How Did We Do? Reviewing SwimSwam’s 2023 World Championship Predictions

2023 WORLD AQUATICS CHAMPIONSHIPS

With the 2023 World Championships wrapping up just over a week ago, it’s time to take a look back and see how SwimSwam’s pre-meet predictions stacked up against what actually transpired in Fukuoka.

PREDICTING THE MEDALISTS

Due to SwimSwam’s somewhat pedestrian 158th-place finish in the Pick ’em Contest, it’s clear everything didn’t go swimmingly regarding our picks performing as expected.

We still predicted 19 of 42 gold medalist correctly for a 45.2 percent rate (the exact same as last year), which came due in part to heavy bets on Katie LedeckySarah Sjostrom, Kaylee McKeown, Summer McIntosh and Leon Marchand, who we correctly predicted for two titles apiece.

On the flip side, both McKeown (200 IM) and McIntosh (400 free) were picked for gold in events they failed to reach the podium (in McKeown’s case, she was disqualified).

The men’s side proved to be extremely difficult to predict, as not only were just four gold medalists picked correctly, but there was also 12 races where none of our medalists finished where we predicted.

  • As a whole, 24 of the 60 female medalists (40 percent) were picked in the correct order while 44 of the 60 predicted medalists (73.3 percent) made it onto the podium but were not necessarily in the right spot.
  • For the men, just 14 of the 60 predicted medalists (23.3 percent) won the medal we picked, while 41 of the 60 predicted medalists (68.3 percent) made it onto the podium but not necessarily in the correct spot.

THE HITS

There were seven events in which we correctly predicted the podium (in the right order), with one slight caveat.

The women’s 100 back and 400 IM were picked correctly, while the other individual event that was bang on was the men’s 100 breast—there was a three-way tie for silver between Nic FinkArno Kamminga and Nicolo Martinenghi, but since we picked Fink for second and Kamminga for third, we’re going to call this one a hit.

We also picked four of the relays correctly, with the women’s free relays perhaps being the most obvious given Australia’s dominance and Canada’s lack of depth making US-China the clear pick for silver/bronze.

Correct Podiums

Event Gold Silver Bronze
W 100 back Kaylee McKeown (AUS) Regan Smith (USA) Katharine Berkoff (USA)
W 400 IM Summer McIntosh (CAN) Katie Grimes (USA) Jenna Forrester (AUS)
W 4×100 free relay Australia United States China
W 4×200 free relay Australia United States China
M 100 breast Qin Haiyang (CHN) Nic Fink (USA) Arno Kamminga (NED)
M 4×200 free relay Great Britain United States Australia
Mixed 4×100 free relay Australia United States Great Britain

In addition to those, there were two other events where we picked the gold and silver medalists correctly, both of which were more or less slam dunks: women’s 200 back (McKeown-Smith) and the men’s 400 IM (Marchand-Foster)—though Smith certainly had a good chance coming in.

THE MISSES

  • One of the major misses (and biggest surprises) of the championships came in the men’s freestyle events, particularly in the 100 and 200 free where defending champion David Popovici failed to reach the podium. We picked Popovici for gold in both events.
  • Florian Wellbrock was well off form and didn’t make the final of either the men’s 800 or 1500 free after we predicted him to win the mile and earn silver in the 800.
  • Of the 11 events in which our predicted gold medalist didn’t reach the podium, they were either fourth (McIntosh, Lilly King x2, Popivici’s 200 free) or fifth (Emma McKeon, Katharine Berkoff, Nicolo Martinenghi) the majority of the time, while McKeown (200 IM) and the British men’s 400 free relay were both DQed.
  • Lilly King underperformed relative to our predictions, having missed the podium in both the women’s 100 and 200 breast after she was tabbed for double gold.

See our full predictions vs results breakdown below.

