Proposed Plan Has 50m Stroke Events Removed From Canadian Junior Nationals

In April Swimming Canada released a document citing a complete overhaul of the competition structure within the country. The changes outlined in the document will be effective starting in 2017 until 2020, pending review. Find a full summary of the changes here.

None of this has become official, and is still an ongoing process.

Among these changes is the elimination of stroke 50m events (butterfly, backstroke and breaststroke) from the Junior Nationals (formerly known as the Age Group Championships).

In the main document in the Executive Summary, section 2.4 Key Improvements includes at #10: “50m events for Butterfly, Backstroke and Breaststroke will be removed from the Canadian Junior Championships.”

This appeared to indicate that they were removing the events from just the Canadian Junior Championships like the United States does (the only 50m event they have at their Junior Nationals is 50 free).

However, there was also a Q&A document released with 50 general questions about the new framework with corresponding answers. Question #42 asks: “Why are all 50m events being removed from Swimming Canada events?”

The answer explains that Swimming Canada is focused on Olympic events and that the 50 fly, back and breast are not on the Olympic program. “Swimming Canada is focused on Olympic events and the 50m events in Butterfly, Backstroke and Breaststroke are not Olympic events. These events lead swimmers and coaches to focus and prepare for a set of events not on the Olympic program.” 

Their answer seemed unclear as to which meets would be removing 50’s, but we have heard that it is just Junior Nationals.

It also explains that the 50m events favor swimmers who mature early, as their strength benefits them in the shorter events. This then leads to them focusing on swimming these events based on their strength and not their technical skills. “Through some of the statistics we have gathered, there is a noticed lack of development in distance swimming and this partly shows that Canada is overly focused on sprint events. 50m events do favour early maturing swimmers who tend to focus on swimming these events based on their strength and maturation and not, due to technical skills developed. This leads to swimmers not building the appropriate aerobic base in the key developmental years.”

At the end it goes on to say that after reviewing results of the Canadian Age Group Championships since they began in 2006, there has been a very low number of 50m stroke winners to go on to represent Canada at the Olympics or World Championships. It also mentions that 12 of the 13 winners also won an event 100m or more. With this data they come to the conclusion that the 50m stroke events haven’t had an impact on developing world-class swimmers over 10 years (with one exception). “In reviewing the results of the Canadian Age Championships since its inception in 2006 there have only been 13 winners in 50m stroke (non-free) events that have gone on to represent Canada at the Olympic Games or World Championships. Twelve of these 13 winners also 12 12 won a 100m+ event at the Age Championships. With only one exception over a 10-year period, the 50m stroke (non-free) events have not had impact on developing world-class swimmers.”

To find the full Competition Framework document, click here. To find the corresponding question and answer document, click here.

19
Leave a Reply

Subscribe
Notify of

19 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
CDN Parent
7 years ago

I don’t think it’s just a proposed change; the time standards for next year are already on Swim Canada and there are no longer any QT’s for stroke 50’s for the CJC’s. Not sure how this will affect the whole ‘need three qualifying times’. They have also removed the 18 year old females from the meet. https://www.swimming.ca/content/uploads/2015/10/2017-standards-revised-final.pdf

Jiggs
7 years ago

Why stop there? They should get rid of breaststroke altogether.

Kirk Nelson
Reply to  Jiggs
7 years ago

Great idea! The statistics show that most Olympic medalists in breaststroke have only won medals in breaststroke. This clearly proves that swimming breast has no impact on developing world-class swimmers in other, faster, strokes. 😉

Irish Ringer
Reply to  Kirk Nelson
7 years ago

Most breaststrokers are on trick ponies ????

Cynthia mae Curran
Reply to  Kirk Nelson
7 years ago

Not true, Amanda Beard had a gold in 200 meter breaststroke and a sliver in 200 I.m. at the 2004 Olympics Many breaststrokes are good at IM. Catilyn Leventz started out as a breaststroke. Margilis is also an Imer and Breastsroker. You need to have a decent breaststroke to win IM even Michael Phelps improved on his weakness stroke.

Bob
7 years ago

Olympics need to include all the 50s or remove the 50 free. Swimming needs to evolve and move away from the free bias.

Ramp it up!
7 years ago

How about the idea that 50’s are fun and exciting? How about the idea that many swimmers and spectators like them? How about the idea that Age Group swimmers are still developing and there are specific skills to learn even in short races? How about the idea that not everyone is destined to be an Olympian?

Cynthia mae Curran
Reply to  Ramp it up!
7 years ago

Masters swimming has 50’s and the worlds does as wll. Maybe, more people would be swimming at 30 if their were the 50’s.

Jeahswim
7 years ago

Silly silly silly

Kirk Nelson
7 years ago

“In reviewing the results of the Canadian Age Championships since its inception in 2006 there have only been 13 winners in 50m stroke (non-free) events that have gone on to represent Canada at the Olympic Games or World Championships. Twelve of these 13 winners also 12 12 won a 100m+ event at the Age Championships. With only one exception over a 10-year period, the 50m stroke (non-free) events have not had impact on developing world-class swimmers.”

This seems like a logical fallacy to me. To me it simply suggests there aren’t a lot of elite swimmers who focus exclusively on the stroke 50s. This shouldn’t shock anyone. I don’t see how it suggests that the 50 stroke events don’t have… Read more »

Kirk Nelson
7 years ago

Why is “developing world-class swimmers” the standard they are using for whether or not to swim stroke 50s? This seems very narrow-minded to me.

swimdoc
7 years ago

Just so this doesn’t spill over into Masters meets.

About James Sutherland

James Sutherland

James swam five years at Laurentian University in Sudbury, Ontario, specializing in the 200 free, back and IM. He finished up his collegiate swimming career in 2018, graduating with a bachelor's degree in economics. In 2019 he completed his graduate degree in sports journalism. Prior to going to Laurentian, James swam …

Read More »