The CSCAA released the official NCAA All-American lists for the 2013-2014 season this season. In order to be considered an NCAA All-American, the athlete has to finish in the top 8 in an individual or relay event at the NCAA Championships. Honorable Mention honors are given to the athletes who finished in places 9-16 at the NCAA Championships.
| Name | Institution | Gender | Affiliation | Honor |
| Adams, Margot | Alaska Fairbanks | Women | DII | First Team |
| Adams, Victoria | Alaska Fairbanks | Women | DII | First Team |
| Heller, Bente | Alaska Fairbanks | Women | DII | First Team |
| Nguyen, Thanh | Alaska Fairbanks | Women | DII | First Team |
| Lyons, Dani | Alaska Fairbanks | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Summers, Gabi | Alaska Fairbanks | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Mattar, Hannah | Ashland | Women | DII | First Team |
| Holder, Hueston | Ashland | Men | DII | First Team |
| Sanchis Peris, Sergio | Ashland | Men | DII | First Team |
| Sikatzki, Philipp | Ashland | Men | DII | First Team |
| Walters, Gregory | Ashland | Men | DII | First Team |
| Evans, Anna | Ashland | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Murphy, Kaylyn | Ashland | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Reidler, Sara | Ashland | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Verdugo-Arzaluz, Gabriela | Ashland | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Sheil, Alexander | Ashland | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Mancini, Nicola | Bentley | Women | DII | First Team |
| Brooker, Rachel | Bloomsburg | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Gilson, Brooke | Bloomsburg | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Dumur, Armony | Bridgeport | Women | DII | First Team |
| Martin, Adeline | Bridgeport | Women | DII | First Team |
| Melnikova, Polina | Bridgeport | Women | DII | First Team |
| Shepel, Tatiana | Bridgeport | Women | DII | First Team |
| Sotnikova, Alina | Bridgeport | Women | DII | First Team |
| Taskin, Jaimy | Bridgeport | Women | DII | First Team |
| Capan, Ivan | Bridgeport | Men | DII | First Team |
| Fattakhov, Vyacheslav | Bridgeport | Men | DII | First Team |
| Gimenez, Ruben | Bridgeport | Men | DII | First Team |
| Matsuyama, Didac | Bridgeport | Men | DII | First Team |
| Nunez, Antonio | Bridgeport | Men | DII | First Team |
| Paskas, Vladislav | Bridgeport | Men | DII | First Team |
| Pereiro, Oscar | Bridgeport | Men | DII | First Team |
| Sangines, Ivan | Bridgeport | Men | DII | First Team |
| Shchekleina, Elena | Bridgeport | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Hanson, Mary | Cal Baptist | Women | DII | First Team |
| Hapsari, Patricia | Cal Baptist | Women | DII | First Team |
| Rumiantceva, Alena | Cal Baptist | Women | DII | First Team |
| Terwilliger, Kyndal | Cal Baptist | Women | DII | First Team |
| Barrows, Elijah | Cal Baptist | Men | DII | First Team |
| Brown, Nolan | Cal Baptist | Men | DII | First Team |
| Hanson, Joshua | Cal Baptist | Men | DII | First Team |
| Golden, Hailey | Cal Baptist | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Megli, Anna | Cal Baptist | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Skinner, Lauren | Cal Baptist | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Tchernyschev, Kristina | Cal Baptist | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Day, Kristin | Clarion | Women | DII | First Team |
| Zerfoss, Sarah | Clarion | Women | DII | First Team |
| Brandenburg, Seth | Clarion | Men | DII | First Team |
| Calhoun, Heath | Clarion | Men | DII | First Team |
| Larmon, Nicholas | Clarion | Men | DII | First Team |
| Vest, Collin | Clarion | Men | DII | First Team |
| Schaffer, Gabriella | Clarion | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Slayton, Lauren | Clarion | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Purkapile, Briana | Colorado Mesa | Women | DII | First Team |
| Martin, Brock | Colorado Mesa | Men | DII | First Team |
