Misty Hyman Dethrones “Madame Butterfly” at the 2000 Sydney Games

This piece was originally published over at YourSwimBook.com. Join Olivier’s weekly newsletter and receive twice-a-week motivational emails designed specifically for competitive swimmers.

Sydney, Australia – September 20, 2000

For the country of Australia, the Sydney Olympics in the pool were a crushing success.

Ian Thorpe dominated the pool in the mid distance events. Grant Hackett took the mantle from distance legend Kieren Perkins to crush the mile, the Aussies going 1-2. The men won the 4x100m freestyle relay to dethrone the Americans in an event they had never lost in the Olympic program.

While the Aussies weren’t as strong on the women’s side, they did have one swimmer who had attained legendary status in the swimming-crazed nation.

Susie O’Neill, or “Madame Butterfly” as she was known.

O’Neill had completely owned her best event, the 200m butterfly stroke for the previous six years, including a gold medal at the 1996 Atlanta Olympics. Several months earlier, in the same Sydney pool, she had broken American Mary T. Meagher’s long standing world record (nearly 20 years).

On top of being the undisputed champ in the 200 fly, earlier that week in Sydney she had also won the 200m freestyle, further catapulting the home nation’s hopes of butterfly gold.

In the final that night O’Neill qualified first, with countrywoman Petria Thomas above her lane 5. With all eyes on the Aussies—the thundering ovation O’Neill received when introduced left no doubt to who the sell out crowd was backing—it was easy to overlook the smiling American in lane 6.

Misty Hyman Goes Ballistic

To understand just how radical Hyman and her powerful underwater dolphin kick were at the time it is important to understand how underwater kicking was regarded during that period.

Even then, in the year 2000, the underwater dolphin kick was viewed as an aberration, the black sheep, a skill that was poorly understood and rarely implemented in training.

While most swimmers nowadays accept that the UDK is part-and-parcel with every event from the 50m splash-and-dash to even some of the distance events, back then it wasn’t.

Even in the butterfly events.

Hyman had been a practitioner of the extended underwater dolphin kicking since 1993, emulating some of the other top butterfliers in the world, including Mel Stewart and Denis Pankratov.

Inspired by an article in Scientific American that showed fish could used spinning eddies to increase the velocity they attained under the water, Hyman’s coach Bob Gillette at the Arizona Desert Fox Swim Team applied this to Hyman’s dolphin kick and had her turn on her side.

It didn’t come without difficulty, however, taking her about a year to get used to kicking on her side, especially trying to maintain a straight line as there was no black line to stare at as a point of reference.

To build up the powerful legs required to maintain the power and velocity—particularly for the grueling 200m long course distance—Hyman worked relentlessly doing underwater work with and without a monofin.

In defending the emphasis on the underwater kick, Hyman explained herself well:

I’m not six feet tall, and for me to compete, I have to do it the best way for me. Skill and innovation were what got me to this level. My coach and I developed this and we’re not breaking any rules. In fact, lots of people are doing the underwater. I think it would be a shame if they changed the rule (to limit the distance of the underwater kick) but if they did I would just have to change my training.

In the winter of 1996 Hyman put her powerhouse legs to work, dropping nearly half a second off of the world record in the 100m butterfly (SCM) in Sainte-Foy, Quebec, using her trademark kick.

Despite this performance, there weren’t many who were expecting Hyman to dethrone the reigning Queen of the butterfly that September in Australia.

Especially not in Sydney.

Especially not in a long course pool, where the effect of Hyman’s superior underwaters would be halved compared to the short course pool.

And especially not in the taxing distance of the 200m butterfly.

SEE ALSO: 5 Reasons You Should Be Working On Your Underwater Fly Kick

September 20, 2000

When the finalists left the block that night Hyman was the slowest to react.

Despite this, she kicked out to nearly 15m and popped up in a slight lead with Thomas in 5.

Off the 50m wall Hyman gained a half body length lead on Thomas, and nearly a body length on O’Neill.

Even though Hyman didn’t kick out the full 15m on subsequent walls, including the third turn, where she pumped out 7-8 kicks—which was good enough to push her out to around 12m—it still contrasted sharply against O’Neill who surfaced at 5m and breathed off her first stroke.

It was clear to see that any dent that O’Neill tried to make in between walls was quickly negated by Hyman’s powerful breakouts.

With O’Neill charging hard on the last 50m, Hyman didn’t relent, surfing into the wall in a time of 2:05.88, just 7/100’s off of O’Neill’s world record mark, but good enough to shave over a second off the former world record holder’s (Meagher) mark of 2:06.90.

For Hyman, who had battled the naysaying that comes with being viewed as a one-trick pony, and who had overcome the implementation of the 15m limit to how far swimmers could perform the kick underwater, the victory was nothing short of overwhelming.

The surprise, shock and joy that envelops her face as she realizes that she has won is a welcome surprise when many athletes would prefer to thump their chest or react with stoic blandness.

As she would recount after the race,

I’ve played it over so many times in my head, but I never thought it would come true.

Here is the race video from Sydney:
[youtube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3zUFLP40nGE?rel=0]

The Next Step

Want to take your dolphin kick to the next level?

I put together a comprehensive 3,000+ word guide on improving your underwater dolphin kick. From flexibility, to strength training, to technique (and even some bonus sets), you will learn everything you need to know about how to dolphin kick like a boss.

It includes tips and info from USA Swimming’s Russell Mark, Canadian Sport Institute-Ontario biomechanist Ryan Atkinson, The Race Club’s Gary Hall Sr., and SwimSwam’s own butterfly kick beast, Mel Stewart.

About YourSwimBook

YourSwimBook is a log book and goal setting guide designed specifically for competitive swimmers. It includes a ten month log book, comprehensive goal setting section, monthly evaluations to be filled out with your coach, and more. Here are 8 reasons why this tool kicks butt.

Join the YourSwimBook weekly newsletter group and get motivational tips, sarcasm and beard growing tips straight to your inbox. Sign up for free here.


Leave a Reply

Notify of

oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
4 years ago

she is such a good person my teacher knows her and she came to are school and it was sooooooooooooooooo fun

8 years ago

Mary T’s time was actually 2:05.96 I believe. The 2:06.9 you are referencing was her Olympic record from 1984.

8 years ago

That is one of my favorite Olympic moments of all time in any sport.

8 years ago

I love the reaction of Kaitlin Sandeno to Missy’s victory. She is truly very excited for her teammate.

Lane Four
Reply to  swimmermama
8 years ago

Kaitlin was always very much a people person – just as excited for your victories as her own.

Olivier Poirier-Leroy
Reply to  swimmermama
8 years ago

That really stood out for me as well when watching it.

8 years ago

This was always one of my favorite races. In prior swims Hyman was always ahead at the 125 and usually at the 150 but would fade that last 50. But in Sydney she had some Olympic magic and brought that last 50 home like I’d never seen her do before. It was awesome!!

8 years ago

Meagher’s best time is 2:05.9.

8 years ago

i watch this race at least once a month. so good. soooooooooooo good.

8 years ago

Amanda Beard carrying a teddy bear was a greater Olympic moment than this.

Reply to  AA
8 years ago

About Olivier Poirier-Leroy

Olivier Poirier-Leroy

Olivier Poirier-Leroy has been involved in competitive swimming for most of his life. Starting off at the age of 6 he was thrown in the water at the local pool for swim lessons and since then has never wanted to get out. A nationally top ranked age grouper as both a …

Read More »