Indian Coach Calls Asian Games Entry Time Error ‘A National Travesty’

As originally reported by ESPN, there was more to the story of how the Indian swimmers fared at the 2018 Asian Games than their lack of medals.

The country ultimately failed to reach the podium while breaking eight National Records and reaching the final in ten events, but an error in submitting their entry times has led to a backlash from their coaching staff.

The entry times for the Indian swimmers apparently were not sent to the Games organizers in time for the competition, which ultimately left the swimmers to swim without an entry time and thus in the slowest seeded heats.

“It’s a national travesty. That’s what it is. Our swimmers were forced to swim alongside the slowest and they had no one to pace against. It severely affected our chances,” said National coach Nihar Ameen.

Ameen is adamant that the Swimming Federation of India (SFI) sent the swimmers’ entry times to the Indian Olympic Association (IOA) well in advance of the Games.

“I am absolutely certain that the Swimming Federation of India (SFI) had forwarded the entry timings but not quite certain about what happened after that,” he says.

One of the many examples is the men’s 50 breast, where Sandeep Sejwal swam a time of 27.95 in heat 1, over seven seconds quicker than the next fastest swimmer in the heat. Sejwal did end up qualifying for the final, where he placed 7th, but the Indian staff does believe the error cost them a few medals and additional spots in finals.

Coach Pradeep Kumar said that they only realized there was a problem on the eve of competition.

“We were shocked to see that our swimmers weren’t on the list. We rushed to the organizers requesting if changes could be made. But it was too close to the competition, everything was up on the website and the heat sheets were printed so they said it was too last-minute to change anything.

“When our swimmers heard this they were absolutely demotivated, but they had no choice. Once the events began, they perhaps just got used to it. Had this not happened, we would have at least made two more finals and won two medals.”

Srihari Nataraj, who broke all three Indian Records in the backstroke events at the Games, including qualifying for the final in both the 100 and 200, commented on the incident, stating “It’s something (entry timings not being sent) I didn’t have any control over so I tried just to focus on what best I could do with whatever I’m given. Of course, our performances would be a lot different had we been in faster heats,” he says.

A similar situation occurred at the 2000 Olympics in Sydney, where Nisha Millet, the first Indian female swimmer to qualify for the Games, was given an incorrect entry time (2:16 instead of 2:06) and thus placed in the first heat.

VD Nanavati, the current SFI CEO, had refused to comment to ESPN on the matter.

All quotes courtesy of ESPN. You can read their full article on the incident here.

29
Leave a Reply

11 Comment threads
18 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
18 Comment authors
newest oldest most voted
NEWTOSWIMSWAM

A national travesty?? Yes all swimmers need to be correctly seeded, but India is not known for its swimming. In 2014 Asian Games, India won one bronze medal, and I am certain all swimmers were properly seeded.

Torchbearer

Swimmers work so hard, it is sad when officials let them down like this

John

The issue is not with the officials…..

25 free champ

Officials can mean more than one thing.

Torchbearer

The officials of the Indian National and Swim team…not the swimming officials at the event…

Human Ambition

But Sarah swam a 24,43 50 FLY with no pacing…. and Manadou a 22,2 50BK SCM… and all Ledeckys swims…

I’ve long thought that coaches (and parents) overvalue ‘having someone to race against.’ Everyone’s wired a little different, but in my experience as a coach, most best times are done when an athlete is way ahead of the field. Maybe the hyper-competitive athletes like Phelps tick differently, but it just doesn’t seem like that big of a deal to me. India swam pretty well in prelims, none the less. I think it disrupts the integrity of the competition to do this, so in that regard, I don’t like it. But, Indian sports are a bit of a mess. The volleyball federation was suspended for 2 years because there was an attempted coup staged, and nobody was sure which organization to… Read more »

Rjm

Rowdy would disagree.

GRUBBY_1

In practice and in competition we are always racing the clock. In every case you have to be savage and swim your best. Too bad for the seeding issue. In a big meet it throws the swimmer off psychologically from the beginning.

NEWTOSWIMSWAM

Braden – Totally agree about getting best times when a swimmer is way ahead, from the perspective of a swimmer: I have swum many best times when I was seeded in early heats when I had non-conformed times (e.g. yard time in a meter meet). In my view, this seeding issue would not change the outcome of their performance.

As for improving Indian sports, the focus should not be on such a small technicality, but rather on valuing sports participation as a nation. With its population soon exceeding China, its showing at the current Asian Games is pathetic: G/S/B = 9/8/22 vs China’s 93/63/45 as of today, even behind North Korea.

They’ve actually made recent big moves in that area. As Sanuj reported in our SS Hindi section, the country recently moved to decrease time spent in the classroom in favor of more time spent on athletics and physical activity in the school system.

Human Ambition

Rember India is great in two super big sports. Cricket and Kabaddi (they lost to Iran this year though). Kabaddi having had over 313,000,000 unique TV-viewers for the regular season.

NEWTOSWIMSWAM

“super”?? Kabaddi is a regional sport, regardless viewership, It is only popular in the Indian subcontinent and other surrounding South Asian countries, such as Pakistan and Central Asian such as Iran. Cricket is a little more popular with more participating countries.

Human Ambition

Regional as Football or Baseball you mean? But with more TV-viewers?

NEWTOSWIMSWAM

Apparently you don’t understand the word regional as i already listed the countries for you. It wastes my time to argue with someone who compares Kabaddi with football or baseball. Goodbye and hope you enjoy watching Kabaddi with 1 billion Indians.

MY MOM!

If they made the finals, who cares? They had people to race at night.

About James Sutherland

James Sutherland

James is currently a university swimmer for the Laurentian Voyageurs in Sudbury, Ontario, Canada. He is studying economics. Along with swimming, he also loves hockey. He's in his 14th season as a competitive swimmer. Best Times - SCM (LCM) 50 FR - 24.56 (25.12) 100 FR - 53.58 (56.70) 200 FR - 1:56.07 (2:04.29) 1500 …

Read More »

Don't want to miss anything?

Subscribe to our newsletter and receive our latest updates!