| Jennings, Amanda | Colorado Mesa | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Brinton, Jarren | Colorado Mesa | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Hastings, Justin | Colorado Mesa | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Olsen-Stavrakas, Kent | Colorado Mesa | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Denise, Caitlin | CSU East Bay | Women | DII | First Team |
| Hauanio, Madison-Gail | CSU East Bay | Women | DII | First Team |
| Rojo, Brittany | CSU East Bay | Women | DII | First Team |
| Tenney, Alyssa | CSU East Bay | Women | DII | First Team |
| Alboro, Kamaehu | CSU East Bay | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Schuck, Makila | CSU East Bay | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Klyarovskaya, Anastasia | Delta State | Women | DII | First Team |
| Tombers, Melanie | Delta State | Women | DII | First Team |
| Fraschi, Matteo | Delta State | Men | DII | First Team |
| Nys, Yvan | Delta State | Men | DII | First Team |
| Wendel, Fabrice | Delta State | Men | DII | First Team |
| Zinca, Vlad | Delta State | Men | DII | First Team |
| Bennett, Chloe | Delta State | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Dugas, Danielle | Delta State | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Meerholz, Danielle | Delta State | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Page, Kierstin | Delta State | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Stroven, Kirsten | Delta State | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Iles, William | Delta State | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Swaine, Matt | Delta State | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Zorn, Nicholas | Delta State | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Andrews, Tinsley | Drury | Women | DII | First Team |
| Gieseke, Kaylan | Drury | Women | DII | First Team |
| Laupp, Rebekah | Drury | Women | DII | First Team |
| Ostrowska, Agnieszka | Drury | Women | DII | First Team |
| Ottaviano, Hilary | Drury | Women | DII | First Team |
| Pullen, Sarah | Drury | Women | DII | First Team |
| Reed, Leah | Drury | Women | DII | First Team |
| Rudenko, Yakaterina | Drury | Women | DII | First Team |
| Tilton, Tessa | Drury | Women | DII | First Team |
| Yu, Wai Ting | Drury | Women | DII | First Team |
| Alkhaldi, Fahad | Drury | Men | DII | First Team |
| Borja, Banjo | Drury | Men | DII | First Team |
| Feher, Sean | Drury | Men | DII | First Team |
| Kowal, Igor | Drury | Men | DII | First Team |
| Kuzmin, Stanislav | Drury | Men | DII | First Team |
| Lloyd, Albert | Drury | Men | DII | First Team |
| McCarthy, Nicholas | Drury | Men | DII | First Team |
| Montseny Diez, Jordi Joan | Drury | Men | DII | First Team |
| Morris, Alec | Drury | Men | DII | First Team |
| Olson, Samuel | Drury | Men | DII | First Team |
| Pelczynski, Kacper | Drury | Men | DII | First Team |
| Ross, Walter | Drury | Men | DII | First Team |
| Rzadkowski, Daniel | Drury | Men | DII | First Team |
| Wong, David | Drury | Men | DII | First Team |
| Reynolds, Allie | Drury | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Staab, Chelsea | Drury | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Stein, Gretchen | Drury | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Allard, Jesse | Drury | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Karu, Fred | Drury | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Stein, Holly | Edinboro | Women | DII | First Team |
| Tekin, Goezde | Edinboro | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Komadina, Pasko | Fairmont | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Holmstrom, Kaley | Findlay | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Ward, Jessica | Findlay | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Burns, Heather | Florida Southern | Women | DII | First Team |
| Crenshaw, Allison | Florida Southern | Women | DII | First Team |
| Gouge, Kelsey | Florida Southern | Women | DII | First Team |
| Ley, Cassandra | Florida Southern | Women | DII | First Team |
| Reynolds, Lauren | Florida Southern | Women | DII | First Team |
| Edwards, Zachary | Florida Southern | Men | DII | First Team |
| Garrastazu, Raul | Florida Southern | Men | DII | First Team |
| Gutierrez, Allan | Florida Southern | Men | DII | First Team |