WOMEN’S WORLD CHAMPIONSHIP PREDICTIONS

  • Swimmers predicted in the correct medal position in bold.
  • Swimmers correctly predicted on the podium but not in the correct medal position unbolded.
  • Swimmers predicted to reach the podium who failed to do so have a strike through their name.
Event Gold Silver Bronze
50 free Sarah Sjostrom (SWE) Abbey Weitzeil (USA) Shayna Jack (AUS)
100 free Emma McKeon (AUS) Siobhan Haughey (HKG) Kate Douglass (USA)
200 free Ariarne Titmus (AUS) Mollie O’Callaghan (AUS) Summer McIntosh (CAN)
400 free Summer McIntosh (CAN) Ariarne Titmus (AUS) Katie Ledecky (USA)
800 free Katie Ledecky (USA) Ariarne Titmus (AUS) Erika Fairweather (NZL)
1500 free Katie Ledecky (USA) Katie Grimes (USA) Lani Pallister (AUS)
50 back Katharine Berkoff (USA) Kylie Masse (CAN) Kaylee McKeown (AUS)
100 back Kaylee McKeown (AUS) Regan Smith (USA) Katharine Berkoff (USA)
200 back Kaylee McKeown (AUS) Regan Smith (USA) Rhyan White (USA)
50 breast Ruta Meilutyte (LTU) Benedetta Pilato (ITA) Lilly King (USA)
100 breast Lilly King (USA) Lydia Jacoby (USA) Tatjana Schoenmaker (RSA)
200 breast Lilly King (USA) Tatjana Schoenmaker (RSA) Kate Douglass (USA)
50 fly Sarah Sjostrom (SWE) Gretchen Walsh (USA) Melanie Henique (FRA)
100 fly Maggie MacNeil (CAN) Torri Huske (USA) Emma McKeon (AUS)
200 fly Summer McIntosh (CAN) Regan Smith (USA) Elizabeth Dekkers (AUS)
200 IM Kaylee McKeown (AUS) Kate Douglass (USA) Alex Walsh (USA)
400 IM Summer McIntosh (CAN) Katie Grimes (USA) Jenna Forrester (AUS)
4×100 free relay Australia United States China
4×200 free relay Australia United States China
4×100 medley relay United States Australia China

MEN’S WORLD CHAMPIONSHIP PREDICTIONS

  • Swimmers predicted in the correct medal position in bold.
  • Swimmers correctly predicted on the podium but not in the correct medal position unbolded.
  • Swimmers predicted to reach the podium who failed to do so have a strike through their name.
Event Gold Silver Bronze
50 free Ben Proud (GBR) Cameron McEvoy (AUS) Florent Manaudou (FRA)
100 free David Popovici (ROU) Kyle Chalmers (AUS) Josh Liendo (CAN)
200 free David Popovici (ROU) Hwang Sunwoo (KOR) Tom Dean (GBR)
400 free Elijah Winnington (AUS) Lukas Märtens (GER) Sam Short (AUS)
800 free Bobby Finke (USA) Florian Wellbrock (GER) Mykhailo Romanchuk (UKR)
1500 free Florian Wellbrock (GER) Bobby Finke (USA) Daniel Wiffen (IRL)
50 back Justin Ress (USA) Hunter Armstrong (USA) Thomas Ceccon (ITA)
100 back Thomas Ceccon (ITA) Hunter Armstrong (USA) Ryan Murphy (USA)
200 back Ryan Murphy (USA) Hubert Kos (HUN) Destin Lasco (USA)
50 breast Nicolo Martinenghi (ITA) Nic Fink (USA) Qin Haiyang (CHN)
100 breast Qin Haiyang (CHN) Nic Fink (USA) Arno Kamminga (NED)*
200 breast Zac Stubblety-Cook (AUS) Qin Haiyang (CHN) Ippei Watanabe (JPN)
50 fly Thomas Ceccon (ITA) Ben Proud (GBR) Maxime Grousset (FRA)
100 fly Josh Liendo (CAN) Dare Rose (USA) Noe Ponti (SUI)
200 fly Tomoru Honda (JPN) Leon Marchand (FRA) Carson Foster (USA)
200 IM Leon Marchand (FRA) Wang Shun (CHN) Carson Foster (USA)
400 IM Leon Marchand (FRA) Carson Foster (USA) Chase Kalisz (USA)
4×100 free relay Great Britain United States Australia
4×200 free relay Great Britain United States Australia
4×100 medley relay United States Italy China

MIXED RELAY PREDICTIONS

Event Gold Silver Bronze
4×100 free relay Australia United States Great Britain
4×100 medley relay United States China Australia

PREDICTING THE MEDAL TABLE

Not to spark any debate, but we’re going to solely look at the medal total per country in this brief analysis.

