though, the water will be even muddier.

At the very least, that conversation should have had a chance to happen – perhaps in future years, the awards season will wait until all of the considerations are in place.

In This Story

21
Leave a Reply

11 Comment threads
10 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
15 Comment authors
newest oldest most voted
fatsmcgee

Ledecky should have won. Imagine if Ledecky retired today. In twenty years from now people would still remember her as an all time great, and would (among other accomplishments) cite her boundary-shifting world records, many of which happened in 2014. Domniating the 400,800, and 1500 records in one year? Cmon! Imagine if Hosszu retired today. In 20 years, hardcore swim fans would remember her as a well rounded and versatile swimmer from the 2010s who had impressively masochistic meet schedules. Most would not remember her. Like it or not, short course accomplishments do not carry the weight of long course accomplishments. In my mind, setting three huge long course freestyle world records is roughly as important as getting 100000000000 world… Read more »

mcmflyguy

i’m still just baffled that you got a downvote. is it mandatory for everyone to get at least one down vote? btw I think your 101% correct with everything you said.

whoknows

Remember this is FINA! $$$$$$$$ TALKS!
No disrespect, her continued outstanding performances over two months resulted in $$$$$. Ka-ching Ho$$zu definitely “$wimmer of the year.”

Dave

SCM records are one thing, LCM records are something entirely different. Complete domination of every LCM freestyle event from the 200 to the 1,500 is yet another thing. How anyone could argue that Ledecky didn’t deserve the award is beyond me.

ERVINFORTHEWIN

Completely agree with u . Ledecky , female swimmer of the year hands down . Fina is not an impartial organization that only puts focus on real terrific accomplishments . So the choise is what ressembles Fina , nothing else . We , as hardcore swim fans would have chosen Ledecky without hesitation .

About Braden Keith

Braden Keith

Braden Keith is the Editor-in-Chief and a co-founder of SwimSwam.com. He first got his feet wet by building The Swimmers' Circle beginning in January 2010, and now comes to SwimSwam to use that experience and help build a new leader in the sport of swimming. Aside from his life on the InterWet, …

Read More »

Want to take your swimfandom to the next level?

Subscribe to SwimSwam Magazine!