| Lima, Edson | Florida Southern | Men | DII | First Team |
| Lupoli, Franco | Florida Southern | Men | DII | First Team |
| Marin, Jesus | Florida Southern | Men | DII | First Team |
| Nguyen, Thomas | Florida Southern | Men | DII | First Team |
| Rojas, Luis | Florida Southern | Men | DII | First Team |
| Rowe, Spencer | Florida Southern | Men | DII | First Team |
| Swan, Robert | Florida Southern | Men | DII | First Team |
| Tolosa, Juan | Florida Southern | Men | DII | First Team |
| Ballard, Alex | Florida Southern | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Gimenez, Diego | Florida Southern | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Fedorchenko, Denys | Gannon | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Falconer, Meghan | Grand Valley | Women | DII | First Team |
| Madsen, Caitlyn | Grand Valley | Women | DII | First Team |
| Roeser, Sarah | Grand Valley | Women | DII | First Team |
| Vallier, Danielle | Grand Valley | Women | DII | First Team |
| Wiercinski, Taylor | Grand Valley | Women | DII | First Team |
| Ferrero, Gianni | Grand Valley | Men | DII | First Team |
| Griffith, Michael | Grand Valley | Men | DII | First Team |
| Gunderson, Kyle | Grand Valley | Men | DII | First Team |
| Kardol, Sven | Grand Valley | Men | DII | First Team |
| Marken, Aaron | Grand Valley | Men | DII | First Team |
| Medo, Milan | Grand Valley | Men | DII | First Team |
| Wagner, Nathan | Grand Valley | Men | DII | First Team |
| Zacek, Nicholas | Grand Valley | Men | DII | First Team |
| Eaton, Emily | Grand Valley | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Marquardt, Kayla | Grand Valley | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Schultz, Olivia | Grand Valley | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Vulpetti, Katie | Grand Valley | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Aakesson, Erik | Grand Valley | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Abbott, Daniel | Grand Valley | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Kurtz, Rachael | Hillsdale | Women | DII | First Team |
| Janosky, Aniella | Indiana-PA | Women | DII | First Team |
| Janosky, Christina | Indiana-PA | Women | DII | First Team |
| Mitidieri, Allyson | Indiana-PA | Women | DII | First Team |
| Snyder, Taylor | Indiana-PA | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Long, Stephen | Indiana-PA | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Chan, Daniel | Indianapolis | Men | DII | First Team |
| Madeira, Julia | Indianapolis | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Barbosa, Bruno | Indianapolis | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Demirtas, Musaffer | Indianapolis | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Rossillo, Justin | Indianapolis | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Milinkovskyi, Julian | Lake Erie | Men | DII | First Team |
| Cizmar, Ivan | Lake Erie | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Byrne, Joshua | LeMoyne | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Clasby, Montana | Lewis | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Kenis, Sarah | Lewis | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Hickey, Rachel | Limestone | Women | DII | First Team |
| Reh, Emily | Limestone | Women | DII | First Team |
| Feigl, Tobias | Limestone | Men | DII | First Team |
| Gunn, Sean | Limestone | Men | DII | First Team |
| Larsen, Christian | Limestone | Men | DII | First Team |
| Trigo, Douglas | Limestone | Men | DII | First Team |
| McGillivray, Alecia | Lindenwood | Women | DII | First Team |
| Troxel, Kyleigh | Lindenwood | Women | DII | First Team |
| Borowicz Skoneczny, Sylweste | Lindenwood | Men | DII | First Team |
| Vinyard, Hannah | Lindenwood | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Wayne, Carleen | Lindenwood | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Werkema, Shelby | Lindenwood | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Cochran, David | Lindenwood | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Eigel, Felix | Lindenwood | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Hohenberger, Schyler | Lindenwood | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Mijatovic, Igor | Lindenwood | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Pacholczyk, Mateusz | Lindenwood | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Paknys, Ramunas | Lindenwood | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Silva Santa, Gustavo | Lindenwood | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Delehanty, Courtney | LIU Post | Women | DII | First Team |
