SEC, Big Ten Withhold Support For Protect College Sports Act

The SEC and Big Ten have withheld support from the landmark bipartisan college sports bill introduced by Senators Ted Cruz and Maria Cantwell last week.

After getting backing from the ACC and Big 12 earlier this week, the Protect College Sports Act has drawn criticism from the NCAA’s two other Power conferences, at least as currently written, saying “the bill leaves critical issues unresolved” in a statement on Tuesday.

The SEC and Big Ten specifically pointed to the bill’s failure to “meaningfully preempt the patchwork of state laws or provide the protections needed to make and enforce consistent rules.”

Cruz and Cantwell told the Associated Press in an interview last week that “the bill is drafted to preempt state laws that conflict with the provisions in this bill.”

The Protect College Sports Act would establish national standards for athlete transfers, player eligibility rules, NIL enforcement and revenue sharing.

Key Bill Aspects:

  • One penalty-free transfer
  • Five-year eligibility model
  • Restricting former professionals from competing
  • Hard salary cap
  • 5% maximum agent fee
  • Prohibits the creation of a super league
  • Prohibits coaches from leaving their team before the season ends

It would also provide the NCAA with limited antitrust protection, shielding it from constant legal challenges over eligibility and transfer disputes.

The SEC and Big Ten, however, believe there are holes in the bill that will lead to more litigation, not less, the way it’s written.

There’s also the sticking point of media rights revenue, as the bill encourages conferences to negotiate TV rights collectively and distribute money if the majority of programs agree. While this may be beneficial for smaller conferences, the SEC and Big Ten are the two biggest conferences in the country and wouldn’t have much incentive to share revenue with others. This issue was not addressed in the statement, however.

Full Statement:

“The Big Ten Conference and the Southeastern Conference support a sustainable national framework for college sports – one with an effective transfer portal, clear eligibility standards, and protections and benefits for student-athletes. While we appreciate the leadership of Senators Cruz and Cantwell in pursuing these shared goals, we do not support the Protect College Sports Act as drafted.

“The bill leaves critical issues unresolved. It does not meaningfully preempt the patchwork of state laws or provide the protections needed to make and enforce consistent rules, both essential to long-term stability in college athletics. It also shifts ongoing rulemaking to Congress, limiting the ability to adapt quickly as the landscape evolves. Rather than reducing litigation, the bill likely expands it without offering clear alternatives for dispute resolution. Finally, the bill alters the House settlement revenue sharing framework in a way that may result in fewer student-athletes receiving direct revenue share payments.

“We are committed to working with Senators Cruz and Cantwell and other members of Congress to improve this legislation so that it can provide lasting stability for college athletics.”

ACC Commissioner Jim Phillips and Big 12 Commissioner Brett Yormark penned letters to Cruz and Cantwell on Sunday expressing their support for the bill, both thanking the Senators and telling them they look forward to continued collaboration on the matter.

American Conference Commissioner Tim Pernetti, and supporters of the “Saving college sports” movement, including several university presidents, also sent letters to lawmakers expressing their support.

A hearing before the Senate Commerce Committee is scheduled for Wednesday, which Yahoo SportsRoss Dellenger has described as “arguably the most significant hearing in the NCAA’s seven-year lobbying effort.”

8
Leave a Reply

Subscribe
Notify of

8 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
MigBike
2 days ago

The SEC is always correct on all topics…The BIG 10 occasionally.

WCNJCTNY
3 days ago

“Prohibits coaches from leaving their team before the season ends.”

Let me guess, though…schools can fire them before the season ends? Either it’s at-will, or not at-will. I don’t think that can be legislated through a bill.

SwimCoach
Reply to  WCNJCTNY
3 days ago

They call this the Lane Kiffin provision. It is amusing that how Kiffin leaving Ole Miss became a lightning rod topic the same season that James Franklin was fired not even halfway through the season immediately following a year his team made the semi-finals in the CFP, and 1 score away from the finals.

This bill is doomed to fail for so many different reasons.

Fishhead
3 days ago

Let’s be honest, it’s all about the TV money and keeping it for themselves. All the other stuff is window dressing.

Horninco
Reply to  Fishhead
3 days ago

As they should

YGBSM
Reply to  Horninco
3 days ago

Well, yes. But …..

Without a nationalized approach / policy / antitrust / guardrails, the conferences and schools will just keep up their bidding war for athletes in the revenue sports, selling tickets, and constantly searching for ways to ditch the non-revenue sports (or just poorly fund them to check a box).

So something has to be done to protect the non-revenue sports or in fact, they will go away eventually.

Horninco
Reply to  YGBSM
3 days ago

I agree but this isn’t charity, it’s business and has been for quite a long time

The genie is out of the bottle. We need a new bottle, not a new cap

Should Walmart share profits with the mom and pop shop on Main Street?

Should JP morgan share profits with a random credit union in Kansas?

Of course not, and Ohio State shouldn’t share revenue with Ohio University

Jimbo
Reply to  Horninco
3 days ago

To a certain extent, Ohio State does share with OU. It may be a law, or maybe just tradition, but one of the non conference home games is always against an Ohio college. Keep the appearance money in state.

About James Sutherland

James Sutherland

James swam five years at Laurentian University in Sudbury, Ontario, specializing in the 200 free, back and IM. He finished up his collegiate swimming career in 2018, graduating with a bachelor's degree in economics. In 2019 he completed his graduate degree in sports journalism. Prior to going to Laurentian, James swam …

Read More »