Indian Swimmer Alleges Timing Manipulation At Uzbekistan Open Championships

Indian swimmer Likith Selvaraj Prema says meet organizers at the Uzbekistan Open manipulated results to create more Olympic qualifying times. Prema is calling on FINA to investigate and take action against the organizers.

Prema competed in the meet, and says he publicly protested the timing manipulation. He published a nearly-ten-minute video to YouTube, detailing the allegations and including race video of the events in question.

“At this competition, it was quite sad and heartbreaking to see a lot of manipulation of the times in favor of the Uzbekistan swimmers,” Prema says in his video. He says the manipulation “also resulted in wrong times being recorded for Indian swimmers as well, which we never asked for.”

Prema asks FINA to launch an investigation into the meet results, calling on other swimmers to come forward as well. SwimSwam has had multiple swimmers, from both India and Uzbekistan, reach out to support the allegations.

The full video:

Allegations of Manipulation

Prema says that in several events, meet organizers shut off the scoreboard and didn’t tell athletes their times. The times eventually listed on results do not line up with race videos, Prema says.

A few of the times Prema says were manipulated, including time-stamps of the race videos Prema provides:

Men’s 100 free heats: Prema says Aleksey Tarasenko swam a 51 in prelims, but the time was changed to 48.55, giving Tarasenko the “A” cut for Olympic qualification.

Video does appear to show the top swimmer in the heat finishing around 51 seconds, and no swimmer finishing in the 48s. The final, which runs right after prelims in the video, appears to show the winner somewhere in the mid-49s.

Time-stamp – 5:07

Men’s 100 fly heats: Prema says times from the entire top 8 were manipulated, with Indian swimmer Sajan Prakash qualifying first, but being listed in third place behind two swimmers from Uzbekistan. Adilbek Yusupbaev was listed in heats results at 51.71 and Eldor Usmonov at 51.83. In the final, Prakash beat both swimmers head-to-head while swimming a much slower time (53.69).

Again, the video provided shows the two fastest swimmers in the prelims heat finishing at about 54 seconds. In the final, Prakash (in lane 3) finishes at about 53 seconds, and the video shows the blank scoreboard both during and after the race.

Time-stamp – 7:18

Prema’s Protest

Prema, a breaststroker, used one of his own events to protest the alleged manipulation of times. In the 200 breast final, he stood up on the block when the rest of the heat started swimming.

“After two minutes and five seconds, I came down, touched the touchpad and stopped my own time,” Prema says. “[I] asked the official, ‘what, is this a new world record?'”

You can see video of that race and protest below. The first clip shows the swimmers in the pool and Prema crouched on the block in the second lane from the top. The second half of the video shows Prema climbing down and hitting the touchpad.

Prema says meet organizers approached him after the protest, telling him that he didn’t understand the politics, and that meet organizers had been given instruction by “higher authorities” to send ten qualifiers from Uzbekistan into the Olympics. Prema claims the officials bribed him to keep his allegations quiet.

When Prema refused the bribe, he says meet organizers demanded he sign a letter saying he was “mentally unstable,” and that his actions on the blocks were not a protest, but the result of deafness that caused him to not hear the starter.

We’ve reached out to both FINA and the Uzbekistan swimming federation for comment, but have not yet received a response.

Update: The Uzbekistan Swimming Federation says there were some “glitches in the time counting software, but they were immediately and promptly fixed.”

The federation called Prema’s allegations “unfounded and unsubstantiated,” saying that the meet included athletes from Afghanistan, Turkmenistan and India, and no official representatives of those teams had any protests or complaints, and that no teams filed a protest to the meet’s chief referee.

“Regarding the videos of the swims published by Likit Prema, no amateur-made videos can be a basis for accusations of manipulating the results,” the federation told SwimSwam, claiming that the “swims featured in this video are not the swims in question in the indictment by the Indian athlete.”