| Garriock, Tamara | LIU Post | Women | DII | First Team |
| Jones, Seren | LIU Post | Women | DII | First Team |
| Kwok, Joyce | LIU Post | Women | DII | First Team |
| Brazier, Meghan | LIU Post | Women | DII | First Team |
| Pettersson, Johanna | LIU Post | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Rademacher, Annina | LIU Post | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Sorenson, Marthe | LIU Post | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Carmigniani, Thalie | Lynn | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Potgieter, Tyne | Lynn | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Dugger, Shayna | Minnesota-Moorhead | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Glaser, Jonathan | Missouri S & T | Men | DII | First Team |
| Goldfarb, Ethan | Missouri S & T | Men | DII | First Team |
| Kerc, Aljaz | Missouri S & T | Men | DII | First Team |
| Norris, Luke | Missouri S & T | Men | DII | First Team |
| Sponsler, Keith | Missouri S & T | Men | DII | First Team |
| Green, Emily | Msu Mankato | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Borchardt, Rachel | Northern Michigan | Women | DII | First Team |
| Kearney, Molly | Northern Michigan | Women | DII | First Team |
| Lawrence, Deborah | Northern Michigan | Women | DII | First Team |
| Bennet, Crystal | Northern Michigan | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Bourguignon, Emily | Northern Michigan | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Dowling, Tara | Northern Michigan | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Sechena, Madisen | Northern Michigan | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Aldabe, Marco | Nova Southneastern | Men | DII | First Team |
| Chapple, Lauren | Nova Southneastern | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Aldabe, Oscar | Nova Southneastern | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Chambers, Cameron | Nova Southneastern | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Kleinbeck, Shane | Nova Southneastern | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Lundgren, Magnus | Nova Southneastern | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Mehlan, Florian | Nova Southneastern | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Simpson, Esau | Nova Southneastern | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Turkin, Dmytro | Pfeiffer | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Arakelian, Caroline | Queens | Women | DII | First Team |
| Boudreaux, Meridith | Queens | Women | DII | First Team |
| Diemer, Kristin | Queens | Women | DII | First Team |
| Durante, Emma | Queens | Women | DII | First Team |
| Gordy, Lillian | Queens | Women | DII | First Team |
| Knight, Shane | Queens | Women | DII | First Team |
| Marshall, Lara | Queens | Women | DII | First Team |
| Mock, Lauren | Queens | Women | DII | First Team |
| Peiffer, Hannah | Queens | Women | DII | First Team |
| Wallmon, Madeleine | Queens | Women | DII | First Team |
| Eriksson, Niclas | Queens | Men | DII | First Team |
| Gibson, Evante | Queens | Men | DII | First Team |
| Josa, Matthew | Queens | Men | DII | First Team |
| Kosater, Hayden | Queens | Men | DII | First Team |
| Menke, Alex | Queens | Men | DII | First Team |
| Oliveira, Felipe | Queens | Men | DII | First Team |
| Phelps, Zachary | Queens | Men | DII | First Team |
| Taylor, Benjamin | Queens | Men | DII | First Team |
| Traystman, Harry | Queens | Men | DII | First Team |
| Johnston, Kathryn | Queens | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Sumrall, Austin | Queens | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Weber, Nicole | Saint Leo | Women | DII | First Team |
| Assis, Matheus | Saint Leo | Men | DII | First Team |