The United States was predicted to win 45 medals, the amount they won last year, but they fell to 38, while the Australians essentially matched our prediction with 25 medals compared to 26 predicted. With 13 of those turning out to be gold, it was certainly a standout showing for the Aussies (we picked them for 10 golds).

Among the other nations, China was a big story throughout the competition after outperforming expectations, earning seven more medals than we predicted.

Due to the performances of Popovici and Wellbrock, Romania and Germany won two fewer medals than we predicted, while the biggest jump up was Tunisia, who had Ahmed Hafnaoui stunningly secure three medals, including two golds, in the men’s distance events.

Actual vs Predicted Medal Table (Total Medals Only)

Nation SwimSwam Predicted Medal Total Actual Total Difference
United States 45 38 -7
Australia 26 25 -1
China 9 16 +7
Great Britain 6 8 +2
Canada 8 6 -2
Italy 6 6
France 6 6
Netherlands 1 3 +2
Tunisia 0 3 +3
Sweden 2 2
South Africa 2 2
Japan 2 2
Lithuania 1 2 +1
Germany 3 1 -2
Hungary 1 1
Hong Kong 1 1
New Zealand 1 1
Switzerland 1 1
South Korea 1 1
Portugal 0 1 +1
Poland 0 1 +1
Ireland 1 0 -1
Ukraine 1 0 -1
Romania 2 0 -2

In This Story

33
Leave a Reply

Subscribe
Notify of

33 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Torchbearer
10 months ago

3 Olympics is a good run….only freaks get to their 4th or 5th, and not so long ago 3 seemed like a lot.
Thorpe only made it to 2 for example….

Troyy
10 months ago

Aussie media are reporting that Chalmers will retire after Paris. There’s gonna be quite a large exodus from the Dolphins next year 🥺

Fraser Thorpe
Reply to  Troyy
10 months ago

Yeah with no Chalmers it’s gunna hurt

Mark69
Reply to  Troyy
10 months ago

I don’t think there will be a mass exodus. Kyle had said in 2017 that he would retire after Tokyo, so I don’t think his announcement today is much of a shock. Emma will probably retire, and obviously C1 and C2, but they are no certainties to even make the 2024 team. Probably Madi Wilson and Brianna Throssell, although if the ISL does come back they may swim on (they both took part in that). I know the media construed things Ariarne said after trials to mean she would retire after Paris, but I think she just meant that she, like many swimmers, would reassess her plans after an Olympics. There are plenty of Aussie swimmers (most of them from… Read more »

Southerly Buster
Reply to  Mark69
10 months ago

I’m pretty sure Madi Wilson said she wanted to start a family after the Olympics (can’t remember where I heard it from). If so, that could be 4 or 5 of the 4×100 Free regulars leaving after Olympics but with MOC, Jack & Harris swimming faster than ever that only leaves one spot needed in the top 4. Wunsch, Casey or Jansen presumably.

Mark69
Reply to  Southerly Buster
10 months ago

Or Perkins, Jacobson or O’Leary.

Southerly Buster
Reply to  Mark69
10 months ago

Yes, also Jamie de Lutiis who comes from the same part of Australia that gave us Emma McKeon.

Troyy
Reply to  Southerly Buster
10 months ago

Same club even.

Miss M
Reply to  Troyy
10 months ago

Kyle has said that for a while, so it’s not really a big surprise.

Mark69
Reply to  Miss M
10 months ago

And, as has been noted elsewhere, he has clarified that all he meant today was that 2024 would be his last Olympics, not that he was going to retire in August 2024.

Troyy
Reply to  Troyy
10 months ago

Chalmers has clarified that he won’t retire after Paris but it’ll probably be his last Olympics: https://www.instagram.com/p/CvtLBeohRhm/

I really wanna see Chalmers, McEvoy and two of the women in the mixed free in 2015!

Last edited 10 months ago by Troyy
Mark69
Reply to  Troyy
10 months ago

I think they could go 3.17.5 in 2025. Their current WR IS 3.18.8.

Emily Se-Bom Lee
Reply to  Troyy
10 months ago

every media source said paris would be his last competition, but newscorp took this a step further and marked it as a “shock retirement”, which gives it no timeframe and implies that it’s effective immediately.