47
Leave a Reply

Subscribe
Notify of
47 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Monteswim
3 months ago

This is WILD

gkjhdslks
Reply to  Monteswim
3 months ago

One dislike on every comment from…. well I would say but they told me to say I couldn’t write

Waterbear13
3 months ago

I gotta think what is the benefit to qualifying swimmers to the Olympics with doctored times? They’re just going to bomb in the Olympic Preliminaries, dashing any hopes of an Uzbekistan finalist/medalist.

Xman
Reply to  Waterbear13
3 months ago

Leader of the country says he wants swimmers at the Olympics. Whoever is in charge of coaching the swimmers decided it was a good idea to listen.

Pretty simple

Dora
Reply to  Xman
3 months ago

It was not the leader of the country. Likith is referring to Uzbekistan Olympic Committee who said we need more swimmers to qualify for OG. And the federation promised them 7 A cuts so they had to get those qualifications in any way possible, so they save their asses and the budget for the team.

German swimmer
Reply to  Waterbear13
3 months ago

money from higher state sport organizations, definitely a “motivation” to fabricate some shit like this…

Last edited 3 months ago by German swimmer
Dan
Reply to  Waterbear13
2 months ago

One of the problems is that they only allow a certain number of swimmers so that would mean someone else would not qualify.

swammer
3 months ago

Standing on the blocks for 2 minutes as a result of his deafness? Cˋmon meet organizers, at least come up with something better.
It would sound like April fools to me if it wasnˋt so sad.

Daaaave
3 months ago

Surely more to come from this, but if this played out as reported above I really admire this guy for sticking to his principles, sacrificing his own swim which he trained for, and speaking out against those in power in a foreign jurisdiction–not without risk!

GATOR CHOMP 🐊
3 months ago

Finally someone has spoken out about this. Hopefully it is not ignored

GowdyRaines
3 months ago

Bold move to doctor Tarasenko’s LCM 100 free to be faster than his SCM 100 free national record…

https://swimswam.com/uzbekistan-record-holder-aleksey-tarasenko-transfers-from-iowa-to-tennessee/

Taa
Reply to  GowdyRaines
3 months ago

If he participated in the ruse he shouldn’t be allowed in the NCAAs. Kick him off the team asap

Xman
Reply to  Taa
3 months ago

He probabaly showed up and didn’t really have a choice.

Ushy
Reply to  Xman
3 months ago

You always have a choice

PVSFree
Reply to  Ushy
3 months ago

I mean, he may not have known about it beforehand, this seems like something that came up from higher up

Dim
Reply to  PVSFree
3 hours ago

All about everything knew perfectly. And the athletes themselves knew for which of them would fake the result. Then in the news they wrote that they were qualified.

Taa
Reply to  Xman
3 months ago

You might be right. So maybe just make him sit out the fall semester. He has to have some repurcussions more than just swim a few 400IMs at the end of practice.

Pabalo Ricarditi
Reply to  Taa
3 months ago

swimming is not a punishment & shame on you for ever thinking it should be.

Alo
Reply to  Xman
3 months ago

Uzbekistan’s government is practically unchanged since the Soviet era … the alternative choice may have been a bit more unpleasant

Taa
3 months ago

its the old Liberty system they probably sold it on the black market

Swimmer
3 months ago

Wondering if some swimmers actually took the money

Nate
Reply to  Swimmer
3 months ago

Tarasenko has posted a story on his instagram expressing his anger and how he was manipulated, this was the day the videos went up. After a few minutes he took it down, so i guess that he got silenced with bribes or threats by the “higher authorities”

Dim
Reply to  Nate
2 hours ago

Anger .. garbage. No one manipulated against their desire. Everyone wants to the Olympics, and even with such fake results.

About Jared Anderson

Jared Anderson

Jared Anderson swam for nearly twenty years. Then, Jared Anderson stopped swimming and started writing about swimming. He's not sick of swimming yet. Swimming might be sick of him, though. Jared was a YMCA and high school swimmer in northern Minnesota, and spent his college years swimming breaststroke and occasionally pretending …

Read More »