| Ceddia, Patrick | Saint Leo | Men | DII | First Team |
| Keown, Gabriel | Saint Leo | Men | DII | First Team |
| Requejo, Milton | Saint Leo | Men | DII | First Team |
| Martinez, Stephanie | Saint Leo | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Name | School | Women | DII | First Team |
| Cossey, Nicole | Simon Fraser | Women | DII | First Team |
| Nam, Carmen | Simon Fraser | Women | DII | First Team |
| Schofield, Alexandria | Simon Fraser | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Swistak, Lauren | Simon Fraser | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Cswerko, Raymond | Southern Connecticut | Men | DII | First Team |
| Renzo, Jes | Southern Connecticut | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Bryson, Alex | St. Cloud State | Men | DII | First Team |
| Magalis, Tyler | St. Cloud State | Men | DII | First Team |
| Rooney, Aaron | St. Cloud State | Men | DII | First Team |
| Hart, Erin | St. Cloud State | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Leeson, Kelsey | St. Cloud State | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Mikrut, Lindsey | St. Cloud State | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Rasmussen, Abby | St. Cloud State | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Woodson, Mary | St. Cloud State | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Sufficool, David | St. Cloud State | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Glenday, Heather | Tampa | Women | DII | First Team |
| Hipolito, Alexandra | Tampa | Women | DII | First Team |
| Murphy, Briana | Tampa | Women | DII | First Team |
| Plachy, Erin | Tampa | Women | DII | First Team |
| Aldaboos, Khalid | Tampa | Men | DII | First Team |
| Augier, Jordan | Tampa | Men | DII | First Team |
| Borgen, Runar | Tampa | Men | DII | First Team |
| Burdis, Karl | Tampa | Men | DII | First Team |
| Hammer, Martin | Tampa | Men | DII | First Team |
| Nordenberg, Philip | Tampa | Men | DII | First Team |
| Parker, Jeremy | Tampa | Men | DII | First Team |
| Parker, Catherine | Tampa | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Hranac, Zane | Tampa | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Phieffer, Damen | Tampa | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Doss, Kyle | Tiffin | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Guardado, Brynn | Truman State | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Jepsen, Casey | Truman State | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Spencer, Evyn | Truman State | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Van Oost, Kristin | Truman State | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Amog, Jaclyn | UC-San Diego | Women | DII | First Team |
| Bryan, Jaimie | UC-San Diego | Women | DII | First Team |
| Daley, Colleen | UC-San Diego | Women | DII | First Team |
| Hon, Sandy | UC-San Diego | Women | DII | First Team |
| Lee, Austine | UC-San Diego | Women | DII | First Team |
| Robbins, Sierra | UC-San Diego | Women | DII | First Team |
| Shakya, Anjali | UC-San Diego | Women | DII | First Team |
| Tang, Natalie | UC-San Diego | Women | DII | First Team |
| Thomas, Naomi | UC-San Diego | Women | DII | First Team |
| Woo, Catherine | UC-San Diego | Women | DII | First Team |
| Calkins, Luke | UC-San Diego | Men | DII | First Team |
| Galvan, Jack | UC-San Diego | Men | DII | First Team |
| Heale, Arthur | UC-San Diego | Men | DII | First Team |
| Jacobs, Julian | UC-San Diego | Men | DII | First Team |
| Korth, Nicholas | UC-San Diego | Men | DII | First Team |
| Malley, Sean | UC-San Diego | Men | DII | First Team |
| McCallum, Reid | UC-San Diego | Men | DII | First Team |
| Pourvahidi, Chandler | UC-San Diego | Men | DII | First Team |
| Yong, Zachary | UC-San Diego | Men | DII | First Team |
| Gage, Sierra | UC-San Diego | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Li, Paul | UC-San Diego | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Mitrushina, Alexander | UC-San Diego | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Nadler, Kyle | UC-San Diego | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Azambuja, Ana | Wayne State | Women | DII | First Team |