Fraser Thorpe
10 months ago

Unrelated – so just putting this here.

Swim Stats just posted on Insta the youngest swimmers to win back to back titles at world champs. Among them is András Hargitay.

If you go to the ‘73 champs you’ll see the mens results are – across the board – are very close to the results from the women’s results from this year.

But while the 100 fly is close to the current WR, the mens Time is 2:01.8. Seems strange to have such a discrepancy compared to textile bests. Especially when the other swims requiring stamina and strength (400 free, 1500 free and 400IM) were all slower in ‘73 than women now.

Probably not a coincidence that those are all the… Read more »

jeff
Reply to  Fraser Thorpe
10 months ago

you mean backstroke? The 200 back winning time was 2:01.8 and the 200 fly time was 2:03.3 (200 free/breast times were 1:53.0 and 2:19.2 for reference).

Fraser Thorpe
Reply to  jeff
10 months ago

Ah you’re right – I’d gotten mixed up with 1975.

Still in ‘75 the 100 fly was 55.6 and the 200 fly was 2:01.9. And the rest of the results are still similar to women’s from this year (though the freestyle – except the 1500 – had moved ahead) – so I’m still surprised the 200 fly is so much faster.

23/51/1:52
Reply to  Fraser Thorpe
10 months ago

Also for both sexes distance events dominate, sprinting really relies on maturity.
On the women’s side, discounting the GDR dopers MOC is the youngest sprinter to do it, plus the only non GDR to do the 100/200 double globally LCM, which she also just missed last year in a weak field. Last year was the mature swimmer winning, but a lot has changed in a year.

Swimfast315
10 months ago

smoliga posted a controversial video about cate campbell, referencing the cowbell on instagram. and there were several comments from team usa swimmers

chickenlamp
Reply to  Swimfast315
10 months ago

lol I love it. I still find all of this hilarious. Bobby Finke talked about recently in an interview as well: https://youtu.be/KneE2ihfuY0?t=2841

23/51/1:52
Reply to  chickenlamp
10 months ago

Relay names guy got mentioned. Proud moment for us all.

Sub13
Reply to  23/51/1:52
10 months ago

Lol when! I watched the rest of the interview from the marked part but didn’t hear it. What did they say?

chickenlamp
Reply to  Sub13
10 months ago

Finke said he reads Swim Swam articles, comments and all, and called out relay names guy: https://youtu.be/KneE2ihfuY0?t=2734

Last edited 10 months ago by chickenlamp
Noah
Reply to  chickenlamp
10 months ago

45:50 time mark

Sub13
Reply to  chickenlamp
10 months ago

Oh that’s so funny!

bubbles
Reply to  chickenlamp
10 months ago

i wonder whether being called out by an olympic champion will change his ways lol

Joel
Reply to  Swimfast315
10 months ago

Did she say that the cowbell was completely disrespectful to other teams in warm up?

Caeleb Remel Cultist
Reply to  Swimfast315
10 months ago

Washed up Smoliga trying to stay relevant in 2023…

bubbles
Reply to  Caeleb Remel Cultist
10 months ago

she set a pb in the 100 free

Sub13
Reply to  Swimfast315
10 months ago

Do you have a link to it?

Swimfast315
Reply to  Sub13
10 months ago
Sub13
Reply to  Swimfast315
10 months ago

The post you linked doesn’t mention Campbell at all. Has she edited/removed it?

EDIT: unless you just mean the cowbell is implied to be about Campbell? I don’t care about the swimmers joking about the cow bell. The whole situation was so ridiculous and blown up by idiots. Swimmers joking about it on Insta is a good thing IMO

Last edited 10 months ago by Sub13
Hooked on Chlorine
Reply to  Swimfast315
10 months ago

“Smoglia” sounds like a highly toxic industrial waste product.

CasualSwimmer
10 months ago

Nooooo not the total medal controversy again

About James Sutherland

James Sutherland

James swam five years at Laurentian University in Sudbury, Ontario, specializing in the 200 free, back and IM. He finished up his collegiate swimming career in 2018, graduating with a bachelor's degree in economics. In 2019 he completed his graduate degree in sports journalism. Prior to going to Laurentian, James swam …

Read More »