| Ferreira, Manuela | Wayne State | Women | DII | First Team |
| Geddis, Alex | Wayne State | Women | DII | First Team |
| Kortman, Paige | Wayne State | Women | DII | First Team |
| Maleski, Ellyson | Wayne State | Women | DII | First Team |
| Martinez Perez, Gloria | Wayne State | Women | DII | First Team |
| Novichenko, Kristina | Wayne State | Women | DII | First Team |
| Prentis, Kei | Wayne State | Women | DII | First Team |
| Rawlings, Elizabeth | Wayne State | Women | DII | First Team |
| Scott, Kayla | Wayne State | Women | DII | First Team |
| Barthel, Till | Wayne State | Men | DII | First Team |
| Fernandez Vilanova, Lucas | Wayne State | Men | DII | First Team |
| Hansen, Jayson | Wayne State | Men | DII | First Team |
| Holm, Soren | Wayne State | Men | DII | First Team |
| Jachowicz, Piotr | Wayne State | Men | DII | First Team |
| Larsen, Kristian | Wayne State | Men | DII | First Team |
| Molina Perez, Juan David | Wayne State | Men | DII | First Team |
| Szegedi, Dylan | Wayne State | Men | DII | First Team |
| Heitchue, Emily | Wayne State | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Krill, Holly | Wayne State | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Maraskine, Emily | Wayne State | Women | DII | First Team |
| Littell, Adam | Wayne State | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Reder, Calvin | Wayne State | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Barone, Mia | West Chester | Women | DII | First Team |
| Barron, Danielle | West Chester | Women | DII | First Team |
| Carastro, Lauren | West Chester | Women | DII | First Team |
| Fischer, Katharina | West Chester | Women | DII | First Team |
| Hayward, Theresa | West Chester | Women | DII | First Team |
| Somer, Kendall | West Chester | Women | DII | First Team |
| Stang, Emily | West Chester | Women | DII | First Team |
| Winslow, Megan | West Chester | Women | DII | First Team |
| Grebenyuk, Bogdan | West Chester | Men | DII | First Team |
| Haley, Jared | West Chester | Men | DII | First Team |
| Letcavage, Philip | West Chester | Men | DII | First Team |
| McCormick, David | West Chester | Men | DII | First Team |
| Parker, Christian | West Chester | Men | DII | First Team |
| Polyakov, Victor | West Chester | Men | DII | First Team |
| Strathmeyer, Bradley | West Chester | Men | DII | First Team |
| McNichol, Kassandra | West Chester | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Murtaugh, Codyanne | West Chester | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Walley, Alexis | West Chester | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Cengia, Tim | West Chester | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| De Villiers, Peggy | West Florida | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Macht, Anna | West Florida | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Mitchell, Emily | West Florida | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Robles, Carla | West Florida | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Arkhipova, Viktoriya | Wingate | Women | DII | First Team |
| Dembny, Valerie | Wingate | Women | DII | First Team |
| Fish, Ana | Wingate | Women | DII | First Team |
| Gervas, Kellie | Wingate | Women | DII | First Team |
| Gilbert, Amanda | Wingate | Women | DII | First Team |
| Petrenko, Sofia | Wingate | Women | DII | First Team |
| Pheil, Kathryn | Wingate | Women | DII | First Team |
| Weiss, Jessika | Wingate | Women | DII | First Team |
| Blazevski, Marko | Wingate | Men | DII | First Team |
| Johnson, Dylon | Wingate | Men | DII | First Team |
| Kanyuka, Roman | Wingate | Men | DII | First Team |
| Kluever, Leif-Henning | Wingate | Men | DII | First Team |
| Kniffler, Tim | Wingate | Men | DII | First Team |
| Zeraidi, Issam | Wingate | Men | DII | First Team |
| Arzadon, Jasmine | Wingate | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Koryukova, Rita | Wingate | Women | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Collum, David | Wingate | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Kolovich, Evan | Wingate | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
| Kosheleva, Olga | Wingate | Men | DII | Honorable Mention |
